Open Access
Translator Disclaimer
1 August 2003 Factors Affecting the Distribution of Populus balsamifera on the North Slope of Alaska, U.S.A
J. G. Bockheim, J. D. O'Brien, J. S. Munroe, K. M. Hinkel
Author Affiliations +
Abstract
Balsam poplar (Populus balsamifera) groves occur north of the Brooks Range and treeline in arctic Alaska in a region of continuous permafrost and tundra vegetation. A poplar grove near the Ivishak River (69°06′N, 147°53′W) that we studied in detail contains 11 clones within 350 m of the river. Individual clones range from 600 to 4500 m2 in size and 90 to 200 yr in age. Poplar trees are larger in diameter in clones within 100 m of the river and less dense in clones away from the river. Unique soil thermal, moisture, and nutrient conditions may limit the expansion of poplar groves to only a few hundred meters from the river channel, including a “thaw bulb,” or depression in the permafrost table; lithologic discontinuities that concentrate moisture in the rooting zone; and accumulation of Ca-enriched precipitates from aufeis deposits. We prepared a map showing the distribution of poplar groves on the North Slope from published reports, satellite images, topographic maps, and observations of a bush pilot. The groves occur within an area bounded by 68–69°N and 142–154°W. A preliminary model explaining the origin and distribution of balsam poplar groves was developed from the case study; unpublished data; and a review of the geologic, hydrologic, and ecologic literature. The groves preferentially occur in areas where there is a sharp change in relief from the Brooks Range to the Arctic Foothills, extensive river braiding accompanied by geothermal springs and aufeis deposits, and a regional groundwater flow system enriched in Ca that may be controlled by faulting.

Introduction

Balsam poplar (Populus balsamifera) groves occur on the North Slope of Alaska over 100 km from continuous populations in the taiga south of the Brooks Range (Spetzman, 1951; Wiggins and Thomas, 1962; Hultén, 1968; Viereck and Foote, 1970; Hettinger and Janz, 1974; Murray, 1980; Edwards and Dunwiddie, 1985). The North Slope is characterized by continuous permafrost and tundra vegetation; for this reason, the poplar stands are anomalous.

The distribution and factors affecting the distribution of balsam poplar in this region are poorly understood. Poplar groves on the North Slope appear to be limited to active or recently abandoned rivers. In this setting the seasonal thaw layer (active layer) tends to be thicker than in the surrounding tundra, and there is a continuous supply of subsurface water (Hettinger and Janz, 1974; Murray, 1980). The groves are often associated with geothermal springs (Nava and Morrison, 1974; Zasada and Phipps, 1990).

The growth of balsam poplar along the North Slope is favored by a floodplain environment with ample moisture (Viereck and Foote, 1970; Hettinger and Janz, 1974; Murray, 1980), periodic flooding (Hettinger and Janz, 1974), a deep active layer within 50 m of the river (Nanson and Beach, 1977), and soils with a high pH (>7) and lithologic discontinuities (Nanson and Beach, 1977; Zasada and Phipps, 1990).

Balsam poplar stands on the North Slope are normally even-aged, less than 230 yr in age, and slow growing (Nanson and Beach, 1977; Edwards and Dunwiddie, 1985; Lev, 1987). The groves have an unusually high plant and animal diversity (Hettinger and Janz, 1974; Nanson and Beach, 1977; Edwards and Dunwiddie, 1985). There are several varieties of balsam poplar, including P. balsamifera var. balsamifera and P. balsamifera var. subcordata, which complicates taxonomic delineation. In addition, P. balsamifera readily hybridizes with P. trichocarpa (Viereck and Foote, 1970; Zasada and Phipps, 1990).

Balsam poplar groves may have originated from seeds carried over the Brooks Range, but the groves reproduce locally both from seed and asexually (Murray, 1980). The groves generally contain more than one clone (Edwards and Dunwiddie, 1985; Lev, 1987), with each clone containing from 10 to 150 or more individuals (ramets). The groves may be outliers along north-flowing rivers (Landhaeusser and Wein, 1993), or they may be relicts from a warmer period when balsam poplar was more widespread on the North Slope (Mott, 1978; Hopkins et al., 1981; Ritchie et al., 1983; Ritchie, 1984; Edwards and Dunwiddie, 1985).

There is considerable evidence of climate change in arctic Alaska, including increased winter and spring air temperatures since about 1970, negative mass balance of small arctic glaciers, warming of permafrost, increased plant growth accompanied by greater shrub abundance, and northward migration of treeline (Serreze et al., 2000). Therefore, the study of the distribution of balsam poplar on the Arctic Slope is of importance with regards to warming of the region.

The purposes of this study are three-fold: (1) to determine the site factors favoring the growth of a balsam poplar grove located along a tributary of the Ivishak River, (2) to summarize data regarding the distribution of balsam poplar along the North Slope, and (3) to prepare a descriptive model explaining the distribution of balsam poplar in arctic Alaska.

Study Area

The study area includes the eastern half of the North Slope of Alaska from 68° to 70°N latitude, bounded by the Colville River to the west (154°W) and the Kongakut River to the east (142°W) (Fig. 1). Although the study area includes the Arctic Coastal Plain, most of the balsam poplar stands occur in the Arctic Foothills physiographic province, as delineated by Wahrhaftig (1965).

