Translator Disclaimer
1 March 2000 Age Determination by Skeletochronology of Rana nigrovittata, a Frog from Tropical Forest of Thailand
Author Affiliations +

Age in 96 individuals of a tropical frog Rana nigrovittata from Thailand was skeleto-chronologically investigated. Hematoxylinophilic lines interpreted as lines of arrested growth (LAGs) were observed clearly in the periosteal bone suggesting that this technique can be used to estimate the age of frogs from tropical Asia. The maximum age observed was nine years in males and six in females, but age structure did not differ significantly between the sexes. In the same age class, males were significantly larger than females.


Many recent studies have documented that skeleto-chronological method is applicable to determine the individual age of amphibians in nature (e.g. Hemelaar, 1988; Kusano et al., 1995a; Sagor et al., 1998). The method is based on the presence of growth layers recorded in cross-sections of long bones (Halliday and Verrell, 1988; Castanet and Smirina, 1990). This technique has been proved to be an excellent tool for investigating population age structure without sacrificing specimens (e.g., Francillon-Vieillot et al., 1990; Roger and Harvey, 1994; Kusano et al., 1995a). However, as pointed out by Halliday and Verrell (1988), there are very few studies for amphibians from tropical regions. Most of previous skeletochronological studies have ever been conducted in species from temperate regions, such as, Bufo bufo (Hemelaar, 1988), Bufo calamita (Denton and Beebee, 1993), Rana sylvatica (Bastein and Leclair, Jr., 1992), Rana tagoi (Kusano et al., 1995a), and Rana sakuraii (Kusano et al., 1995b). Much smaller numbers of studies have been made for desert species such as Bufo pentoni (Barbault et al., 1979) and Scaphiopus couchii (Tinsley and Tocque, 1995), and only a single study dealt with a mantellid, Mantidactylus micro-tympanum from the tropical rain forest of Madagascar (Guarino et al., 1998). Thus no studies have ever been made for amphibians from Asian tropics. The present study was made to examine the applicability of skeletochronological method for amphibians from tropical Asia, using a frog Rana nigrovittata from Thailand. We also studied the age structure, longevity, and growth pattern of this species on the basis of individual ages estimated.


Rana nigrovittata is widely distributed from Assam to Southern China, Vietnam, and south to Peninsular Malaysia (Frost, 1985), and inhabits on small pools, banks of rivers, small streams, and edges of lakes (Taylor, 1962).

Sampling was made in the Chachoengsao Wildlife Research Center, eastern Thailand (13°24′17″N, 101°52′17″E, alt. 30–150 m). The study area is in a mainly dry evergreen forest with small patchy area of moist evergreen, moist-mixed species forest and dipterocarp dominated forest. Monthly climatic data of the area are shown in Fig. 1. The dry season in this area occurs from November to February with a total rainfall of 0–60 mm per month.

Fig. 1

The relationship between the date of collection and the number of individuals collected (below) and values of the average monthly total rainfall (dotted line) and average temperature (solid line) of Chachoengsao Wildlife Research Center (top). Closed squares, hatched squares, open squares, and dotted squares indicate adult males, juvenile males, adult females, and juvenile females, respectively.


A small stream in a dry evergreen forest was chosen for studying of R. nigrovittata. Surveys were carried out from March to July, September, and November to December of 1996, and a total number of 96 frogs were captured. Frogs were seen in and along the stream during the dry season while they were found on the bank in the rainy season. Frogs collected were anesthetized by chloroform and preserved in 70% alcohol. The snout to vent length (SVL) was measured to the nearest 0.5 mm with a vernier caliper. We checked sex of each specimen by dissection. Sexual maturity was determined by the presence of secondary sexual characters such as humeral gland and nuptial pad in males while female maturity was determined by the presence of large pigmented ova and convoluted oviducts. As a result, we examined 28 juveniles (14 males and 14 females) and 68 adults (35 males and 33 females).

In the study area, the breeding season of R. nigrovittata occurs from April to June when the frequency of occurrence of adult frogs was higher (Figs. 12) and majority of females contained mature eggs in their ovaries. Although the larval period and time of metamorphosis at the study site is unclear, the smallest frog with an SVL of 16.1 mm was captured in December.

Fig. 2

The relationship between the date of collection and frog SVL. Closed circles, closed diamonds, open circles, and open diamonds indicate adult males, juvenile males, adult females, and juveniles females, respectively.


