Bird Casualties on European Roads — A Review

Johannes Erritzoe; Tomasz D. Mazgajski; Łukasz Rejt

doi:10.3161/068.038.0204

How to translate text using browser tools

1 December 2003 Bird Casualties on European Roads — A Review

Johannes Erritzoe, Tomasz D. Mazgajski, Łukasz Rejt

Author Affiliations +

Acta Ornithologica, 38(2):77-93 (2003). https://doi.org/10.3161/068.038.0204

Abstract

Road traffic affects the natural environment in numerous ways. The most striking of these is the death of wild animals and birds as a result of collisions with moving vehicles. In this paper the available data on bird mortality on roads are reviewed. Estimates of annual mortality for some European countries (350 000 to 27 million birds), the monthly distribution of casualties, their distribution among sex and age classes, as well as the methods used in the study of this problem are presented. The species composition of birds killed in this way is compared for several countries. In western Europe sparrows and Blackbirds are the species that most frequently die on the roads, but in Central and Eastern Europe not only sparrows but also corvids and Barn Swallows make up a high proportion of the victims. Analysis of the monthly distribution of casualties in 10 species shows this to differ between countries, probably because of the geographic variation of certain aspects of their biology (migration, breeding etc.). Several factors affecting the frequency of casualties are discussed, and some suggestions for the prevention of bird casualties are also given.

REFERENCES

1.

L. Aronson 1979. The Hume's Tawny Owl Strix butleri in Israel. Dutch Birding 1: 18–20. Google Scholar

2.

C. R. Barlow , G. Gale 1999. Information gained from nine road-killed Red-necked Nightjar Caprimulgus ruficollis in the Gambia, in winters 1990–1997. Bull. African Bird Club 6: 48–51. Google Scholar

3.

M. D. Barnes 1936. The death-toll of birds on our roads. Naturalist 1936: 85–86. Google Scholar

4.

T. A. Bashta 1999. [Cars as an anthropogenic factor of birds elimination]. In: A. Bokotey (ed.). Ecological aspects of birds protection. Mat. VII Conf. Western Ukraine Ornithol. L'viv, pp. 11–12. Google Scholar

5.

M. Bartoszewicz 1997. [Mortality of vertebrates on the highway bordering on the Słońsk Reserve, western Poland]. Parki narodowe i Rezerwaty Przyrody 16: 59–69. Google Scholar

6.

C. M. Beadnell 1937. The toll of animal life exacted by modern civilisation. Proc. Zool. Soc. London 107: 173–182. Google Scholar

7.

A. F. Bennett 1991. Roads, roadsides and wildlife conservation: a review. In: D. A. Saunders , R. J. Hobbs (eds). Nature Conservation 2. The role of corridors. Surrey, Beatty & Sons, 99–117. Google Scholar

8.

C. W. Benson 1955. Nightjars on roads at night. Ibis 97: 370–371. Google Scholar

9.

A. Bereszyński 1980. [Studies on mortality of birds died on public roads]. Roczniki Akademii Rolniczej w Poznaniu 72: 2–9. Google Scholar

10.

N. N. Berezovikov 1995. [On mortality of vertebrates on the highways]. Selevinia 3: 82–85. Google Scholar

11.

H. H. Bergmann 1974. Zur Phänologie and Ökologie des Strassentodes der Vögel. Vogelwelt 95: 1–21. Google Scholar

12.

D. Bersuder , J. Caspar 1986. [Impact of the roads on local fauna]. Ciconia 10: 91–102. Google Scholar

13.

E. Bezzel 1982. Vögel in der Kulturlandschaft. Stuttgart. Google Scholar

14.

H. Blümel , R. Blümel 1980. Wirbeltiere als Opfer des Straßenverkehrs. Abh. Ber. Naturk. Mus- Forsch. Stelle Görlitz 54: 19–24. Google Scholar

15.

S. Bosch 1989. Totfunde von Greifvögeln und Eulen in Bereich des Autobahnkreuzes Weinsberg. Ornithol. Jahresh. Baden-Württ. 5: 109–111. Google Scholar

16.

J. D. Bourquin 1983. [Mortality of raptors along the route Genève-Lausanne]. Nos Oiseaux 37: 149–169. Google Scholar

17.