The climate of the Arctic Foothills is harsh but warmer than that of the Coastal Plain to the north and the Brooks Range to the south. The average winter temperature is −20° to −24°C. Average summer temperature is 10° to 15°C, with freezing temperatures occurring during any month of the year (National Climatic Data Center, 1998). Annual precipitation is approximately 150 mm, with an additional 50 mm near the boundary of Brooks Range. Snowfall accumulation can vary from 750 to 1300 mm, with the highest amounts found near the Brooks Range.

Valleys in the southern part of the Arctic Foothills were glaciated repeatedly during the Pleistocene; the Ivishak River site described herein contains drift of the late Pleistocene Itkillik glaciation (Hamilton, 1986). Surface sediments in the Arctic Foothills also include alluvial and colluvial deposits overlying folded beds of chert, conglomerate, sandstone, and greywacke of Jurassic and early Cretaceous age.

The Arctic Foothills and Arctic Coastal Plain physiographic regions contain low-shrub and tussock tundra along with willow, birch shrub, and poplar (Wiggins and Thomas, 1962; Hultén, 1968; Hettinger and Janz, 1974; Gallant et al., 1995). The highest species diversity on the North Slope is associated with meadow vegetation on solifluction lobes and modern and abandoned river floodplains (Hettinger and Janz, 1974). The vegetation of these floodplains includes dwarf willow (Salix reticulata), mountain avens (Dryas integrifolia spp. integrifolia), cotton grass (Eriophorum vaginatum), sedge (Carex bigelowii), Labrador tea (Ledum palustre spp. decumbens), and moss (Tomenthypnum nitens). The understory vegetation of balsam poplar groves consists of arctic bearberry (Arctostaphylous rubra), felt-leaf willow (Salix alaxensis spp. alaxensis), other willows (S. glauca and S. planifolia spp. pulchra), and wintergreen (Pyrola rotundifolia spp. grandiflora) (Hettinger and Janz, 1974).

Poplar groves were identified from a review of vegetation surveys on the North Slope (Spetzman, 1951; Wiggins and Thomas, 1962; Hultén, 1968; Viereck and Foote, 1970; and Hettinger and Janz, 1974), personal communications with scientists and bush pilots, and a detailed examination of topographic maps and color-infrared satellite imagery. U.S. Geological Survey topographic maps, at a scale of 1:63,360, show trees or brush at least 2 m tall with densities sufficient to afford cover for troops but do not distinguish among forest cover types.

We used a digital database of the hydrographic system of the North Slope provided by the North Slope Borough Planning Department/GIS (D. Bevington, pers. comm.) to construct a base map. Major stream braiding and aufeis deposits identified by Sloan et al. (1976), Harden et al. (1977), Hall (1980a), Dean (1986), Sloan (1987), and Li et al. (1997) were digitized into ArcView 3.0 (Fig. 1). Aufeis deposits located along tributaries of principal north-flowing rivers are not shown in Figure 1, as they are too small to be represented at this scale. Similarly, major faults and geothermal springs identified by Hall and Roswell (1981) and Sloan (1987) were digitized in ArcView 3.0 (Fig. 2).

We examined a poplar grove along “Cottonwood Creek” (informal name), a tributary of the north-flowing Ivishak River (69°06′N, 147°53′W) in the Arctic Foothills (site No. 5, Fig. 1). This grove was selected for comprehensive analysis because of its accessibility, comparatively large size (distributed over 40 ha), and information gathered by us and others during previous visits. The grove is located on the south side of the creek and contains 11 scattered stands on the banks of current and former braided channels.

Methods and Materials

SAMPLE COLLECTION

The Cottonwood Creek poplar grove contains 11 stands mapped from compass bearings and pacing; an uncorrected aerial photograph (approximately 1:1500 scale) was also used to adjust tree measurements to an aerial basis. After counting the total number of ramets in each stand, we randomly selected 2 trees from each of the 11 stands for measuring diameter at breast height (1.38 m) and total height (m). Although this sample is admittedly small (2% of all trees on the site), there was minimal variation in diameter (average difference = 3.6 cm, or 8%) and height (average difference = 1.3 m, or 5.6%) between the 2 trees within a stand, likely because they were ramets from the same parent. Increment cores were taken at 15 cm above the ground for the determination of radial increment and stand age.

Stembark conditions, including “cracked” (thin, vertical frost-induced cracks), scarred (broader abrasion from moose grazing and flooding), and undamaged, were determined from a random survey of at least 20 trees per stand. Seedlings (including root suckers) were tallied in 5 randomly located, 4-m2 plots in each stand. A stem analysis (Husch et al., 1972) was performed on a single tree in August 1997. Tissue samples of poplar branches, current twigs, current buds, and foliage were collected from the upper, middle, and lower crown. Disks were collected every 1 m along the stem for a total distance of 12 m, and the proportions of bark, sapwood, and heartwood were determined.

Variation in soil properties and soil temperature was examined along a north-south transect perpendicular to the river and along an east-west transect in forested and nonforested areas parallel to the channel. The north-south transect extended 200 m south from the river at 20-m intervals, passing through two of the largest stands. A 40-cm-deep soil pit was excavated at each sampling point.

