Psychosocial factors, particularly social stress, may compromise reproduction. However, some individuals may be more susceptible to socially induced infertility. The present study used group-housed, adult, ovariectomized rhesus monkeys to test the hypothesis that exposure to psychosocial stress, imposed by social subordination, would enhance estradiol (E2)-negative feedback inhibition of LH. Because polymorphisms in the gene encoding the serotonin transporter (SLC6A4) may contribute to individual differences in response to adverse environments, we determined whether subordinate females with the short-promoter-length allele (s-variant) would show greater suppression of LH. Subordinate females, particularly those with the s-variant SLC6A4 genotype, received significantly higher rates of noncontact aggression from more dominant cage mates and had consistently lower body weights. Serum LH was not influenced by social status in the absence of E2. In contrast, subordinate females were hypersensitive to E2-negative feedback inhibition of LH. Furthermore, serum LH in subordinate females with s-variant SLC6A4 genotype was maximally suppressed by Day 4 of treatment, whereas nadir concentrations were not reached until later in treatment in other females. Finally, pharmacological elevation of serum cortisol potentiated E2-negative feedback inhibition in all females. The current data suggest that infertility induced by psychosocial stressors may be mediated by hypersensitivity to E2-negative feedback and that polymorphisms in the SLC6A4 gene may contribute to differences in reproductive compromise in response to chronic stress.