Ration of food per capita of larval population is widely thought to limit mosquito production from container habitats, directly reflecting resource limitation. In this study, the importance of density-dependent resource limitation on larval Aedes triseriatus (Say) (Diptera: Culicidae) depended on the degree of microbial conditioning of senescent leaf detritus in surrogate tree holes. Density and ration strongly affected emergence, total female mass, and mean female mass of populations grown on leaves that had conditioned for 3 d, but had less impact when larval populations were grown on leaves that had conditioned for 1 mo. Ration per capita was a stronger predictor (50–94% of the variance) of all growth parameters measured for populations grown on leaves conditioned for 3 d compared with 1 mo (2–66% of variance), with the exception of development time. Larvae grew faster and to a larger body size on leaves conditioned for 3 d at low densities of larvae and a higher ration per capita. However, populations grown on leaves conditioned for 1 mo produced equal or more total mass and individuals of higher average mass than when grown on leaves conditioned for 3 d in treatments with low ration per capita. Well-conditioned detritus, representing the degree of microbial colonization of the organic material, must reflect the typical condition in tree holes with unconditioned leaves atypical. Therefore, results of this study suggest that experiments using well-conditioned leaves better estimate growth responses, including moderated density dependence and less importance of ration per capita, than experiments using unconditioned detritus.