H. Bräutigam 1978. Vogelverluste auf einer Fernverkehrsstrasse von 1974 bis 1977 in den Kreisen Altenburg und Geithain. Orn. Mitt. 30: 147–149. Google Scholar

18.

G. J. Broekhuysen 1965. An analysis of birds casualties on the roads in the South Western Cape Province, South Africa. L'Oiseau R. F. O. 35: 35–51. Google Scholar

19.

J. Brouwer 1992. Road-kills of three nightjar species near Niamey, Niger. Malimbus 14: 16–18. Google Scholar

20.

R. J. Brown , M. N. Brown , B. Pesotto 1986. Birds killed on some secondary roads in Western Australia. Corella 10: 118–122. Google Scholar

21.

J. Bruun-Schmidt 1994. [Traffic killed animals in relation to landscape, topography and type of road]. Upubliceret specialerapport, Odense Universitet, Biologisk Institut. Google Scholar

22.

R. M. Case 1978. Interstate highway road-killed animals: a date source for biologists. Wildlife Soc. Bull. 6: 8–13. Google Scholar

23.

B. Coleman 1968. Common Gulls and Blackbirds feeding on road casualties. British Birds 61: 227. Google Scholar

24.

G. Creutz 1935. Strassentod. Orn. Monatschrift 60: 189–192. Google Scholar

25.

C. Ćwikowski 1997. [Dead and injured owls and diurnal raptors in Krosno province]. Badania Ornitol. Ziemi Przemyskiej 5: 57–64. Google Scholar

26.

S. Dale 2001. Necrophilic behaviour, corpses as nuclei for resting flock formation, and road-kills of Sand Martins Riparia riparia. Ardea 89: 545–547. Google Scholar

27.

M. S. Dhindsa , J. S. Sandhu , H. S. Toor 1988. Roadside birds in Punjab (India): Relation to mortality from vehicles. Environ. Conserv. 15: 303–310. Google Scholar

28.

L. M. Dickerson 1939. The problem of wildlife destruction by carmobile traffic. J. Wildl. Manage. 3: 104–116. Google Scholar

29.

H. R. Dill 1926. Is the carmobile exterminating the woodpecker? Science 63: 69–70. Google Scholar

30.

A. A. Dunthorn , F. P. Errington 1964. Casualties among birds along a selected road in Wiltshire. Bird Study 11: 168–182. Google Scholar

31.

F. P. Errington 1971. Bird deaths on roads. Ibis 113: 416. Google Scholar

32.

J. Erritzøe 1999. Causes of mortality in the Long-eared Owl Asio otus. Dansk Ornitologisk Forenings Tidskrift 93: 162–164. Google Scholar

33.

I. Fajardo , V. Pividal , M. Trigo , M. Jiménez 1998. Habitat selection, activity peaks and strategies to avoid road mortality by the Little Owl Athene noctua. Alauda 66: 49–60. Google Scholar

34.

P. Feindt , H. Göttgens 1967. Überwintrende Rote Milane (Milvus milvus) in Süd-Niedersachsen an ihren Sammel-Schlaf- und Nährungsplätzen. Vogelwelt 88: 8–19. Google Scholar

35.

S. A. Fetisov 1990. [On the death of birds on the motor patch of the Pskov region]. Vestn. Leningr. Univ. Biol. 20: 26. Google Scholar

36.

R. G. Finnis 1960. Road casualties among birds. Bird Study 7: 21–32. Google Scholar

37.

W. P. Flint 1926. The automobile and wild life. Science 63: 426–27. Google Scholar

38.

R. T. T. Forman 1995. Land mosaics. The ecology of landscapes and regions. Cambridge Univ. Press. Google Scholar

39.

R. T. T. Forman , L. E. Alexander 1998. Roads and their major ecological effects. Annu. Rev. Ecol. Syst. 29: 207–231. Google Scholar

40.

U. Fuellhaas , C. Klemp , A. Kordes , H. Ottersber , M. Pirmann , A. Thiessen , C. Tshoetschel , H. Zucchi 1989. Untersuchungen zum Strassentod von Vögeln, Säugetieren, Amphibien und Reptilien. Beiträge Naturkunde Niedersachsens 42: 129–147. Google Scholar

41.