Thirteen soil pits in alternating poplar stands and shrubby areas were excavated along the 1000-m-long east-west transect parallel to the river. Soils were described along both transects using the Soil Survey Division Staff (1993) protocol. Samples were taken from each horizon >2 cm in thickness. Soil temperature was measured at a depth of 40 cm with a digital thermometer.

Samples of bulk precipitation, poplar throughfall, and stream water were collected during a heavy precipitation event on 18 August 1998. An additional sample of stream water was collected on 14 August 1997.

LABORATORY ANALYSIS

Soil samples were returned to the University of Wisconsin–Madison for the determination of pH and gravimetric moisture content (dried at 70°C for 48 hr). Oven-dried soils were passed through a 2-mm sieve. Ninety-three soil samples were sent to the University of Missouri Soil Characterization Laboratory, where analyses were performed using methods established by the Soil Survey Staff (1996). These analyses include easily oxidizable organic C by dichromate digestion (6A1a); total N by semimicro Kjeldahl (6B2a); extractable P by the Olsen method (6S3); cation-exchange capacity by saturation with ammonium at pH 7 (5A8); exchangeable acidity (6Ha, 6H5); extractable Al (6G1); and particle-size distribution with sand and silt fractionation by sieving and pipette, respectively (3A, 3A1). Base cations were extracted with ammonium acetate (pH 8.2).

The University of Wisconsin Soil and Plant Analysis Laboratory (SPAL) ( http://riprock.soils.wisc.edu) analyzed stream water, precipitation, and throughfall solutions for cations with an inductively coupled plasma optical-emission spectrometer (ICP-OES) and anions by ion chromatography. Bicarbonate was determined using the Gran titration method (Gran, 1952). Tissue samples were analyzed by SPAL for total nutrients (ICP-OES) and total Kjeldahl nitrogen following grinding in a laboratory mill.

Annual radial growth of poplar trees was determined from increment cores using a binocular zoom microscope (7–30×). Because Armillaria mellea (butt rot) and Fomes igniarius (heart rot) stem decay resulted in incomplete cores, the total age of 21 of the 22 sampled trees was estimated from the outermost 10 years of radial growth projected to the pith of the tree. Stand basal area was estimated stem density and basal area of the two sample trees. Finally, a wood fragment collected from a soil pit in stand 10 at the 52-cm depth was split; one subsample was sent to the U.S. Forest Products Laboratory for identification and another to the Lawrence Livermore Laboratory for radiocarbon dating.

STATISTICAL ANALYSES

Six of the stands were located within 100 m of the river and 5 of the stands more than 100 m away from the river. Differences in mean values between stands in proximity to the river were compared using an unpaired t-test, assuming equal variances.

Results

STAND CHARACTERISTICS

There were no significant differences in tree height, age, number of seedlings, the incidence of scarred and cracked trees, and basal area with distance from the river (Table 1). However, diameter was significantly greater (p = 0.01) and density was significantly lower (p = 0.006) within 100 m of the river.

Average radial increment was 1.1 mm yr−1 and height increment was 7.6 cm yr−1 (data not shown). Based on dendrochronological studies, a single tree experienced the greatest growth rates in 1940, 1970, 1959, 1885, 1887, and 1974, while poor growth occurred in 1875, 1889, and 1980 (data not shown). The radiocarbon date of the wood fragment found at a soil depth of 52 cm in stand 10 was 650 ± 50 BP. This date calibrates to between 550 and 670 cal yr BP at 2-σ (Stuiver et al., 2000).

TISSUE ANALYSES

Calcium, nitrogen, and potassium are the most abundant macronutrients in tissues of the sampled balsam poplar, followed by Mg, P, and S (Table 2). The micronutrients are arrayed Zn > Na > Fe > Mn > B > Al > Cu, except in sapwood, where Na was abundant, followed by Al, Fe, Zn, Mn, B, and Cu. In perennial tissues, such as heartwood, sapwood, bole bark, live branches, and current twigs/buds, the mobile elements N, K, and P increased toward the apex of the tree. In contrast, the immobile element Ca was more concentrated toward the base of the tree or live crown.

SOIL PROPERTIES

Soils of the study area are poorly developed and contain a sequence of alluvium and buried organic horizons (Table 3). Lithologic discontinuities, consisting of overbank silts over river cobbles, were found at depths ranging from 40 to 43 cm in 5 of the 13 pits along the east-west transect and in 7 of the 11 pits along the north-south transect.

There were no trends in soil morphological or chemical properties with distance from the river or in relation to vegetation type (i.e., balsam poplar stand vs. shrubs) along the river. Silt concentration of the surface mineral horizon was lower away from the river, but the differences were not statistically significant (Table 1). In general, soils within 100 m of the river were silt loams with an average of 76% silt, 100% base saturation primarily by Ca, and a pH averaging 7.7.