The third phalanges of the third digit of the left hand taken from preserved specimens were washed in running water for 24 hr, decal-cified in 5% nitric acid for 60–90 min, and washed in the running water for 24 hr. It was cross-sectioned (20–22 μm thick) by a freezing microtome and stained with hematoxylin (Mayer's acid hemalum) for 30 min. Since resting line was absent or incomplete in the epiphysis, sections from the central region of diaphysis were selected, and mounted in glycerin after rinsed in the tap water. Sections were examined under a light microscope and the number of lines of arrested growth (LAGs) presented in the periosteal bone was counted. To specify the age of each individual frog, the time of capture in the year was taken into consideration. Diameters of the innermost LAG and of the innermost portions of the periosteal bone were measured using an ocular micrometer.

We examined sexual difference in age composition by Mann-Whitney U-test. For body size difference between sexes, Student's t-test was applied. Logistic Model L=a/(1+ec–bt), where L is the SVL (mm) at time t (yr), a is the asymptotic size; c is the constant determined by putting 0 to t; and b is the instantaneous growth rate, was used to estimate the growth pattern (Misawa and Matsui, 1999). The significance level was set at 0.05.


The cross-sections of phalangeal bones were nearly circular in shape, and heamatoxylinophilic lines interpreted as LAGs were observed in the periosteal tissue, which was separated from the endosteal tissue by a resorption line (RL in Fig. 3). Although LAGs were not uniformly clear (Fig. 3), we could count their number by closely examining several sections for each individual. Age was calculated on the basis of the number of LAG and the time of the year when the frog was captured. In juvenile frogs captured from September to December, the LAG was not found in the phalangeal bones. By contrast, one LAG was found closer to the outer margin of the periosteal bone tissue in juveniles collected from March to May, suggesting these juveniles being collected shortly after formation of the LAG. These results indicate that the first LAG is formed during the dry season between November and February. Thus, when the starting point is set at June (at the end of the breeding season), frogs in the age class 0 included both without LAG (from June to the next February) and with one LAG (from March to May of the next year). Similarly, each age class included frogs both with LAGs corresponding to that age and with one additional LAGs (Table 1).

Fig. 3

Five LAGs seen in a phalangeal bone of an adult female R. nigrovittata with the body size in SVL of 51.9 mm and collected on 8 May 1996. As seen in the figure, the 2nd, 4th, and 5th LAGs are not clear compared with 1st and 3rd ones. RL=resorption line. Scale bar=100 μm.


Table 1

Average diameters (in μ) of the innermost portion of periosteal bone and the innermost LAG.


Because the periosteal tissue including the inner LAGs may be resorbed through the growth of the endosteal tissue, we measured diameters of the innermost portion of the periosteal bone (=resorption line) and of the innermost LAG to detect the resorption process. The result indicated that some part of the periosteal bone tissue was actually resorbed and that this resorption process was enhanced with the increase of the age. Four individuals with 6 LAGs (2 individuals) and 7 LAGs (2 individuals) had apparently their first LAG resorbed, and one year was added to estimate their ages (Table 1).

Population age structure differed insignificantly between the sexes (Mann-Whitney U-test; P >0.05, Fig. 4). Age of adult frogs differed insignificantly between the sexes (mean± 2SE =3 .70± 0.68 yrs in 35 males and 3.29± 0.42 yrs in 33 females; Mann-Whitney U-test, P >0.05). The maximum age that was observed in R. nigrovittata in this study was 8.8 years in males and 5.7 year in females. Thus, the maximum life span for R. nigrovittata is estimated to be at least 8.8 years.

Fig. 4

Population age structure for male (n=49) and female (n=47) Rana nigrovittata. Closed squares, hatched squares, open squares, and dotted squares indicate adult males, juvenile males, adult females, and juveniles females, respectively.


The smallest adult male was 36.3 mm (in SVL) with 0.7 yr of age and the smallest females was 33.2 mm with 1.4 yr. The largest size was 67.9 mm in a 8.8 yr male and 53.9 mm in a 5.0 yr female. Adult males were significantly larger than females (mean± 2SE: 50.6± 2.6 mm in 35 males and 45.3± 2.1 mm in 33 females: t-test, P <0.05), and this was the case in each age group (Table 2).

Table 2

Number of individuals, mean SVL in mm, and range, for each age class.


Individuals of different ages greatly overlapped in body size as seen in Table 2 and the body size proved to be not good indicator of age. Thus, growth curves estimated by a Logistic Model (Fig. 5) indicated that sexes did not differ in the instantaneous growth rate (b ± 2SE=0.5805± 0.1494 in males and 0.5587± 0.1527 in females) or in the asymptotic size (a ± 2SE=62.72 ± 4.32 in males and 57.35 ± 5.23 in females), probably due to great variation in SVL.

