In Upper Guinea in Africa three species of Triclisia Benth. (Menispermaceae) are recognized: T. dictyophylla Diels, T. patens Oliv. and T. subcordata Oliv. Triclisia dictyophylla and T. subcordata, as delimited in the revision of this genus by Troupin (1962), each include more than one distinct species. On the basis of a comparative morphological analysis, T. dictyophylla is split here into T. dictyophylla s.s. and T. gilletii (De Wild.) Staner and T. subcordata is split into T. angolensis Exell, T. hypochrysea Diels and T. subcordata s.s. No new names have to be published. Illustrations are provided along with distribution maps.
Version of record first published online on 9 November 2017 ahead of inclusion in December 2017 issue.
Triclisia Benth. is a genus of Menispermaceae with c. 16 liana species endemic to Africa including Madagascar; all species are dioecious. In Upper Guinea (sensu White 1979), three species are recognized: T. dictyophylla Diels, T. patens Oliv, and T. subcordata Oliv. (Hawthorne & Jongkind 2006). Only T. patens is endemic to Upper Guinea. In Upper Guinea the male flowers and fruits of T. dictyophylla, T. patens and T. subcordata are clearly different from each other. Triclisia dictyophylla has male flowers with six stamens (Fig. 1A–E) and almost glabrous fruit carpels of 3–4.5 × 2.5–3.5 cm, while T. patens has male flowers with only three stamens (Fig. 1H–M, Fig. 2) and pubescent fruits 1–2 cm in diameter. The third species, T. subcordata, has male flowers with six stamens (Fig. 3) and is smaller than the other two in habit, leaf, inflorescence, flower and fruit (Table 1).
Part of the herbarium specimens from outside Upper Guinea, included in Triclisia dictyophylla and T. subcordata in the last revision of the African Menispermaceae (Troupin 1962), have flower and fruit characters that are clearly different from those in Upper Guinea. Because of that, these two species are re-evaluated here. Three species, T. angolensis Exell, T. gilletii (De Wild.) Staner and T. hypochrysea Diels, which were earlier made synonym by Troupin, are resurrected here as a result.
This paper is a first step to a new revision of Triclisia for continental Africa. More problems have to be solved before a complete revision can be published. Several more Triclisia species, in the way they are used by Troupin (1962) in his revision of the Menispermaceae for Africa, are clearly a mixture. Solving the complete Tri1 clisia puzzle is hampered by several accepted names that are only represented by incomplete collections.
Summary of diagnostic characters for the species of Triclisia treated here.
Material and methods
The morphological characters of all continental African Triclisia species in the BM, BR, K, P and WAG herbaria were studied and the three Upper Guinean species were also studied in the field. The herbaria are indicated by the international code registered in Index Herbariorum (Thiers 2017+). The African Plant Database (2015+) was checked for more information on the species and the genus. The distribution maps are based only on herbarium specimens.
When specimens of Triclisia dictyophylla from all over its distribution area are compared, conspicuous differences in the shape and size of flowers and fruit carpels can be seen. The exceptional large, for Triclisia, fruit carpels from the specimens west of Cameroon were already described by Keay & Troupin (1954: 71, as T. gilletii). In publications on Central Africa the fruit carpels of the same species were described by Troupin (1951: 216, fig. 17; 1962: 91) as being about half that size and ending in a conspicuous beak. Both descriptions are correct for the specimens of that area. It is clear that Troupin included two species in T. dictyophylla with conspicuously different fruits and flowers. The species involved are T. dictyophylla s.s., from Guinea to Angola, with small flowers (Fig. 1A–E) and large fruit carpels (Fig. 5), and T. gilletii, from Cameroon, Central African Republic, Gabon, Congo Kinshasa and Angola, with large flowers (Fig. 1F, G) and relatively small fruit carpels (Fig. 6) (see also Table 1). The fruits of T. dictyophylla are usually found on the bigger stems closer to the forest floor while the fruits of T. gilletii are often found on the smaller branches. Triclisia gilletii is the only Triclisia species with fruit carpels that are conspicuously beaked. This beak was also mentioned by Exell (1935: 8) for T. flava Exell, here a synonym of T. gilletii.
Another name presented by Troupin as synonym of Triclisia dictyophylla, T. trichantha Diels from Cameroon, cannot be placed yet with certainty; it might not be a Triclisia species.