SOLUTION ANALYSIS

The distribution of cations in precipitation, on a charge basis in descending order, was Ca > Al > Na > Mg > K > Mn; anions were distributed: NO3 > Cl > SO4 > HCO3 (Table 4). Throughfall cations can be ranked K > Ca > Mg > Al > Na > Mn, and anions HCO3 > Cl > NO3 > SO4. Streamwater cations can be ranked Ca > Mg > Na > Al > K > Mn and anions SO4 > HCO3 > NO3 > Cl. All solutions were weakly acidic to neutral, with a pH ranging from 6.3 to 7.7.

Discussion

GROWTH AND ORIGIN OF THE COTTONWOOD CREEK BALSAM POPLAR STAND

The diameter and height growth rates of balsam poplar at Cottonwood Creek are comparable to those reported elsewhere in arctic Alaska and in areas immediately south of the Brooks Range. Radial increment ranged from 0.5 to 2.2 mm yr−1 (data not shown), which is comparable to the 0.1 to 2.2 mm yr−1 values reported by Edwards and Dunwiddie (1985) and Lev (1987).

Morphological features of the stands were examined using the criteria of Gom and Rood (1999). The 11 stands investigated at Cottonwood Creek likely represent individual clones in that they were separated by distances ranging from 50 to 250 m, vary considerably in age, and contain distinct differences in phenological properties such as stem form, branching habit, bark color and texture, and leaf size and shape. The stands are of seed origin; the seeds may have been carried over the Brooks Range by wind and deposited throughout the southern Arctic Foothills. Because of the unique thermal and moisture conditions along the rivers draining the northern Brooks Range, balsam poplar becomes established only in specific localities. Alternatively, the seeds may be carried by water birds favoring riparian areas. The clones have persisted for at least 90 to 200 yr and possibly as long as 670 yr, based on a radiocarbon-dated wood fragment found at a depth of 52 cm in one of the stands.

There were no obvious differences in soil properties along the river or with distance from the river other than silt content, thus providing no distinct criteria for site selection for individual stands. However, several factors appear to promote the establishment and growth of poplar groves: the soil thermal, moisture, and nutrient regimes all appear to be more favorable near the river. Soil temperatures taken at the 40-cm depth along both the north-south and east-west transects in mid-August 1998 were 10–12°C, in contrast with soil temperatures of 0–0.5°C reported at similar depths and time frame in arctic tundra (Nelson et al., 1997). The continuous subsurface flow of the river, even during the harsh winter months, depresses the permafrost table near and beneath stream channels (Corbin and Benson, 1983). A depression in the permafrost table results in higher near-surface soil temperatures; less heat energy is needed to thaw frozen ground and is, therefore, available to increase soil enthalpy.

A second factor that may influence the distribution of balsam poplar along Cottonwood Creek is the effect of lithologic discontinuities on soil moisture relations. Lithologic discontinuities strongly affect water retention and movement in soil parent materials (Kung, 1993). In the alluvial soils along Cottonwood Creek, silt-rich materials over cobbly loamy sand materials enhance water retention and availability for poplar roots by suspending water in the unsaturated zone. The widespread occurrence of lithologic discontinuities along transects, and their absence elsewhere on the arctic tundra, suggest that they provide a unique environment for rooting of balsam poplar. The effective rooting depth of balsam poplar ranged from 13 to 42 cm and averaged 29 cm.

A third factor investigated relative to the distribution of balsam poplar along Cottonwood Creek is the nutrient regime. Natural waters (bulk precipitation, throughfall, and streamwater), soils, and tree tissues at the Cottonwood Creek site are particularly enriched in calcium. Dissolved calcium in river water likely originates from the groundwater-fed stream system originating in the Brooks Range, which is supersaturated with respect to calcite (Table 4). The soils may be enriched in calcium from weathering of the calcareous alluvium or more likely from dry deposition of nearby aufeis deposits, which is discussed in the next section. The foliage, branch, and heartwood tissues of North Slope balsam poplar (Table 2) all contain as much as two times the concentration of calcium as Populus species outside Alaska (Bartos and Johnson, 1978; Pastor and Bockheim, 1984).

Although the tissues are enriched in calcium, it could be argued that the high level of calcium may not be essential for poplar growth. For example, crop and pasture plants grown in calcium-rich solutions showed little additional gain in biomass as calcium concentrations increased (Loneragan and Snowball, 1969). Moreover, calcareous parent materials occur elsewhere on the North Slope in the absence of balsam poplar (Bockheim et al., 1998). Therefore, Ca enrichment adjacent to the river may be a cofactor influencing the occurrence and growth of balsam poplar beyond its normal range.

Distribution of Balsam Poplar on the North Slope: A Descriptive Model

We identified 28 balsam poplar groves on the North Slope that occur from 68°N in the Brooks Range to 69°N latitude in the Arctic Foothills and from 142°W to 154°W longitude (Fig. 1; Table 5). Balsam poplar groves are found in areas with strong topographic gradients, typically where there is a >200-m km−1 topographic gradient (Table 5). The stands occur in the foothills of the Brooks Range at elevations generally ranging from 245 to 638 m. The poplar groves also are associated with spring-fed rivers, aufeis deposits, and areas of extensive river braiding (Figs. 1 and 2).