Fig. 5

Growth curves for Rana nigrovittata as determined by a logistic model. The closed and open circles indicate males L=62.7/ (1+e0.45–0.58t) and females L=57.4/(1+e0.40–0.56t), respectively.



From the results of the present study, the technique of skeletochronology proved to be successfully applied for Asian tropical frog at least for R. nigrovittata. In the case of Mantidactylus microtympanum, a single tropical species by now examined, LAGs are reported to be formed by the harsh annual period, with decreasing temperature, rainfall, and available food (Guarino et al., 1998). On the other hand, LAGs of Bufo pentoni living in the subdesert are considered to be formed by a long aestivation (Barbault et al., 1979), and LAGs Geocrinia alba and G. vitellina are similarly estimated to be formed during the dry months (Driscoll, 1999). In our study area, the dry season occurred from November to February and the number of frogs found was not so large in this period (Fig. 1). In addition, LAG of juvenile frog was closer to the outer edge of phalangeal bone cross-section. It is, therefore, highly probable that LAG is formed in the dry season (November to February) in R. nigrovittata. The temperature is also low in this season (Fig. 1) and probably activities of frogs would be lower resulting in the formation of resting lines.

Forester and Lyken (1991) reported that periosteal bone is eroded over a time in Notophthalmus viridescens. Verrell and Francillon (1986) similarly noted that endosteal bone may be deposited after the innermost LAG has been eroded in Triturus vulgaris. We also observed the endosteal bone and the occurrence of resorption in the innermost portion of the periosteal tissue in most phalangeal bones. Thus the simple counting of LAGs may underestimate true age especially in older individuals and diameters of the resorption line and inner LAG should be measured and compared for accurate estimation of individual ages.

Compared with a frog from a temperate region (e.g. R. rugosa and R. nigromaculata: Khonsue, unpublished data) the distinctness or intensity of LAGs was less conspicuous in R. nigrovittata. This finding supports an assumption made by Castanet and Smirina (1990) that the optical sharpness sometimes decreases and LAGs can be more or less inconspicuous in bones of specimens living under a more constant climatic condition.

Our finding confirmed that body size is a poor indicator for estimating the age of frogs. This tendency has been pointed out by many previous authors (Halliday and Verrell, 1988; Guarino et al., 1998; Tinsley and Tocque, 1995).

Shine (1979) reported females were larger than males in more than 90% of 589 anuran species he studied. Male R. nigrovittata contrariwise proved to be significantly larger than females. Larger body size in male frogs has been discussed in relation to male-male combating behavior (Shine, 1979). Our field observation, however, never proves presence of such behavior in R. nigrovittata, and further studies are necessary to explain reversed sexual dimorphism in this species.

The longevity of R. nigrovittata was estimated to be at least nine yrs in males and six yrs in females. This is the first indication of longevity in R. nigrovittata in nature. Longevity observed in the other tropical species M. microtympanum was seven yrs (Guarino et al., 1998). Longevities of these two tropical species seem to be shorter than those of some temperate species such as Bufo bufo (12 yrs: Hemelaar, 1988) and Bombina variegata (11–14 yrs: Plytycz and Bigaj, 1993). Hemelaar (1988) demonstrated that populations of Bufo bufo from higher altitudes and more northern latitudes were older than those from lower altitudes and more southern latitudes. Different longevity of frogs is regarded as being constrained by the mortality rate, and it is generally accepted that a high mortality of animals occurs due to a large number of predators in the tropical region. Ballinger (1979) pointed out that predation was the major factor of mortality in a lizard species at lower altitudes. On the other hand, Ryser (1996) attributed shorter period of activity to reduction of risks to be killed in the temperate regions. We need future detailed field studies of predation and activity pattern in R. nigrovittata.

In conclusion, the present result demonstrates that skeletochronological technique using phalangeal bone can be used to estimate the age of a tropical species R. nigrovittata. This species occurs mainly in the Savanna where annual climate condition is less constant than in tropical rain forest. Therefore, further studies using many other tropical Asian frog species, especially those from tropical rain forests, are necessary to confirm the generality of the present results.


Kumthorn Thirakhupt, Chulalongkorn University gave WK constructive suggestions in his field surveys. The TRF/BIOTEC special program for Biodiversity Research and Training supported field works of WK (BRT539008). Toshiaki Hirai helped part of the statistical analyses. Also the TJTTP-OECF graduate scholarship for WK is fully acknowledged.