In the Flora of West Tropical Africa (Keay & Troupin 1954: 72), Triclisia subcordata was still restricted to Ghana, Togo, Benin and Nigeria, but was later united by Troupin with T. angolensis Exell from Angola and T. hypochrysea Diels from Gabon (Troupin 1962: 86). This lumping does not seem correct because the flowers and fruits from T. subcordata s.s. and T. angolensis are clearly different. The type and only known specimen of T. hypochrysea, the third species included by Troupin in T. subcordata, is sterile.
Triclisia angolensis and T. subcordata s.s. (Table 1) are in fact distinct species. The innermost sepals in the male flower of T. angolensis are more than twice as long as wide (Exell 1926: 13), while these sepals in T. subcordata s.s. (Fig. 3C–G) are almost equal in length and width (Keay & Troupin 1954: 71). The fruit carpel and endocarp of T. subcordata s.s. are also conspicuously different from those of T. angolensis and from all other species in the genus. To show this, these fruit characters are illustrated here for five different Triclisia species, including four T. subcordata s.s. examples from different countries (Fig. 4). The shape of the fruit carpel and endocarp of T. angolensis is more or less equal to that of most other species of the genus, with the style relatively close to the stipe (Fig. 4A1–3). The orientation of the endocarp in the fruit carpel of T. subcordata s.s. is different from that in all the other Triclisia species, resulting in a style that is situated almost opposite to the stipe (Fig. 4B–E, Fig. 7).
There is a large geographical gap between Triclisia angolensis and T. subcordata s.s. The type and only specimen of T. hypochrysea, the third species included by Troupin, was collected in between the areas of these other two species (Fig. 10). This type specimen is sterile and the leaf shape and indumentum do not link it to T. angolensis or to T. subcordata, making it hard to place this species. In the protologue, Diels keyed out T. hypochrysea using the characters of the flowers (Diels 1910: 69, 71), which is surprising because in the same publication he wrote that his type and only specimen is sterile. Mildbraed 8726 from Cameroon, a specimen with flower buds also cited by Troupin under T. subcordata, might belong to T. hypochrysea. Looking at indumentum and leaf shape, there could also be a connection with T. lucida Exell & Mendonça from Angola.
After separating Triclisia subcordata, T. angolensis and T. hypochrysea, T. subcordata is here restricted to West Africa again, it is found from Ivory Coast to Nigeria (Fig. 10). There it is found only in drier forest types such as semi-deciduous forest (Hall & Swaine 1981: 310). Triclisia angolensis is again endemic to the north of Angola. Only a few herbarium specimens of T. angolensis exist but, according to Exell (1926: 13), it was not uncommon early last century in rocky situations around Cazengo in the north of Angola.
The distribution of none of the three species from Upper Guinea goes all the way to E Africa. In the Flora of Tropical East Africa, Troupin (1956: 5–7) recognized three species of Triclisia for East Africa: T. sacleuxii (Pierre) Diels, T. sp. A (based on Faulkner 769) and T. sp. B (based on Loveridge 244). Faulkner 769 (T. sp. A) became the type of Anisocyclea blepharosepala subsp. tanzaniensis Vollesen (Vollesen 1981). Loveridge 244 (T. sp. B) in the Kew herbarium is in the present study identified as Syrrheonema fasciculatum Miers. This means that T. sacleuxii is the only species of Triclisia that is found in East Africa.
No new names have to be published here, all species have already published names. The number and names of the species in Upper Guinea stays the same: Triclisia dictyophylla, T. patens and T. subcordata.
List of species with synonyms, types and vouchers
Triclisia angolensis Exell in J. Bot. 64 (Suppl. 1): 12. 1926. — Holotype: Angola, Crianza Norte, Cazengo, Granja de S. Luis, fl., Nov 1909, Gossweiler 4892 (BM; isotypes: COI, K, LISC). — Table 1, Fig. 4A, Fig. 10.
Additional specimens seen — Angola: Cuanza Norte, proximum flumen Zenza, fr., 20 Oct 1922, Gossweiler 8435 (BM); Cuanza Norte, Cazengo, Granja de S. Luis, fl., Gossweiler 10356 (BM).