Three of the sites (Nos. 6, 20, and 28) occur at elevations >1000 m and are not associated with braiding and aufeis development on streams. These sites were identified from color-infrared photos and were not ground truthed. Therefore, they may represent tall Salix rather than Populus balsamifera. We also observed scattered trees along May Creek (68°40′N, 151°37′W) and low-scrub balsam poplar west of Toolik Lake (68°38′N, 149°38′W), but these occurrences are not listed in Table 5.

Therefore, balsam poplars are found adjacent to rivers where favorable thermal and moisture conditions exist, due to a unique combination of factors including areas of extensive river braiding accompanied by aufeis, faults that run parallel to the river, deeper thaw bulb, and warmer soil temperatures relative to the surrounding tundra (Figs. 1 and 2). These factors are illustrated in Figure 3 and are discussed separately below.

SUBSURFACE WATER FLOW

Springs emerging from the Brooks Range provide a continual source of water at temperatures around 0°C that inhibits permafrost beneath rivers and their adjacent floodplains (Corbin and Benson, 1983). The surface temperature of North Slope streams may be lower than the temperature of the surrounding ground because of surface reflectance and the high specific heat of water. The heat pulse penetrates deeper under the stream than in the adjacent floodplain due to the channel topography and higher thermal conductivity of saturated channel sediments. The net effect is to lower the permafrost table to depths of 6 m beneath the stream and about 4 m on the adjacent floodplain (Corbin and Benson, 1983). These findings have implications for the thermal regime of Cottonwood Creek.

AUFEIS DEVELOPMENT

Aufeis or overflow deposits that form during the winter may cause a depression in the permafrost table. As the freezing front penetrates downward into the thaw bulb, aufeis (icings, naleds) can develop. Subsurface water flowing in the coarse alluvium beneath the stream channel is under increasing hydrostatic pressure due to the 9% volumetric expansion associated with the phase change (Hall, 1980a). During freezing of the water, ions are excluded from the ice crystal lattice, and at high concentrations they may further depress the freezing point. Eventually, the frozen overburden will deform upward and crack, allowing the water to rupture to the surface, where it quickly freezes. This process is repeated many times during the winter, and over time the aufeis aggrades upward. Ice at the top of the deposit is enriched in ions relative to the lower layers. The icings may reach sufficient thickness to prevent complete thermomechanical ablation in summer.

Aufeis remnants persisting well into the summer or year-round may contribute to river braiding by obstructing floodwater and causing channels to widen or new channels to form (Harden et al., 1977). Aufeis characteristically forms at the mountain front, where stream gradients decrease as rivers leave constricting valleys, pouring onto extensive outwash plains (Carey, 1973).

Corbin and Benson (1983) related soil temperature and stream water temperature along the North Slope to the latent heat of fusion of icing deposits during the winter and penetration of the summer heat pulse. Although icings enhance heat loss by removal of the insulating snow cover, their net thermal effect is the addition of heat to the system through the release of latent heat during freezing. The heat available from freezing a 20-cm-thick aufeis overflow is more than twice the amount required to bring thick accumulations of aufeis to their melting point (Corbin and Benson, 1983). The percolation of water downward along ice fractures advects heat more efficiently than conduction, which is the only other mechanism for transporting heat to the soil surface.

INFLUENCE OF FAULTS

A system of faults across the Brooks Range–Arctic Foothills contact contributes to the groundwater flow network and may indirectly influence the distribution of balsam poplar (Fig. 2). Whereas faults running perpendicular to the generally north-flowing rivers have limited aufeis development and are not associated with known poplar groves, faults parallel to the rivers have aufeis and according to our map are often accompanied by balsam poplar.

Spring water emerging from the north flank of the Brooks Range carries a large dissolved load of calcium carbonate and calcium sulfate (Childers et al., 1977; Hall, 1980b; Himes, 1980). The bedrock of the Brooks Range is composed of a complex sequence of calcareous limestone, sandstone, and shale (Sloan, 1987; Moore et al., 1994). The Lisburne Limestone, Endicott Sandstone, and Sadlerochit Sandy Limestone aquifers direct groundwater from recharge areas high in the Brooks Range along faults and solution cavities to discharge areas in the Arctic Foothills and Coastal Plain (Carey, 1973; Childers et al., 1977; Hall, 1980b; Sloan, 1987; Moore et al., 1994). Freezing of streamwater during the winter forces precipitation of this dissolved load, providing a continually renewed source of base cations to soils along reaches with aufeis.

The impact of faults on the groundwater flow system is not completely understood, but the transport time and distance traveled from the recharge area appear to be important (Carey, 1973; Childers et al., 1977). The groundwater residence time may increase due to impeded flow through pervasive permafrost, enhancing dissolution of the calcareous bedrock (Childers et al., 1975; Himes, 1980; Sloan, 1987). The presence of a thaw bulb adjacent to the river increases drainage of water through the soil profile, reduces moisture, increases soil temperatures, and provides a deeper rooting zone than in areas away from the thaw bulb (Carey, 1973; Corbin and Benson, 1983).

The estimated annual precipitation of 150 mm and an average of 25 mm during the summer months (June–August) would appear to be insufficient to support poplar growth, particularly considering that the seasonal thaw layer as determined from this study is more than 2 m thick. However, lithologic discontinuities in stratified fluvial sediments may suspend water in the unsaturated zone, which plants can readily use.

