Translator Disclaimer
1 December 2004 Data, Sample Sizes and Statistics Affect the Recognition of Species of Bats by Their Echolocation Calls
Stefania Biscardi, Jazmine Orprecio, M. Brock Fenton, Asaf Tsoar, John M. Ratcliffe
Author Affiliations +

Identification of bat species based on analysis of echolocation calls can be affected by the way data are manipulated, the diversity of species, and call variability. We document the effects of sample sizes and a priori assignment of calls by species on the outcome of discriminant function analysis (DFA) and multinomial logistic regression (MLR) of features of echolocation calls, and determine which features of calls are most useful for identification. We used recorded echolocation calls of eight species readily distinguishable by call features, including molossids, emballonurids and a moormopid recorded at sites in Belize, Brazil, and Mexico. On individual calls, we measured four features: frequency with most energy, highest and lowest frequencies and call durations obtained from sequences consisting of 10 calls. Cluster analysis and multiple analyses of variance indicated significant differences between the calls of different species. Outcomes of DFA and MLR were affected by both sample sizes (numbers of calls, numbers of sequences) and the subjective approach that researchers take to their data (i.e., categorizing calls or sequences of calls by species). Levels of variation in calls of some species in our sample often precluded the use of single calls in making call-based identifications. Accurate documentation of variability in echolocation behavior of sympatric bats is a prerequisite for an effective sound-based bat survey.



A. A. Afifi , and V. Clark . 1990. Computer-aided multivariate analysis. Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York, 512 pp. Google Scholar


I. Ahlén 1990. Identification of bats in flight. Swedish Society for Conservation of Nature and the Swedish Youth Association for Environmental Studies and Conservation. Google Scholar


R. M. R. Barclay 1983. Echolocation calls of emballonurid bats from Panama. Journal of Comparative Physiology, 151: 515–520. Google Scholar


R. M. R. Barclay 1999. Bats are not birds — a cautionary note on using echolocation calls to identify bats: a comment. Journal of Mammalogy, 80: 290–296. Google Scholar


E. Bernard 2001. Species list of bats (Mammalia, Chiroptera) of Santarén area, Parà State, Brazil. Revista Brasileira de Zoologia,18: 455–463. Google Scholar


E. Bernard , and M. B. Fenton . 2002. Species diversity of bats (Mammalia: Chiroptera) in forest fragments, primary forest and savannas in central Amazon, Brazil. Canadian Journal of Zoology, 80: 1124–1140. Google Scholar


J. W. Boughman , and G. S. Wilkinson . 1998. Greater spear-nosed bats discriminate group mates by vocalizations. Animal Behaviour, 55: 1717–1732. Google Scholar


R. M. Brigham , J. E. Cebek , and M. B. C. Hickey . 1989. Intraspecific variation in the echolocation calls of two species of insectivorous bats. Journal of Mammalogy, 70: 426–428. Google Scholar


A. R. C. Britton , G. Jones , J. M. V. Rayner , A. M. Boonman , and B. Verboom . 1997. Flight performance, echolocation and foraging behaviour in pond bats, Myotis dasycneme (Chiroptera: Vespertilionidae). Journal of Zoology (London), 241: 503–522. Google Scholar


G. Ceballos , and A. Miranda . 2000. Guía de campo de los mamíferos de la Costa de Jalisco, México. Fundación Ecologica de Cuixmala. Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Mexico City, 502 pp. Google Scholar


C. Chávez , and G. Ceballos . 2001. Diversidad y abundancia de murciélagos en selvas secas de estacionalidad contrastante en el oeste de México. Revista Mexicana de Mastozoología, 5: 27–44. Google Scholar


J. Cohen 1988. Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences, 2nd edition. Hillsdale, New Jersey, 567 pp. Google Scholar