T. Gollob , W. M. Pulich 1978: Lapland Longspur casualties in Texas. Bull. Texas Orn. Soc. 11: 44–46. Google Scholar

42.

A. Goławski , S. Goławska 2002. [Mortality of birds on the local roads in the environs of Siedlce]. Notatki Ornitol. 43: 270–275. Google Scholar

43.

G. Göransson , J. Karlsson , A. Lindgren 1978. [Influence of roads on the surrounding nature. II. Fauna]. Rapport från Statens Naturvårdsverk. Google Scholar

44.

J. R. Govett 1960. Mortality of wild birds on roads. Naturalist 872: 5–6. Google Scholar

45.

U. Günther 1979. Eine Untersuchung zur Frage der Gefährdung unserer Vogelwelt durch des Straßenverkehr. Thüringer Ornithologische Mitteilungen 25: 3–14. Google Scholar

46.

W. Haas 1964. Verluste von Vögeln und Säugern auf Carstrassen. Orn. Mitt. 16: 245–250. Google Scholar

47.

A. H. Hadley 1927. Wild life and carmobiles. Bird Lore 29: 391–392. Google Scholar

48.

L. Hansen 1969. [Roadkill of Danish vertebrates]. Dansk Ornitologisk Forenings Tidskrift 63: 81–92. Google Scholar

49.

L. Hansen 1982. [Roadkills in Denmark]. Dansk Ornitologisk Forenings Tidskrift 76: 97–110. Google Scholar

50.

B. D. Harding 1979. Road mortality of swifts. Brit. Birds 72: 392. Google Scholar

51.

T. Harrisson 1954. Nightjars sitting on roads at night. Ibis 96: 626. Google Scholar

52.

F. Haverschmidt 1955. Nightjars sitting on roads at night. Ibis 97: 371–372. Google Scholar

53.

J. Havlin 1987. Motorways and birds. Folia Zoologica 36: 137–153. Google Scholar

54.

D. Heinrich 1978. Untersuchungen zur Verkehrsopferrate bei Säugetieren und Vögeln. Die Heimat 85: 193–208. Google Scholar

55.

M. Hernandez 1988. Road mortality of the Little Owl (Athene noctua) in Spain. J. Raptor Res. 22: 81–84. Google Scholar

56.

J. Herz 1970. [Loses caused to vertebrates by automobile traffic]. Ochrana Fauny 4: 178–184. Google Scholar

57.

N. L. Hodson 1960. A survey of vertebrate road mortality. Bird Study 7: 224–231. Google Scholar

58.

N. L. Hodson 1962. Some notes on the causes of bird casualties. Bird Study 9: 168–173. Google Scholar

59.

N. L. Hodson 1966. Some notes on the habits of roadside carrion feeders. Bird Study 13: 272–273. Google Scholar

60.

N. L. Hodson , D. W. Snow 1965. The road deaths enquiry, 1960–61. Bird Study 12: 90–99. Google Scholar

61.

V. Holisová , R. Obrtel 1986. Vertebrate casualties on a Moravian Road. Acta Sc. Nat. Brno 20: 1–44. Google Scholar

62.

Jones P. Hope 1980. Bird scavengers on Orkney roads. British Birds 73: 561–568. Google Scholar

63.

H. Illner 1992. Road deaths of Westphalian owls: methodological problems, influence of road type and possible effects on population levels. In: C. A. Galbraith , I. R. Taylor , S. Percival (eds). The ecology and conservation of European owls. UK Nat. Conserv. 5, Peterborough, pp. 94–100. Google Scholar

64.

D. J. Jefferies 1975. Different activity patterns of male and female badgers (Meles meles) as shown by road mortality. J. Zool. 177: 504–506. Google Scholar

65.

B. Jensen 1996. 11 [11 years registration of road-killed larger mammals and birds in central Zealand]. Flora og Fauna 101: 65–70. Google Scholar

66.

P. N. Johnson 1989. Annual avian and mammalian traffic mortality along a South Yorkshire road. Naturalist (Leeds) 114: 99–101. Google Scholar

67.

D. A. Jonkers , Vries G. W. de 1977. Verkeersslachtoffers under de Fauna. Zeist. Nederlandse Vereningen tot Bescherming van Vogels, Zeist. Google Scholar

68.