QUATERNARY HISTORY OF POPLARS ON THE NORTH SLOPE

It is not known when balsam poplar first appeared on the North Slope. The poplar grove examined at Cottonwood Creek contained clones ranging from 90 to 200 yr in age; a wood fragment from 52 cm below the modern soil surface was radiocarbon dated at 650 ± 50 BP. These data suggest that balsam poplar may have been on the North Slope for at least the past 650 yr. However, poplars may have existed at specific locations on the North Slope for thousands of years. Buried poplar logs along the north-flowing Sagavanirktok River and the Nigu River in the Brooks Range and in the floodplain of the Putuligayuk River near Prudhoe Bay were radiocarbon dated at 8400 ± 300 yr BP (Detterman, 1970), 11,100 BP (Hopkins et al., 1981), and 35,600 ± 550 BP (Hopkins et al., 1981), respectively, suggesting that poplar may even have been present during the mid-Wisconsin.

Therefore, it is likely that poplars on the North Slope of Alaska and in northwest Canada have occurred as groves or clumps on suitable sites throughout the Holocene (Mott, 1978; Hopkins et al., 1981). The natural pioneering characteristics of Populus and its ability to withstand severe climatic conditions make it adaptable to the harsh climatic conditions of the region (Ritchie and Hare, 1971). Whether or not the modern stands are relicts cannot be determined from this study. However, warm summers in Beringia during the early Holocene may have permitted poplar expansion (Hopkins et al., 1981). These warmer climatic conditions were associated with greater amounts of exposed land from marine regressions, creating a more continental climate.

The warming of arctic Alaska during the past three decades has resulted in increased shrub abundance (Sturm et al., 2001). This increase in shrub cover will alter the partitioning of energy in the summer, trapping of snow cover in the winter, and ecosystem carbon distribution. A major question is whether warming of arctic Alaska has affected the growth and distribution of balsam poplar.

Conclusions

A balsam poplar grove near the Ivishak River is composed of 11 clones that range from 90 to 200 yr in age and are spaced at distances of 50 to 250 m. The clones have slow radial and height growth rates that are similar to other clones studied on the North Slope. The clones originated from seeds carried over the Brooks Range either by wind or birds. Soil thermal, moisture, and nutrient regimes all appear to be most favorable within 100 m of the river. We prepared a map (Fig. 1) showing the distribution of 28 balsam poplar groves on the North Slope that is based on published reports, Land-Sat images, topographic maps, and observations of scientists and a bush pilot. The groves are invariably in areas of braided streams and aufeis deposits. In addition, the groves commonly are in areas of faulting and geothermal springs (Fig. 2). We developed a preliminary model (Fig. 3) showing that the distribution of balsam poplar in arctic Alaska is due to a unique combination of factors, including a steep topographic gradient, braided streams and aufeis deposits, the lack of near-surface permafrost within several hundred meters of the river, and stratified sediments that enhance retention of soil moisture in the rooting zone.

Acknowledgments

Funding for this work was provided by the National Science Foundation Office of Polar Programs and included grants to J. G. Bockheim (9912035) and K. M. Hinkel (9529783, 9732051). We are grateful to F. E. Nelson and W. Eisner, who provided funding for the soil and radiocarbon analyses, respectively. L. Rivers, bush pilot, identified several of the poplar grove locations. Figures 1 and 2 were produced by J. Nelson and J. Bell of the Soil Landscape Analysis Laboratory at the University of Minnesota.

References Cited

1.

D. L. Bartos and R. S. Johnston . 1978. Biomass and nutrient content of quaking aspen at two sites in the western United States. Forest Science 24:2273–280. Google Scholar

2.

J. G. Bockheim, D. A. Walker, L. R. Everett, F. E. Nelson, and N. I. Shiklomanov . 1998. Soils and cryoturbation in moist nonacidic and acidic tundra in the Kuparuk River basin, arctic Alaska, U.S.A. Arctic and Alpine Research 30:166–174. Google Scholar

3.

K. L. Carey 1973. Icings developed from surface water and ground water. Cold Regions Research and Engineering Laboratory. Hanover, NH. 65 pp. Google Scholar

4.

J. M. Childers, C. E. Sloan, J. P. Meckel, and J. W. Nauman . 1975. Hydrologic reconnaissance of the eastern North Slope, Alaska. United States Geological Survey Open-File Report 77–492, Anchorage, Alaska. 65 pp. Google Scholar

5.

S. W. Corbin and C. S. Benson . 1983. Thermal regime of a small Alaskan stream in permafrost terrain. In Proceedings of the 4th International Conference on Permafrost, July 17–22, 186–191. Google Scholar

6.

K. G. Dean 1986. Regional distribution of stream icings in Alaska. Cold Regions Hydrology Symposium, American Water Resources Association, 339–344. Google Scholar

7.

R. L. Detterman 1970. Early Holocene warm interval in northern Alaska. Arctic 23:130–132. Google Scholar

8.

M. E. Edwards and P. W. Dunwiddie . 1985. Dendrochronological and palynological observations on Populus balsamifera in northern Alaska, U.S.A. Arctic and Alpine Research 17:271–278. Google Scholar

9.

