Identifying Eimeria spp. circulating in a poultry flock assists in designing vaccine preventive programs, as different species do not cross-protect. Because species differ in anticoccidial drug susceptibility, species identification can also be used to optimize anticoccidial medication. In the present study, we designed pan-Eimeria–specific primers for the 18S rDNA and the cytochrome oxidase I (COI) genes, and tested whether next-generation sequencing of their amplicons allowed reliable identification of Eimeria spp. in samples of isolated oocysts. For each gene, two sets of primers to be used in a nested PCR (nPCR) system were designed. In silico evaluation of the primers using published sequences showed that nucleotide sequence identities of the nested amplicons were less than 97% between most species, while only identities of 18S rDNA genes of Eimeria necatrix and Eimeria tenella and between the COI genes of Eimeria mitis and Eimeria mivati were higher than 97%. Three vaccines and five Eimeria samples from chickens in backyard flocks were investigated by nPCRs and by direct PCRs (dPCR) using the nested (inner) primers with genomic DNA as the template. Seventeen further Eimeria samples from chickens in backyard flocks and three Eimeria samples from commercial broiler flocks were investigated only by nPCR. Sequencing nPCR products tended to detect more species than sequencing dPCR products and sequencing 18S rDNA products tended to detect more species than sequencing COI products. Regarding the detected species, there was a clear difference between the commercial broiler flocks and the backyard flocks. Eimeria acervulina, Eimeria maxima, and E. tenella/E. necatrix were the only species detected in broiler flocks, while the population in the backyard flocks was more varied, with Eimeria brunetti and E. mitis/E. mivati and the previously described operational taxonomic unit Y being more prevalent. Several sequences having less than 97% identity with one of the sequences used for clustering were detected in samples from backyard flocks. In conclusion, next-generation amplicon sequencing can be a useful tool to determine which Eimeria spp. are circulating in chicken flocks.