A. Denzinger , B. M. Siemers , A. Schaub , and H.-U. Schnitzler . 2001. Echolocation by the barbastelle bat, Barbastella barbastellus. Journal of Comparative Physiology A, 187: 521–528. Google Scholar


W. R. Dillon , and M. Goldstein . 1984. Multivariate analysis: methods and applications. Wiley, New York, 608 pp. Google Scholar


M. B. Fenton , and G. P. Bell . 1981. Recognition of species of insectivorous bats by their echolocation calls. Journal of Mammalogy, 62: 233–243. Google Scholar


M. B. Fenton , E. Bernard , S. Bouchard , L. Hollis , D. S. Johnston , C. L. Lausen , J. M. Ratcliffe , D. K. Riskin , J. R. Taylor , and J. Zigouris . 2001. The bat fauna of Lamanai, Belize: roosts and trophic roles. Journal of Tropical Ecology, 17: 511–524. Google Scholar


M. B. Fenton , Jacobs , E. J. Richardson , P. J. Taylor , and W. White . 2004. Individual signatures in the frequency-modulated sweep calls of large African large-eared free-tailed bats (Otomops martiensseni; Chiroptera: Molossidae). Journal of Zoology (London), 262: 11–19. Google Scholar


D. R. Griffin 1958. Listening in the dark. Yale University Press, New Haven, 415 pp. Google Scholar


D. R. Griffin , F. A. Webster , and C. R. Michael . 1960. The echolocation of flying insects by bats. Animal Behaviour, 8: 141–154. Google Scholar


A. Herr, N. I. Klomp, and J. S. Atkinson. 1997. Identification of bat echolocation calls using a decision tree classification system. Complexity International, Volume 4, URL: Scholar


C. Ibáñez , J. Juste , J. Lopez-Wilchis , L. Albuja , and A. Nunez-Garduno . 2002. Echolocation of three species of sac-winged bats (Balantiopteryx). Journal of Mammalogy, 83: 1049–1057. Google Scholar


G. Jones , and T. Kokurewicz . 1994. Sex and age variation in echolocation calls and flight morphology of Daubenton's bat Myotis daubentonii. Mammalia, 58: 41– 50. Google Scholar


G. Jones , and R. D. Ransome . 1993. Echolocation calls of bats are influenced by maternal effects and change over a lifetime. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B, 252: 125–128. Google Scholar


G. Jones , T. Gordon , and J. Nightingale . 1992. Sex and age-differences in the echolocation calls of the lesser horseshoe bat, Rhinolophus hipposideros. Mammalia, 56: 89–193. Google Scholar


G. Jones , N. Vaughan , and S. Parsons . 2000. Acoustic identification of bats from directly sampled and time expanded recordings of vocalizations. Acta Chiropterologica, 2: 155–170. Google Scholar


E. K. V. Kalko 1995. Echolocation signal design, foraging habitats and guild structure in six Neotropical sheath-tailed bats (Emballonuridae). Pp. 259–273, in Ecology, evolution and behaviour of bats ( P. A. Racey and S. M. Swift, eds.). The Zoological Society of London, Clarendon Press, Oxford, 421 pp. Google Scholar


E. K. V. Kalko 1997. Diversity in tropical bats. Pp. 13–43, in Tropical biodiversity and systematics. Proceedings of the International Symposium on Biodiversity and Systematics in Tropical Ecosystems, Bonn, 1994 ( H. Ulrich, ed.). Zoologisches Forschungsinstitut und Museum Alexander Koenig, Bonn, 357 pp. Google Scholar


E. K. V. Kalko , and H.-U. Schnitzler . 1993. Plasticity in echolocation signals of European pipistrelle bats in search flight -implications for habitat use and prey detection. Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology, 33: 415–428. Google Scholar


K. A. Kazial , S. C. Burnett , and W. M. Masters . 2001. Individual and group variation in echolocation calls of big brown bats, Eptesicus fuscus (Chiroptera: Vespertilionidae). Journal of Mammalogy, 8: 339–351. Google Scholar