Additional specimens seen — Guinea: N'Zérékoré, Nimba Mts, fr. 11 Jul 2012, Jongkind & Bilivogui 11470 (MO, WAG). — Liberia: Grand Gedeh, Diebla, fr. 2 Jul 1947, Baldwin 6327 (K); Putu Hills, fr., 28 May 2005, Jongkind & al. 6450 (BR, G, K, WAG). — Ivory Coast: along road from Dakpadou to Sago, fl., 30 Mar 1968, Geerling & Bokdam 2349 (WAG); Sassandra, Forêt Classée Niégre, fl., 23 Mar 2000, Jongkind & al. 4679 (WAG); Sassandra, 25 km SW of Guéyo, 11., 24 Mar 1962, Leeuwenberg 3725 (K, WAG). — Ghana: Eastern Region, Asiakwa, fr., 2 Jul 1995, Harder & al. 3313 (K, MO). — Nigeria: Okomu Forest Reserve, 5 Jan 1948, Brenan & Onochie 8809 (K, P); Ijebu Prov., Omo Forest Reserve, fr., 28 Apr 1946, Tamajong FHI 16923 (K). — Cameroon: km 36 piste Yokadouma-Lomie, fr., 16 Jun 1963, Letouzey 5282 (P); c. 40 km WNW de Moloundou, fl., 16 Mar 1973, Letouzey 12117 (P). — Gabon: Nyanga, Milandou, fl., 24 Sep 1908, Le Testu 1383 (BM, P); Ngounié, upper Waka area, fl., fr., 28 Mar 2004, Wieringa & al. 5115 (BR, LBV, MO, WAG). — Congo Kinshasa: 40 km E-SE de Bomassa, fl., 27 Feb 2011, Ndolo Ebika & Koni 504 (E, WAG).
Triclisia gilletii (De Wild.) Staner in Bull. Séances Inst. Roy. Colon. Belge 4: 430. 1933 ≡ Tiliacora gilletii De Wild. in Bull. Jard. Bot. État. Bruxelles 3: 255. 1911. — ectotype (designated by Troupin 1951: 216): Congo Kinshasa, Mogandjo, 1 Jan 1906, Laurent 1876 (BR). — Table 1, Fig. 1F, G, Fig. 6, Fig. 8.
= Triclisia flava Exell in J. Bot. 64(Suppl. 1): 12. 1926. — Holotype: Angola, Maiombe, Sub-Luali, 5 May 1919, Gossweiler 8046 (BM; isotypes: COI, K, LISJC, LISU).
Additional specimens seen — Cameroon: piste Guere — Manjou, fr., 8 Feb 1961, Letouzey 3429 (P). — Central African Republic: 15 km SW de Mbaiki, fr., 14 May 1968, Badre 29 (P); Yalinga, fl., 9 Jan 1923, Le Testu 4474 (BR, P); Lobaye, fr., 5 Feb 1948, Tisserant 672 (BR, P). — Gabon: Lastoursville, 7 May 1929, Le Testu 7273 (BM, P); Lastoursville, 8 Nov 1930, Le Testu 8503 (BM, P); Moyen-Ogooué, Okano River, fl., fr., 11 Mar 2015, Simons & al. 1497 (WAG). — Congo Kinshasa: Asongo Hill, fr., 24 Jul 2011, X. van der Burgt 1510 (K); Kimuenza, fr., Nov 1956, Carlier 289 (BR, K); Kasayi Muetshi, fl., 2 Feb 1983, Casier 416 (BR); Lolifa prés Eala, fr., 17 May 1907, Coûteaux 228 (BR); km 26, route Bikoro, fr., 28 Aug 1964, Leonard 446 (BR, K, P); Kisanji, 17 Dec 1945, Renier 120 (BR); Ipamu, fr., Sep 1922, Vanderyst 12219 (BR). — Angola: Cabinda, Pango Munga, fr., Feb 1916, Gossweiler 6246 (BM, LISC); Buco Zau, fl., fr., 24 Oct 1916, Gosswelier 6785 (BM, LISC).
Known only from the sterile type specimen.
Additional specimens seen — Guinea Bissau: Região de Tombali, Cantanhez, 11 May 2000, Catarino & Bancessi 988 (LISC, WAG). — Guinea: Conakry, fl., Feb 1905, Chevalier 12077 (P); Rio Nunez, fl., Jan 1837, Heudelot 740 (G, P). — Sierra Leone: Mano, fl., Mar 1928, Deighton 1107 (K). — Liberia: Sapo NP, around Jelaytown, fr., 24 Nov 2002, Jongkind & Blyden 5401 (WAG); N of Lake Piso, fr., 22 Jul 2004, Jongkind & al. 6070 (BR, WAG); Lofa, near Ziggida, fl., 12 Feb 2010, Jongkind & al. 9461 (BR, K, WAG). — Ivory Coast: Yapo forest, fr., 21 May 1875, van den Burg 442 (WAG); along Tabou—Prolo road, fr., 10 Apr 2000, Jongkind & Assi-Yapo 5058 (WAG); between Adidjan and Grand Bassam, fl., 9 Sep 1956, J. J. de Wilde 480 (WAG). — Ghana: Eastern Region, Aiyaola Forest Reserve, fl., 24 Mar 1994, Jongkind & Nieuwenhuis 1368 (K, MO, WAG); foot of Aburi scarp, fl., 27 Feb 1961, Morton A 4135 (K, WAG).
