1 July 2006 The ability of 29 barley cultivars to compete and withstand competition
Paul R. Watson, Douglas A. Derksen, Rene C. Van Acker
Author Affiliations +

Using competitive crops and cultivars can be an important integrated weed management (IWM) tool, useful in both conventional and low-external-input (LEI) farming systems. Barley is considered a competitive crop, but cultivar competitiveness varies. There are two aspects of cultivar competitive ability; the ability to compete (AC) and the ability to withstand competition (AWC). However, the relationship between these aspects has not been addressed in barley. A study was conducted to explore aspects of barley cultivar competitive ability with oats, and to examine the feasibility of ranking cultivars based on either, or both, AWC and AC. Field trials were undertaken in 2001 and 2002 to determine cultivar competitive ability for 29 barley cultivars commonly grown on the Canadian prairies. Cultivars were selected from semidwarf and full height, hulled and hull-less, 2- and 6-row, and feed and malt classes. Yield loss ranged from 6 to 79% while weed seed return ranged from 10 to 83% of gross yield. As a class, semidwarf and hull-less cultivars were less competitive than full height and hulled cultivars, respectively. However, considerable variation existed within these classes, and an absolute relationship between class membership and competitive ability did not exist. Ability to withstand competition was significantly correlated with ability to compete, but correlation coefficients were not strong enough to attempt reliable co-selection within a breeding program. Ability to compete was a more consistent measure of competitive ability than AWC. Ranking barley cultivar competitive ability would make it a valuable IWM tool for farmers and extension personnel.

Nomenclature: Barley, Hordeum vulgare L.; oat, Avena sativa L. cv. AC Assiniboia.

Paul R. Watson, Douglas A. Derksen, and Rene C. Van Acker "The ability of 29 barley cultivars to compete and withstand competition," Weed Science 54(4), 783-792, (1 July 2006). https://doi.org/10.1614/WS-05-020R3.1
Received: 22 February 2005; Accepted: 1 April 2006; Published: 1 July 2006
competitive cultivar
integrated weed management
Weed competition
Get copyright permission
Back to Top