A. L. Gallant, E. F. Binnian, J. M. Omernik, and M. B. Shasby . 1995. Ecoregions of Alaska. United States Geological Survey Professional Paper 1567. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office. 73 pp. Google Scholar

10.

L. A. Gom and S. B. Rood . 1999. The discrimination of cottonwood clones in a mature grove along the Oldman River in southern Alberta. Canadian Journal of Botany 77:1084–1094. Google Scholar

11.

G. Gran 1952. Determination of the equivalence point in potentiometric titration. Part II. The Analyst 77:661–671. Google Scholar

12.

D. K. Hall 1980a. Analysis of the origin of water which forms large aufeis fields on the Arctic Slope of Alaska using ground and Landsat data. Ph.D. dissertation, Department of Geography, University of Maryland, College Park, MD. 118 p. Google Scholar

13.

D. K. Hall 1980b. Mineral precipitation in the North Slope river icings. Arctic 33:343–348. Google Scholar

14.

D. K. Hall and C. Roswell . 1981. The origin of water feeding icings on the eastern North Slope of Alaska. Polar Record 20:433–438. Google Scholar

15.

T. D. Hamilton 1986. Late Cenozoic glaciation of the central Brooks Range. In Hamilton, T. D., Reed, K. M., and Thorson, R. M. (eds.), Glaciation in Alaska: The Geologic Record. Anchorage, AK: Alaska Geological Society, 9–49. Google Scholar

16.

D. Harden, P. Barnes, and E. Reimnitz . 1977. Distribution and character of naleds in northeastern Alaska. Arctic 30:28–40. Google Scholar

17.

L. R. Hettinger and A. J. Janz . 1974. Vegetation and soils of northeastern Alaska. Northern Engineering Services Company, Alaskan Arctic Gas Study, Volume 21. 206 pp. Google Scholar

18.

G. T. Himes 1980. A preliminary study of the chemistry of icings and associated spring and surface waters of the northern Brooks Range, Alaska. MS thesis, Department of Geology, Indiana University, Bloomington, IN. 126 pp. Google Scholar

19.

D. M. Hopkins, P. A. Smith, and J. V. Matthews Jr. . 1981. Dated wood from Alaska and the Yukon: implications for forest refugia in Beringia. Quaternary Research 15:217–249. Google Scholar

20.

E. Hultén 1968. Flora of Alaska and Neighboring Territories: A Manual of Vascular Plants. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 331–717. Google Scholar

21.

B. Husch, C. I. Miller, and T. W. Beers . 1972. Forest Mensuration. New York: Ronald Press, 299–301. Google Scholar

22.

K-J. S. Kung 1993. Laboratory observation of funnel flow mechanism and its influence on solute transport. Journal of Environmental Quality 22:191–102. Google Scholar

23.

S. M. Landhaeusser and R. M. Wein . 1993. Postfire vegetation recovery and tree establishment at the arctic treeline: climate-change-vegetation-response hypothesis. Journal of Ecology 81:665–672. Google Scholar

24.

D. J. Lev 1987. Balsam poplar (Populus balsamifera) in Alaska: ecology and growth response to climate. MS thesis, College of Forest Resources, University of Washington, Seattle. 70 pp. Google Scholar

25.

S. Li, C. Benson, L. Shapiro, and K. Dean . 1997. Aufeis in the Ivishak River, Alaska, mapped from satellite radar interferometry. Remote Sensing Environment 60:131–139. Google Scholar

26.

J. F. Loneragan and K. Snowball . 1969. Calcium requirements of plants. Australian Journal of Agricultural Research 20:465–478. Google Scholar

27.

T. E. Moore, W. K. Wallace, K. J. Bird, S. M. Karl, C. G. Mull, and J. T. Dillon . 1994. Geology of northern Alaska. In Plafker, G., and Berg, H. C. (eds.), The Geology of Alaska. Boulder, CO: Geological Society of America, The Geology of North America, G-1: 49–140. Google Scholar

28.

R. J. Mott 1978. Populus in late-Pleistocene pollen spectra. Canadian Journal of Botany 56:1021–1023. Google Scholar

29.

D. F. Murray 1980. Balsam poplar in arctic Alaska. In Rutter, N. W., and Schweger, C. E. (eds.), The Ice-Free Corridor and Peopling the New World. Canadian Journal of Anthropology 1:29–32. Google Scholar

30.

G. C. Nanson and H. F. Beach . 1977. Forest succession and sedimentation on a meandering-river floodplain, northeast British Columbia, Canada. Journal of Biogeography 4:229–251. Google Scholar

31.

National Climatic Data Center. 1998. Precipitation and temperature data.  http://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/pub/data/coop-precip/ and  ftp://arcss.colorado.edu/pub/projects2/climate/Alaska_GHCN/alsktmp.dataGoogle Scholar

32.

J. A. Nava and P. Morrison . 1974. A note on hot springs in the interior of Alaska. Arctic 27:241–243. Google Scholar

33.

F. E. Nelson, N. I. Shiklomanov, G. R. Mueller, K. M. Hinkel, D. A. Walker, and J. G. Bockheim . 1997. Estimating active-layer thickness over a large region: Kuparuk River basin, Alaska, U.S.A. Arctic and Alpine Research 29:367–378. Google Scholar

34.

