Translator Disclaimer
19 January 2016 Comment on “A New Arctic Hadrosaurid from the Prince Creek Formation (Lower Maastrichtian) of Northern Alaska” by Hirotsugu Mori, Patrick S. Druckenmiller, and Gregory M. Erickson
Author Affiliations +

Recently Mori et al. (2016) published a paper describing a new taxon of hadrosaurid dinosaur from the Upper Cretaceous Prince Creek Formation of the North Slope Alaska, a rock unit that has recently proven to be a productive source of scientific insights into the workings of an ancient Arctic terrestrial ecosystem (Fiorillo and Gangloff 2001; Gangloff et al. 2005; Fiorillo et al. 2009, 2010; Gangloff and Fiorillo 2010; Flaig et al. 2011, 2013, 2014; Fiorillo and Tykoski 2012, 2014). Although thorough testing of the systematics of this proposed taxon will occur over the next few years, one statement in the Mori et al. (2016) paper warrants comment now. In their section on “Geologic setting and taxonomic composition”, the authors state “The hadrosaurid remains are almost entirely disarticulated, show little evidence of weathering, predation, or trampling and are typically uncrushed and unpermineralized.” As evidence for this statement, the authors cite two papers: Gangloff and Fiorillo (2010) and Fiorillo et al. (2010). These two papers discuss the taphonomy and depositional setting of the Liscomb Bonebed, which is the source of the materials used by Mori et al. (2016).

It is puzzling that Mori et al. (2016) state the bones are “typically uncrushed and unpermineralized” because these bones are indeed permineralized. As stated by Gangloff and Fiorillo (2010: 300) there is common to abundant occurrence of minerals such as pyrite, calcite, and chalcedony (microcrystalline quartz) within the dinosaur bones collected. All of these minerals are commonly introduced during the permineralization process. Further, Gangloff and Fiorillo (2010) discussed fractures of bones resulting from freezethaw dynamics present along boundaries of permafrost, and the paper included figures illustrating the degree of crushing in some of the bones (2010: fig. 5C, D). The bones from the Liscomb Bonebed are remarkable but they are indeed fossilized and they are indeed permineralized. Fiorillo et al. (2010), did not focus on any of the mineralogical aspects of bone preservation so the use of this paper in support of Mori et al.'s (2016) claim is baffling. As a co-author of the two papers that are being misused, several colleagues have now contacted me requesting clarification on the state of fossilization of dinosaur bones from northern Alaska. The Mori et al. (2016) paper serves as a reminder that scientists are not only obligated to provide the supporting data for their conclusions, they are also obligated to cite their sources accurately.

References

  1. Fiorillo, A.R. and Gangloff, R.A. 2001. The caribou migration model for Arctic hadrosaurs (Ornithischia: Dinosauria): a reassessment. Historical Biology 15: 323–334. Google Scholar
  2. Fiorillo, A.R. and Tykoski, R.S. 2012. A new species of centrosaurine ceratopsid Pachyrhinosaurus from the North Slope (Prince Creek Formation: Maastrichtian) of Alaska. Acta Palaeontologica Polonica 57: 561–573. Google Scholar
  3. Fiorillo, A.R. and Tykoski, R.S. 2014. A diminutive new tyrannosaur from the top of the world. PLoS ONE 9 (3): e91287. Google Scholar
  4. Fiorillo, A.R. , McCarthy, P.J. , and Flaig, P.P. 2010. Taphonomic and sedimentologic interpretations of the dinosaur-bearing Upper Cretaceous strata of the Prince Creek Formation, Northern Alaska: insights into an ancient high-latitude terrestrial ecosystem. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 295: 376–388. Google Scholar
  5. Fiorillo, A.R. , Tykoski, R.S. , Currie, P.J. , McCarthy, P.J. , and Flaig, P. 2009. Description of two partial Troodon braincases from the Prince Creek Formation (Upper Cretaceous), North Slope Alaska. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 29: 178–187. Google Scholar
  6. Flaig, P.P. , Fiorillo, A.R. , and McCarthy, P.J. 2014. Dinosaur-bearing hyperconcentrated flows of Cretaceous Arctic Alaska: recurring catastrophic event beds on a distal paleopolar coastal plain. Palaios 29: 594–611. Google Scholar
  7. Flaig, P. , McCarthy, P.J. , and Fiorillo, A.R. 2011. A tidally-influenced, high-latitude alluvial/coastal plain: the Late Cretaceous (Maastrichtian) Prince Creek Formation, North Slope, Alaska. In: C. North , S. Davidson , and S. Leleu (eds.), From River to Rock Record: The Preservation of Fluvial Sediments and their Subsequent Interpretation. SEPM Special Publication 97: 233–264. Google Scholar
  8. Flaig, P.P. , McCarthy, P.J. , and Fiorillo, A.R. 2013. Anatomy, evolution, and paleoenvironmental interpretation of an ancient Arctic coastal plain: Integrated paleopedology and palynology from the Upper Cretaceous (Maastrichtian) Prince Creek Formation, North Slope, Alaska, USA. In: S.G. Driese and L.C. Nordt (eds.), New Frontiers in Paleopedology and Terrestrial Paleoclimatology: Paleosols and Soil Surface Analogue Systems. SEPM Special Publication 104: 179–230. Google Scholar
  9. Gangloff, R.A. and Fiorillo, A.R. 2010. Taphonomy and paleoecology of a bonebed from the Prince Creek Formation, North Slope, Alaska. Palaios 25: 299–317. Google Scholar
  10. Gangloff, R.A. , Fiorillo, A.R. , and Norton, D.W. 2005. The first Pachycephalosaurine (Dinosauria) from the Paleo-Arctic and its paleogeographic implications. Journal of Paleontology 79: 997–1001. Google Scholar
  11. Mori, H. , Druckenmiller, P.S. , and Erickson, G.M. 2016. A new Arctic hadrosaurid from the Prince Creek Formation (lower Maastrichtian) of northern Alaska. Acta Palaeontologica Polonica 61: 15–32. Google Scholar
© 2016 A.R. Fiorillo. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (for details please see http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
and Anthony R. Fiorillo "Comment on “A New Arctic Hadrosaurid from the Prince Creek Formation (Lower Maastrichtian) of Northern Alaska” by Hirotsugu Mori, Patrick S. Druckenmiller, and Gregory M. Erickson," Acta Palaeontologica Polonica 61(1), (19 January 2016). https://doi.org/10.4202/app.00233.2015
Received: 7 December 2015; Accepted: 1 December 2015; Published: 19 January 2016
JOURNAL ARTICLE
1 PAGES


SHARE
ARTICLE IMPACT
Back to Top