G. B. Joselyn , J. E. Warnock , S. L. Etter 1969. Wildlife — an essential consideration determining future highway roadside maintenance policy. Highway Research Record 280. Google Scholar

69.

A. N. Khokhlov 1991. [New data on bird loss on roads of the Stavropol Territory]. In: [Actual problems of ecology and conservation of nature of the Stavropol Territory and adjoining territories: Mat. Conf.]. Stavropol, pp. 165–169. Google Scholar

70.

A. N. Khokhlov , N. A Khokhlov 1998. [On bird mortality on road “Stavropol town-Podlesnoye settlement” in winter 1997/98]. Kavkazskiy orn. Vestnik, Stavropol State Univ.Press, pp. 156–157. Google Scholar

71.

K. Korhonen , L. Nurminen 1987. Traffic deaths of animals on the Kuopio-Siilinjarvi Highway in eastern Finland. Aquilo Ser. Zool. 25: 9–16. Google Scholar

72.

V. A. Kovalev 1998. [On the death of birds on roads]. In: V. N. Grishchenko (ed.). Mat. III Conf. Young Ukrainian Ornithol. Chernivtsi, pp. 70–71. Google Scholar

73.

J. M. Linsdale 1929. Roadways as they affect bird life. Condor 31: 143–145. Google Scholar

74.

T. Lodé 2000. Effect of a motorway on mortality and isolation of wildlife populations. Ambio 29: 163–166. Google Scholar

75.

M. Lüpke 1983. Vogelverluste an einer Fernverkehrsstrasse. Falke 30: 58–60. Google Scholar

76.

H. E. McClure 1951. An analysis of animal victims on Nebraska's highways. J. Wildl. Manage. 15: 410–20. Google Scholar

77.

A. B. Madsen , H. W. Fyhn , A. Prang 1998. [Traffic killed animals in a landschaft ecological planning and research]. Danmarks Miljøundersøgelser. Faglig Rap. DMU 228. Google Scholar

78.

J. Martens 1962. Gefährdung der Vogelwelt durch Kraftwagen. Orn. Mitt. 14: 221. Google Scholar

79.

C. Mason , S. MacDonald 1995. Corvids feeding on carrion. Bird Study 42: 255–256. Google Scholar

80.

S. Massemin , Y. Hendrich 1997. Higher winter mortality of the Barn Owl compared to the Long-eared owl and the Tawny Owl: influence of lipid reserves and insulation. Condor 99: 969–971. Google Scholar

81.

S. Massemin , Y. Le Maho , Y. Hendrich 1998. Seasonal pattern in age, sex and body condition of Barn owls Tyto alba killed on motorways. Ibis 140: 70–75. Google Scholar

82.

S. Massemin , T. Zorn 1998. Highway mortality of barn owls in northeastern France. J. Raptor Res. 32: 229–232. Google Scholar

83.

G. M. Meade 1942. Calcium chloride — a death lure for crossbills. Auk 59: 439–40. Google Scholar

84.

R. Meinertzhagen 1954. Grit. Bull. Brit. Orn. Club 74: 97–102. Google Scholar

85.

A. Müller 1995. Vogelverluste durch den Straßenverkehr in Abhängigkeit von der Jahreszeit. Beitr. Gefiederkunde und Morphologie der Vögel 2: 47–54. Google Scholar

86.

D. N. Nankinov , N. M. Todorov 1983. Bird casualties on highways. Sov. J. Ecol. 14: 288–293. Google Scholar

87.

R. W. Nero , H. W. R. Copland 1981. High mortality of Great Gray Owls in Monitoba — winter 1980–81. Blue Jay 39: 158–165. Google Scholar

88.

V. O. Novak 1995. [The birds death on the main roads of Podilya]. In: [Problems of study and protection of birds]. Mat. VI Conf. Western Ukraine Ornithol. Lviv-Chernivtsi, pp. 99–100. Google Scholar

89.

W. Odzuck 1975. Im bayerischen Alpenvorland durch den Straßenverkehr getötete Wirbeltiere. Natur und Mensch 17: 153–158. Google Scholar

90.

R. Oeser 1977. Der Fichtenkreuzschnabel (Loxia curvirostra L.) als Opfer des Straßenverkehrs im Fichtenberggebiet. Beitr. Vogelkd. 23: 278–280. Google Scholar

91.

