Translator Disclaimer
31 December 2003 Further study of the Middle Ordovician cephalopod Holmiceras coreanicum with a revision of two Geisonoceras species from Korea
Author Affiliations +


In the cephalopod fauna from the Middle Ordovician Jigunsan Formation of Korea, the most abundant fossil is the lituitid Holmiceras coreanicum which is composed of an early coiled portion and a sigmoidally curved later portion (Yun, 1999). However, it is rare to discover complete individual specimens because of poor preservation, like other fossil nautiloids. Previously, Kobayashi (1934) described several annulated nautiloids as different species based on fragmentary specimens. Yun (1999) has shown that these could be reassigned to H. coreanicum.

H. coreanicum is characterized by having prominent annulations and fine growth lines on the shell surface. These features are, however, observed in other Ordovician nautiloid cephalopods from Korea, such as Holmiceras, Cycloceras, Geisonoceras, Sactorthoceras, Tofangoceras, Kogenoceras, Jiangshanoceras, Centroonoceras, Wennanoceras, Spyroceras, and Centrocyrtoceras. Among species of these genera, two species belong to Geisonoceras, G. hyatti Kobayashi, 1934 and G. abruptum Kobayashi, 1934. Kobayashi (1934) showed that the two species are characterized by having bands or raised lines on the shell surface, as can only be seen in the longitudinal section. The genus Geisonoceras is known to occur commonly from the Middle Ordovician strata in Europe and North America, but is uncommon in Asia.

In this study, the taxonomic position of the two Geisonoceras species from Korea is reexamined on the basis of observation of the type specimens. The specimens numbered with prefix UMUT and KPE are deposited in the University Museum, the University of Tokyo, Japan and the Department of Earth Science Education, Kyungpook National University, Korea, respectively.

Systematic paleontology

Order Tarphycerida Flower in Flower and Kummel, 1950

Family Lituitidae Phillips, 1848

Genus Holmiceras Hyatt, 1894

Type species.—Lituites praecurrens Holm, 1891 from the Middle Silurian of Bohemia, Original designation.

Holmiceras coreanicum (Kobayashi, 1927)

Orthoceras coreanicum Kobayashi, 1927, p. 181, pl. 18, fig. 6; pl. 19, figs. 3a-c.

Orthoceras makkolense Kobayashi, 1927, p. 181, pl. 19, figs. 2a-c.

Sigmorthoceras coreanicum (Kobayashi). Kobayashi, 1934, p. 413, pl. 22, fig. 7.

Sactorthoceras makkolense (Kobayashi). Kobayashi, 1934, p. 408, pl. 15, fig. 9.

Cycloceras sp. Kobayashi, 1934, p. 421, pl. 29, figs. 12-13.

Sinuitopsis kochiriensis Kobayashi, 1934, p. 360, pl. 5, figs. 1-4.

Geisonoceras hyatti Kobayashi, 1934, p. 415, pl. 23, figs. 3-4.

Geisonoceras abruptum Kobayashi, 1934, p. 416, pl. 20, fig. 3. aff. Trilacinoceras sp. Ozaki and Ogino, 1968, pl. 3, fig. 3.

Holmiceras coreanicum (Kobayashi). Yun, 1998, p. 78, figs. 1c-h; Yun, 1999, p. 68, figs. 3.1a, b, 2a, b; 4.1-4.10

Material studied.—Two type specimens UMUT PM653, UMUT PM654, 19 newly collected specimens (KPE20001-KPE20007, KPE20011, KPE20013, KPE20020, KPE20023, KPE20026-1, KPE20027, KPE20028, KPE20295, KPE20302, KPE20304, KPE20307, KPE20320) from the Middle Ordovician Jigunsan Formation, Sangdong area, Gangwondo, Korea (Yun, 1999, fig. 1).

Diagnosis.—Conch sigmoidally curved with early loosely coiled portion; body chamber long; circular in cross section; siphuncular segments somewhat expanded within camera; septal necks orthochoanitic; no cameral and annulosiphonate deposits present; surface ornamented with prominent annulations and very fine growth lines (Yun, 1999).

Description.—As given by Yun (1999).

Remarks.—This species has an orthochoanitic, subcentral siphuncle, a loosely coiled early stage, and surface ornamentation of growth banding and annulations. It is the most abundant species among the Korean Ordovician nautiloids. Several nautiloids previously reported from Korea were reassigned as synonyms of Holmiceras coreanicum (Yun, 1999).

Kobayashi (1934) proposed G. hyatti and G. abruptum from the Middle Ordovician Jigunsan Formation of Korea on the basis of the characteristics of growth bands on conch surface. Both species are based on the monotype, UMUT PM653 and UMUT PM654, respectively. The type species of the genus Geisonoceras Hyatt, 1884 is Orthoceras rivale Barrande, 1866 (figured pl. 209; described 1874, p. 383) from the Middle Silurian of Bohemia (Figure 1). The genus is diagnosed by the transverse lirae or broadly spaced bands which are occasionally adorally imbricated, and annulosiphonate, and have well developed cameral deposits (Sweet, 1964). The two species of Geisonoceras from Korea do not possess siphuncluar and cameral deposits, and they therefore cannot be placed in Geisonoceras.

Figure 1

Type species of Geisonoceras, Orthoceras rivale (Barrande). Reproduced from Barrande (1866) × 0.8.