= Triclisia dielsii Hutch. & Dalziel in Bull. Misc. Inform. Kew. 1927: 155. 1927. — Holotype: Togo, prope Lome, 1900/1902, Warnecke 327 (K; isotypes: B, BM, BR).
Additional specimens seen — Ivory Coast: Koffie-Yaboué, fl., fr., 17 May 1971, Audru 4174 (P); Ahouaty, fr., 24 Sep 1983, César 1809 (P); SE of Akakro, fr., 11 Apr 2015, Mertens & Jongkind 198 (BR, K). — Burkina Faso: 50 km S Foronzo, fr., 27 Mar 2007, Boko BUR 541 (K). — Ghana: Kadjebi, 18 Mar 1943, Box 3440 (K); Legon, fl., 28 Mar 1994, Jongkind & Nieuwenhuis 1381 (MO, WAG); between Tainboi and Bamboi, 15 Nov 1997, Jongkind 4032 (WAG). — Togo: Avétonou, fr., 17 Sep 1971, Breteler 7176 (WAG); Gamé, fr., 30 Sep 1971, Breteler 7199 (B, BR, MO, WAG). — Benin: Dévé, 18 Feb 1999, Essou 1474 (BR, WAG); Djègbé, fr., 9 Aug 2001, Sokpon 2232 (WAG). — Nigeria: Ibadan Distr., fr., 7 Apr 1949, Chizea FHI 24489 (K); Ibu-Iya, Upper Ogun Game Reserve, fr., 15 Sep 1971, Geerling 4194 (WAG).
The author wants to thank Hans de Vries for the line drawings and Xander van der Burgt and Jan Mertens for the use of their photos. The author also would like to thank the reviewers for their comments, which helped to improve the manuscript.
- African Plant Database 2015+ [continuously updated]: African Plant Database (version 3.4.0). Conservatoire et Jardin botaniques de la Ville de Genève and South African National Biodiversity Institute, Pretoria. — Published at http://www.ville-ge.ch/musinfo/bd/cjb/ africa/ [accessed 13 Mar 2015]. Google Scholar
- Diels L. 1910: Menispermaceae. — In: Engler A. (ed.), Das Pflanzenreich. Regni vegetabilis conspectus. IV. 94 (Heft 46). — Leipzig: Wilhelm Engelmann. Google Scholar
- Exell A. W. 1926: Mr. John Gossweiler's plants from Angola and Portuguese Congo, Dicotyledones, Part I., Polypetalae. — J. Bot. 64 (Suppl. 1): 1–24. Google Scholar
- Exell A. W. 1935: Mr. John Gossweiler's Portuguese West African plants, Dicotyledones, Menispermaceae. — J. Bot. 73 (Suppl.): 7–10. Google Scholar
- Hawthorne W. D. & Jongkind C. C. H. 2006: Woody plants of Western African forests: a guide to the forest trees, shrubs and lianes from Senegal to Ghana. — Kew: Royal Botanic Gardens. Google Scholar
- Keay R. W. J. & Troupin G. 1954: Menispermaceae. — In: Keay R. W. J. (ed.), Flora of West Tropical Africa, ed. 2, 1(1). — London: Crown Agents for Oversea Governments and Administration. Google Scholar
- Troupin G. 1951: Menispermaceae. In: Robyns W., Staner P., Demaret F., Germain R., Gilbert G., Hauman L., Homès M., Jurion F., Lebrun J., Vanden Abelle M. & Boutique R. (ed.), Flore du Congo Belge et du Ruanda-Urundi, Spermatophytes 2. — Bruxelles: I.N.E.A.C. Google Scholar
- Troupin G. 1956: Menispermaceae. — In: Turrill W. B. & Milne-Redhead E. (ed.), Flora of Tropical East Africa. — London: Crown Agents for Oversea Governments and Administration. Google Scholar
- Troupin G. 1962: Monographie des Menispermaceae Africaines. — Mém. Acad. Roy. Sci. Outre-Mer, Cl. Sci. Nat. Méd., Collect. 8vo 13(2). Google Scholar