M. Kossl , E. Mora , F. Coro , and M. Vater . 1999. Two-toned echolocation calls from Molossus molossus in Cuba. Journal of Mammalogy, 80: 929–932. Google Scholar


P. A. Lachenbruch 1975. Discriminant analysis. Hafner Press, New York, 128 pp. Google Scholar


B. S. Law , L. Reinhold , and M. Pennay . 2002. Geographic variation in the echolocation calls of Vespadelus spp. (Vespertilionidae) from New South Wales and Queensland, Australia. Acta Chiropterologica, 4: 201–215. Google Scholar


B. D. Lawrence , and J. A. Simmons . 1982. Measurements of atmospheric attenuation at ultrasonic frequencies and the significance for echolocating bats. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 71: 585–590. Google Scholar


W. M. Masters , S. C. Jacobs , and J. A. Simmons . 1991. The structure of echolocation sounds used by the big brown bat, Eptesicus fuscus: some consequences for echo processing. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 89: 1402–1413. Google Scholar


G. Neuweiler , W. Metzner , U. Heilmann , R. Rubsamen , M. Eckrich , and H. H. Costa . 1987. Foraging behavior and echolocation in the rufous horseshoe bat (Rhinolophus rouxi) of Sri Lanka. Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology, 20: 53–67. Google Scholar


M. K. Obrist 1995. Flexible bat echolocation: the influence of individual, habitat and conspecifics on sonar signal design. Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology, 36: 207–219. Google Scholar


M. K. Obrist , R. Boesch , P. F. Flückiger , and U. Dieckmann . 2004. Who's calling? Acoustic bat species identification revised with synergetics. Pp. 468–477, in Advances in the study of echolocation in bats and dolphins. Proceedings of the Biosonar Conference 1998 ( J. Thomas, C. Moss, and M. Vater, eds.). University of Chicago Press, Chicago, 604 pp. Google Scholar


J. Ochoa , M. J. O'Farrell , and B. W. Miller . 2000. Contribution of acoustic methods to the study of insectivorous bat diversity in protected areas from northern Venezuela. Acta Chiropterologica, 2: 171–183. Google Scholar


M. J. O'Farrell , and B. W. Miller . 1997. A new examination of echolocation calls of some neotropical bats (Emballonuridae and Mormoopidae). Journal of Mammalogy, 78: 954–963. Google Scholar


M. J. O'Farrell , and B. W. Miller . 1999. Use of vocal signatures for the inventory of free-flying neotropical bats. Biotropica, 31: 507–516. Google Scholar


J. D. Olden , and D. A. Jackson . 2002. A comparison of statistical approaches for modelling fish species distributions. Freshwater Biology, 47: 1976–1995. Google Scholar


S. Parsons 1997. Search-phase echolocation calls of the New Zealand lesser short-tailed bat (Mystacina tuberculata) and long-tailed bat (Chalinolobus tuberculatus). Canadian Journal of Zoology, 75: 1487–1494. Google Scholar


S. Parsons , and G. Jones . 2000. Acoustic identification of 12 species of echolocating bats by discriminant function analysis and artificial neural networks. Journal of Experimental Biology, 203: 2641–2656. Google Scholar


K. J. Patriquin , L. K. Hogberg , B. J. Chruszcz , and R. M. R. Barclay . 2003. The influence of habitat structure on the ability to detect ultrasound using bat detectors. Wildlife Society Bulletin, 31: 475–481. Google Scholar


D. L. Pearl, and M. B Fenton. 1996. Can echolocation calls provide information about group identity in the little brown bat (Myotis lucifugus)? Canadian Journal of Zoology, 74: 2184–2192. Google Scholar


S. J. Press , and S. Wilson . 1978. Choosing between logistic regression and discriminant analysis. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 73: 699–705. Google Scholar