Kobayashi (1934) stated that the two species have transverse ridges that incline more steeply backward than for-ward. My examination of the type specimens of G. hyatti and G. abruptum, however, shows that the inclination of the transverse ridges is almost symmetric rather than adorally imbricated (Figures 2, 3) and the asymmetrical pattern of the transverse ridges illustrated in Kobayashi (1934, pl. 20, fig. 3 and pl. 23, fig. 4) could not be observed either by the naked eye or optical microscopy.

Figure 2

Details of annulation represented on the longitudinal section. 1. Geisonoceras abruption Kobayashi, UMUT PM654, × 1.5. 2. Diagrammatic section of internal structure and surface ornamentation, showing the nearly symmetrical annulations, × 1.5.


Figure 3

Details of annulation represented on the longitudinal section. 1. Geisonoceras hyalti Kobayashi, UMUT PM653, × 1.5. 2. Diagrammatic section of internal structure and surface ornamentation, showing the nearly symmetrical annulations, × 1.5.


The intervals between the crests of annulations are comparable with those of other species of Homiceras as well as Cycloceras and Kogenoceras. As shown in Figure 4, the annulation intervals in the type specimens of the two Geisonoceras species from Korea are nearly identical with those of H. coreanicum. Additionally, the two Geisonoceras species and H. coreanicum commonly have annulation intervals even narrower than those of Cycloceras and Kogenoceras, both with strong annulations. Consequ-ently, G. hyatti and G. abruptum are regarded as synonymous with H. coreanicum in the following features: no annulosiphonate and cameral deposits in the phragmocone and narrowly spaced symmetrical annulations in both sides of conch. Without exception, H. coreanicum has fine growth lines and relatively strong annulations on the conch surface (see Yun, 1999, fig. 4.10). Also, its conch surface on the ventral side has prominently lobed growth lines and ridges in the juvenile stage (see Yun, 1999, fig. 4.2, 4.10).

Figure 4

Comparison of annulation intervals in several nautiloids with annulalions. The specimens belonging to Geisonoceras and Holmiceras commonly have even narrower intervals than those of Cycloceras and Kogenoceras, both with strong annulations. The specimens with prefix KPE are all Holmiceras coreanicum (Kobayashi).



The author is grateful to Kazushige Tanabe of the Department of Earth and Planetary Science, University of Tokyo for help in collecting fossil specimens and valuable suggestions, and Takeo Ichikawa of the University Museum of the University of Tokyo for access to the UMUT specimens examined. I am indebted to Seong-Young Yang of the Department of Earth Science Education, Kyungpook National University in Korea for his kind advice and encouragement. Special thanks are due to Royal H. Mapes of the Department of Geological Sciences, Ohio University for his critical review.



J. Barrande 1866. Système Silurien du centre de la Bohime, Parlie I, Recherches Paléontologiques. Vol. 2, des Mollusques, Ordre des Céphalopodes pls. 108–244. Google Scholar


R. H. Flower and B. Kummel Jr. . 1950. A classification of the Nautiloidea. Journal of Paleontology 24/5:604–616. Google Scholar


G. Holm 1891. Om mynningen hos Lituites Breyn. Geologiska Föreningcns I Stockholm Förhandlingar. 13/7:736–774. Google Scholar


A. Hyatt 1894. Phylogeny of an acquired characteristic. Proceedings of the American Philosophical Societ32/143:349–647. Google Scholar


T. Kobayashi 1927. Ordovician fossils from Corea and South Manchuria. Japanese Journal of Geology and Geography 5/4:173–212. Google Scholar


T. Kobayashi 1934. The Cambro-Ordovician formations and faunas of South Chosen. Palaeontology. Part. I, Middle Ordovician faunas. Journal of the Faculty of Science, University of Tokyo, Section II 3:part 8. 363–519. Google Scholar


K. Ozaki and S. Ogino . 1968. On the macrofauna from the Jigunsan Shale in the Jangseong area, Kangweondo, Korea. in H. Aramaki and T. Yamaguchi , editors. eds.. Report of Geological Expeditionary Parly in Kangweondo, Korea. 21–38. pls. 1–7. Geological Society of Yokohama. Yokohama. in JapaneseGoogle Scholar


J. Phillips 1848. The Malvern Hills, compared with the Palaeozoic districts of Abberlcy. Woolhope, May Hill, Tortworth and Usk. Geological Survey of Great Britain, Memoir, Pt. I 2:246–250. Google Scholar


W. C. Sweet 1964. Nautiloidea-Orthocerida, Mollusca 3. in R. C. Moore , editor. ed.. Treatise on Invertebrate Paleontology, Part K. 216–261.Geological Society of America and University of Kansas Press. Lawrence. Google Scholar


C. S. Yun 1998. First discovery of Holmiceras from the Jigunsan Formation of Korea. Abstracts with Programs, the 1998 Annual Meeting of the Palaeontological Society of JapanJan. 30-Feb. 1, 1998Odawara78. Google Scholar


C. S. Yun 1999. Three Ordovician cephalopods from the Jigunsan Formation of Korea. Paleontological Research 3/2:65–81. Google Scholar
CHEOLSOO YUN "Further study of the Middle Ordovician cephalopod Holmiceras coreanicum with a revision of two Geisonoceras species from Korea," Paleontological Research 7(4), 363-366, (31 December 2003).
Received: 10 May 2002; Accepted: 1 September 2003; Published: 31 December 2003

Back to Top