E. Osieck 1973. Groot aantal Kepen (Fringilla montifringilla L.) slachtoffer van het verkeer in winter 1970–1971. Het Vogeljaar 21: 274. Google Scholar

92.

W. Pickles 1942. Animal mortality on three miles of Yorkshire roads. J. Animal Ecol. 11: 37–3. Google Scholar

93.

Z. Przybylski 1979. The effect of carmobile exhaust gases on the arthropods of cultivated plants, meadows and orchards. Environ. Pollution 19: 157–161. Google Scholar

94.

J. Ptaszyk 1979. [Negative effect of chemization, mechanization and communication on birds]. Chrońmy Przyrodę Ojczystą 35: 52–59. Google Scholar

95.

G. Quadrelli 1984. [Birds killed by traffic]. Riv. Ital. Orn. Milano 54: 77–80. Google Scholar

96.

E. Quene , J. Grotenhuis 1994. [Bird casualties on roads in the province of Drenthe: an update]. Drentse Vogels 7: 73–81. Google Scholar

97.

D. J. Ramsden 2003. Barn Owls and major roads: results and recommendations rom a 15-year research project. The Barn Owl Trust, Ashburton. Google Scholar

98.

M. Räty 1979. Effect of highway traffic on tetraonid densities. Ornis Fennica 56: 169–170. Google Scholar

99.

M. J. S. M. Reijnen , J. B. M. Thiessen 1987. Effects from road traffic on breeding bird populations in woodland. Annual Report 1986: 121–132. Google Scholar

100.

R. Reijnen , R. Foppen 1991. Effect of road traffic on the breeding site-tenacity of male Willow Warblers (Phylloscopus trochilus). J. Ornithol. 132: 291–195. Google Scholar

101.

R. Reijnen , R. Foppen 1994. The effect of car traffic on breeding bird populations in woodland. I. Evidence of reduced habitat quality for Willow Warblers (Phylloscopus trochilus) breeding close to a highway. J. Appl. Ecol. 31: 85–94. Google Scholar

102.

R. Reijnen , R. Foppen , C. T. Braak , J. Thissen 1995. The effects of car traffic on breeding bird populations in woodland. III. Reduction of density in relation to the proximity of main roads. J. Appl. Ecol. 32: 18. Google Scholar

103.

K. Rettig 1965. Tierverluste auf Autostrassen. Orn. Mitt. 17: 233–234. Google Scholar

104.

McB. J. Robertson 1930: Roads and birds. Condor 32: 142–146. Google Scholar

105.

Yu. F. Rohovyi 1998. [On the death of birds on roads]. In: V. N. Grishchenko Mat. III Conf. Young Ukrainian Ornithol. Chernivtsi, pp. 123–126. Google Scholar

106.

G. M. Salnikov , S. V. Buslayev 1986. [The birds mortality on roads of Ivanovo Region]. In: [Study of birds of the USSR, their conservation and wise management]. Leningrad, pp. 222–223. Google Scholar

107.

A. B. Sargeant , J. E. Forbes 1973. Mortality among birds, mammals and certain snakes on 17 miles of Minnesota roads. Loon 45: 4–7. Google Scholar

108.

W. Schoenemann 1977. Wildunfälle im Strassenverkehr. Zool. Beiträge 23: 169–219. Google Scholar

109.

T. G. Scott 1938. Wildlife mortality on Iowa's highways. Am. Midland Nat. 20: 527–539. Google Scholar

110.

H. C. Seibert , J. H. Conover 1991. Mortality of Vertebrates and Invertebrates on an Athens County, Ohio Highway. Ohio Journal of Science 91: 163–166. Google Scholar

111.

A. Seller 2001. Ecological effects of roads. A review. Introductory Reasearch Essay no 9. Dept. Conserv. Biol., SLU, Uppsala. Google Scholar

112.

S. K. Sharma 1988. Bird casualties in road accidents. J. Bombay Nat. Hist. Soc. 85: 195–197 Google Scholar

113.

F. Slater 1994. Wildlife road casualties. British Wildlife 5: 214–221. Google Scholar

114.

H. W. Smettan 1988. Wirbeltiere und Strassenverkehr — ein ökologischer Beitrag zum Strassentod von Säugern und Vögeln am Beispiel von Ostfildern/Württemberg. Ornithologische Jahreshefte für Baden-Württemberg 4: 29–55. Google Scholar

115.

