Many questions remain concerning the viability and productivity of seeding native legumes in the Canadian Prairies for forage production. Field research was conducted with four native legume species (Astragalus flexuosus, Dalea purpurea, Hedysarum boreale, and Vicia americana) to evaluate performance in Swift Current and Saskatoon, SK. The experimental design was a randomized complete block design with four replicates to evaluate legume–grass mixtures and monoculture performance, botanical composition, and effect of harvest dates (July and August) from 2016 to 2018. The native legume–grass mixtures performed differently at the sites, with greater foliar cover at Saskatoon but a greater proportion of legumes in mixtures at Swift Current. The mixtures had similar forage nutritive value as monoculture Bromus riparius, with legumes contributing 10% or less of the forage dry matter yield (DMY) at both sites. Astragalus flexuosus showed the greatest foliar cover and produced the greatest DMY in monoculture at both sites. Based on this study, native legumes would need to make up a larger proportion of forage dry matter yield to change the nutritional value of mixtures. In a subsequent seeding rate evaluation, the four legume species were planted at three seeding rates [300, 200, and 100 pure live seeds (PLS) per metre] and tested for DMY one year following establishment near Swift Current. Increasing seeding rates up to 300 PLS·m⁻¹ corresponded with an increase in seedling density and foliar cover, but DMY was not affected. Additional research with A. flexuosus is needed to demonstrate its value as a forage.