R. E. Ballinger 1979. Intraspecific variation in demography and life history of the lizard, Scelepous jarrovi, along an altitudinal gradient in southeastern Arizona. Ecology 60:901–909. Google Scholar


R. J. Barbault, H. Castanet, Francillon, and A. de Ricqles . 1979. Determination de l'age chez un anoure déserticole Bufo pentoni Anderson 1839. Terre Vie Rev Ecol 33:129–142. Google Scholar


H. Bastien and R. Leclair Jr . 1992. Aging wood frog (Rana sylvatica) by skeletochronology. J Herpetol 26:222–225. Google Scholar


J. Castanet and E. Smirina . 1990. Introduction to the skeletochronological method in amphibians and reptiles. Ann Sci Nat Zool 11:191–196. Google Scholar


J. S. Denton and T. J. C. Beebee . 1993. Density-related features of natterjack toad (Bufo calamita) populations in Britain. J Zool Lond 229:105–119. Google Scholar


D. A. Driscoll 1999. Skeletochronological assessment of age structure and population stability for two threatened frog species. Aust J Ecol 24:182–189. Google Scholar


D. C. Forester and D. V. Lykens . 1991. Age structure in a population of red-spotted newt from the Allegheny plateau of Mayland. J Herpetol 25:373–376. Google Scholar


H. J. Francillon-Vieillot, W. Aratzen, and J. Geraudie . 1990. Age, growth and longevity of sympatric Triturus cristatus, T. marmoratus and their hybrids (Amphibia, Urodela): A skeletochronological comparison. J Herpetol 24:13–22. Google Scholar


D. R. Frost , editor. (ed) 1985. Amphibian Species of the world: A Taxonomic and Geographical Reference. Allen Press. Lawrence, Kansas. iv+732. p. Google Scholar


F. M. Guarino, F. Anderson, and F. Angelini . 1998. Growth and longevity by skeletochronological analysis in Mantidactylus microtympanum, a rainforest anuran from southern Madagascar. Copeia 1998:194–198. Google Scholar


T. R. Halliday and P. A. Verrell . 1988. Body size and age in amphibians and reptiles. J Herpetol 22:253–265. Google Scholar


A. Hemelaar 1988. Age, growth and other population characteristics of Bufo bufo from different latitudes and altitudes. J Herpetol 22:369–388. Google Scholar


T. Kusano, K. Fukuyama, and N. Miyashita . 1995a. Body size and age determination by skeletochronology of the brown frog, Rana tagoi tagoi in Southwestern Kanto. Jpn J Herpetol 16:29–34. Google Scholar


T. Kusano, K. Fukuyama, and N. Miyashita . 1995b. Age determination of the stream frog, Rana sakuraii, by skeletochronology. J Herpetol 29:625–628. Google Scholar


Y. Misawa and M. Matsui . 1999. Age determination by skeletochronology of the Japanese salamander Hynobius kimurae (Amphibia, Urodela). Zool Sci 16:845–851. Google Scholar


B. Plytycz and J. Bigaj . 1993. Studies on the growth and longevity of the yellow-bellied toad, Bombina variegata, in natural environments. Amphibia-Reptilia 14:35–44. Google Scholar


K. L. Roger and L. Harvey . 1994. A skeletochronological assessment of fossil and recent Bufo cognatus from South-central Colorado. J Herpetol 28:133–140. Google Scholar


J. Ryser 1996. Comparative life histories of a low- and a high-elevation population of the common frog Rana temporaria. Amphibia-Reptilia 17:138–195. Google Scholar


E. S. Sagor, M. Ouellet, E. Barten, and D. M. Green . 1998. Skeletochronology and geographic variation in age structure in the wood frog, Rana sylvatica. J Herpetol 32:469–474. Google Scholar


R. Shine 1979. Sexual selection and sexual dimorphism in the amphibia. Copeia 1979:297–306. Google Scholar


E. H. Taylor 1962. The amphibian fauna of Thailand. Univ Kansas Sci Bull 63:265–599. Google Scholar


R. C. Tinsley and K. Tocque . 1995. The population dynamics of a desert anuran, Scaphiopus couchii. Aust J Ecol 20:376–384. Google Scholar


P. A. Verrell and H. Francillon . 1986. Body size, age and reproduction in the smooth newt, Triturus vulgaris. J Zool Lon 210:89–100. Google Scholar
Wichase Khonsue, Masafumi Matsui, and Yasuchika Misawa "Age Determination by Skeletochronology of Rana nigrovittata, a Frog from Tropical Forest of Thailand," Zoological Science 17(2), 253-257, (1 March 2000).
Received: 9 August 1999; Accepted: 1 October 1999; Published: 1 March 2000

Back to Top