H. Straube 1988. Tiere am Strassenrand. Collurio 5: 28–39. Google Scholar

116.

P. A. Stewart 1971. Persistence of remains of birds killed on motor highways. Wilson Bull. 83: 203–204. Google Scholar

117.

D. Stoner 1925. The toll of the carmobile. Science 61: 56–57. Google Scholar

118.

G. M. Sutton 1927a. Mortality among Screech Owls of Pennsylvania. Auk 44: 563–564. Google Scholar

119.

G. M. Sutton 1927b. Snowy Owl killed by carmobile. Auk 44: 564. Google Scholar

120.

S. Svensson 1998. Birds kills on roads: is this mortality factor seriously underestimated? Ornis Svecica 8: 183–187. Google Scholar

121.

R. Tabor 1974. Earthworms, crows, vibrations and motorways. New Scientist 62: 482–483. Google Scholar

122.

V. I. Telegin , N. G. Ivleva 1983. [Birds on roads]. In: [Birds of Siberia], Gorno-Altaysk, pp. 256–257. Google Scholar

123.

K. Thomsen 1992. [Project game register]. Rapport for Falck Danmark. Google Scholar

124.

S. C. Trombulak , C.A. Frisseil 2000. Review of ecological effects of roads on terrestrial and aquatic communities. Conserv. Biol. 14: 18–30. Google Scholar

125.

K. Uhlenhaut 1976. Unfalle von Schleiereulen durch Kraftfahrzeuge. Falke 21: 56–60. Google Scholar

126.

J. E. Underhill , P. G. Angold 2000. Effects of roads on wildlife in an intensively modified landscape. Environ. Rev. 8: 21–39. Google Scholar

127.

G. Valkiunas 1998. Haematozoa of wild birds: peculiarities in their distribution and pathogenicity. Bull. Skand. Soc. Parasitol. 8: 39–16. Google Scholar

128.

W. J. M. Vestjens 1973. Wildlife mortality on a road in New South Wales. Emu 73: 107–112. Google Scholar

129.

J. C. Vignes 1984. [Birds casualities on roads in Pays]. Oiseaux 54: 137–148. Google Scholar

130.

S. Wäscher , A. Janisch , M. Sattler 1988. Verkehrstrassen-Todesfallen der Avifauna. Luscinia 46: 41–55. Google Scholar

131.

P. C. Whitford 1985. Bird behavior in response to the warmth of blacktop roads. Trans. Wis. Acad. Sci. Arts. Lett. 73: 135–143. Google Scholar

132.

P. Williamson , P. R. Evans 1972. Lead: Levels of roadside invertebrates and small mammals. Bull. Environ. Contam. Toxicol. 8: 280–288. Google Scholar

133.

K. Wołk 1978. [The animals killed by motor vehicles in the Scenic Reserve in the Białowieża Primeval Forest]. Chrońmy Przyrodę Ojczystą 34: 20–29. Google Scholar

134.

A. N. van der Zande , W J. ter Keurs , W. J. van der Weijden 1980. The impact of roads on the densities of four bird species in an open field habitat: evidence of a long distance effect. Biol. Conserv. 18: 299–321. Google Scholar

135.

V. A. Zhumaniyazov , G. V. Fesenko 1995. [The analysis of birds death on the main roads in Lubny district of Poltava Region]. Mat. VI Conf. Western Ukraine Ornithol. L'viv-Chernivtsi, pp. 58–60. Google Scholar

136.

D. C. Zumeta , R. T. Holmes 1978. Habitat shift and roadside mortality of Scarlet Tanagers during a cold wet New England spring. Wilson Bull 90: 575–586. Google Scholar

Citation Download Citation

Johannes Erritzoe, Tomasz D. Mazgajski, and Łukasz Rejt "Bird Casualties on European Roads — A Review," Acta Ornithologica 38(2), 77-93, (1 December 2003). https://doi.org/10.3161/068.038.0204

Received: 1 March 2003; Accepted: 1 November 2003; Published: 1 December 2003

Access the abstract

JOURNAL ARTICLE
17 PAGES

DOWNLOAD PAPER + SAVE TO MY LIBRARY