J. M. Ratcliffe , and J. W. Dawson . 2003. Behavioural flexibility: the little brown bat,Myotis lucifugus, and the northern long-eared bat, M. septentrionalis, both glean and hawk prey. Animal Behaviour, 66: 847–856. Google Scholar


J. M. Ratcliffe, H. M. Ter Hofstede, R. Avilaflores, M. B. Fenton, G. F. McCracken, S. Biscardi, J. Blasko, E. Gillam, J. Orprecio, and G. Spanjer. In press. Conspecifics influence call design in the Brazilian free-tailed bat, Tadarida brasiliensis. Canadian Journal of Zoology. Google Scholar


D. Russo , and G. Jones . 2002. Identification of twenty-two bat species (Mammalia: Chiroptera) from Italy by analysis of time-expanded recordings of echolocation calls. Journal of Zoology (London), 258: 91–103. Google Scholar


D. Russo, G. Jones, and M. Mucedda. 2001. Influence of age, sex and body size on echolocation calls of Mediterranean (Rhinolophus euryale) and Mehely's (Rhinolophus mehelyi) horseshoe bats (Chiroptera: Rhinolophidae), Mammalia 65: 429–436. Google Scholar


J. Rydell , H. T. Arita , M. Santos , and J. Granados . 2002. Acoustic identification of insectivorous bats (order Chiroptera) of Yucatan, Mexico. Journal of Zoology (London), 257: 27–36. Google Scholar


O. Sanchez , G. Lopez-Ortega , and R. Lopezwilchis . 1989. Murcielagos de la cuidad de Mexico y sus alrededores. Pp. 141–165, in Ecología urbana ( R. Gío-Argáez, I. Hernández-R., and E. Sáinz-H, eds.). DDF, Mexico City, 220 pp. Google Scholar


H.-U. Schnitzler, and E. K. V. Kalko. 1998. How echolocating bats search and find food. Pp. 183–196, in Bat biology and conservation ( T. H. Kunz and P. A. Racey, eds.). Smithsonian Institution Press, Washington, D.C., 365 pp. Google Scholar


H.-U. Schnitzler , and E. K. V. Kalko . 2001. Echolocation by insectivorous bats. BioScience, 51: 557–569. Google Scholar


A. Surlykke , and C. F. Moss . 2000. Echolocation behavior of big brown bats, Eptesicus fuscus, in the field and the laboratory. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 108: 2419–2429. Google Scholar


B. G. Tabachnick , and L. S. Fidell . 2001. Using multivariate statistics, 4th edition. Allyn and Bacon, Needham Heights, 966 pp. Google Scholar


N. H. Timm 2002. Applied multivariate statistics. Springer, Berlin, 720 pp. Google Scholar


D. W. Thomas , G. P. Bell , and M. B. Fenton . 1987. Variation in echolocation call frequencies recorded from North American vespertillionid bats: a cautionary note. Journal of Mammalogy, 68: 842–847. Google Scholar


N. Ulanovsky, M. B. Fenton, A. Tsoar, and C. Korine. In press. Dynamics of jamming avoidance in echolocating bats. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Google Scholar


N. Vaughan , G. Jones , and S. Harris . 1997. Identification of British species by multivariate analysis of echolocation call parameters. Bioacustics, 7: 189–207. Google Scholar


L. Wollerman , and R. H. Wiley . 2002. Possibilities for error during communication by neotropical frogs in a complex acoustic environment. Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology, 52: 465–473. Google Scholar
© Museum and Institute of Zoology PAS
Stefania Biscardi, Jazmine Orprecio, M. Brock Fenton, Asaf Tsoar, and John M. Ratcliffe "Data, Sample Sizes and Statistics Affect the Recognition of Species of Bats by Their Echolocation Calls," Acta Chiropterologica 6(2), 347-363, (1 December 2004).
Received: 29 April 2004; Accepted: 1 July 2004; Published: 1 December 2004

Back to Top