J. Pastor and J. G. Bockheim . 1984. Distribution and cycling of nutrients in an aspen-mixed hardwood Spodosol ecosystem in northern Wisconsin. Ecology 65:2339–353. Google Scholar

35.

J. C. Ritchie 1984. Past and Present Vegetation of the Far Northwest of Canada. Toronto: University of Toronto Press. 251 pp. Google Scholar

36.

J. C. Ritchie, L. C. Cwynar, and R. W. Spear . 1983. Evidence from north-west Canada for an early Holocene Milankovitch thermal maximum. Nature 305:126–128. Google Scholar

37.

J. C. Ritchie and F. K. Hare . 1971. The late-Quaternary vegetation and climate near the arctic tree line of northwestern North America. Quaternary Research 1:331–342. Google Scholar

38.

M. C. Serreze, J. E. Walsh, F. S. Chapin III, T. Osterkamp, M. Dyurgerov, V. Romanovsky, W. C. Oechel, J, Morison, T. Zhang, and R. G. Barry . 2000. Observational evidence of recent change in the northern high-latitude environment. Climatic Change 46:159–207. Google Scholar

39.

C. E. Sloan 1987. Water resources of the North Slope, Alaska. In Tailleur, I., and Weimer, P. (eds.). Alaska North Slope Geology, Vol. 1, 223–252. Google Scholar

40.

C. E. Sloan, C. Zenone, and L. R. Mayo . 1976. Icings along the Trans-Alaska Pipeline route. U.S. Geological Survey Professional Paper 979. 17 pp. Google Scholar

41.

Soil Survey Division Staff, 1993. Soil Survey Manual. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Agriculture Handbook No. 18. 437 pp. Google Scholar

42.

Soil Survey Staff, 1996. Soil Survey Methods Manual. Soil Survey Investigations Report No. 42, v. 3.0, January 1996. 693 pp. Google Scholar

43.

L. A. Spetzman 1951. Plant geography and ecology of the Arctic Slope of Alaska. MS thesis, Department of Botany, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN. 186 pp. Google Scholar

44.

M. Stuiver, P. J. Reimer, and R. W. Reimer . 2000. calib 4.3 www program and documentation.  http://www.calib.orgGoogle Scholar

45.

M. Sturm, R. Racine, and K. Tape . 2001. Increasing shrub abundance in the Arctic. Nature 411:546. Google Scholar

46.

L. A. Viereck and J. M. Foote . 1970. The status of Populus balsamifera and P. trichocarpa in Alaska. The Canadian Field-Naturalist 84:169–173. Google Scholar

47.

C. Wahrhaftig 1965. Physiographic divisions of Alaska. U.S. Geological Survey Professional Paper 482. 52 pp. Google Scholar

48.

I. L. Wiggins and J. H. Thomas . 1962. A Flora of the Alaskan Arctic Slope. Arctic Institute of North America Special Publication No. 4. Toronto: University of Toronto Press. 136 pp. Google Scholar

49.

J. C. Zasada and H. W. Phipps . 1990. Populus balsamifera L. Balsam poplar. In Burns, R. M. and Honkala, B. H. (eds.), Silvics of North America, Vol. 2: Hardwoods. Washington, DC: U.S. Forest Service, 518–529. Google Scholar

Appendices

FIGURE 1.

A map showing the location of balsam poplar groves in relation to braiding and aufeis development on major rivers on the North Slope of Alaska (numbered sites are described in Table 5)

i1523-0430-35-3-331-f01.gif

FIGURE 2.

A map showing the location of balsam poplar groves in relation to faulting and geothermal springs on the North Slope of Alaska

i1523-0430-35-3-331-f02.gif

FIGURE 3.

A preliminary model showing conditions favoring balsam poplar on the North Slope of Alaska

i1523-0430-35-3-331-f03.gif

TABLE 1

A comparison of vegetation and soil variables along a north-south transect with distance from the rivera

i1523-0430-35-3-331-t01.gif

TABLE 2

Chemical composition of Populus balsamifera in arctic Alaska by tissue and crown/stem position

i1523-0430-35-3-331-t02.gif

TABLE 3

Soil properties of representative pedons at the “Cottonwood Creek” balsam poplar site, North Slope of Alaska

i1523-0430-35-3-331-t03.gif

TABLE 4

Chemical composition of natural waters along the North Slope of Alaska

i1523-0430-35-3-331-t04.gif

TABLE 5

Physiographic features of sites containing balsam poplar

i1523-0430-35-3-331-t05.gif
J. G. Bockheim, J. D. O'Brien, J. S. Munroe, and K. M. Hinkel "Factors Affecting the Distribution of Populus balsamifera on the North Slope of Alaska, U.S.A," Arctic, Antarctic, and Alpine Research 35(3), 331-340, (1 August 2003). https://doi.org/10.1657/1523-0430(2003)035[0331:FATDOP]2.0.CO;2
Published: 1 August 2003
JOURNAL ARTICLE
10 PAGES


Share
SHARE
RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS
Get copyright permission
Back to Top