How to translate text using browser tools
1 January 2018 A Systems Comparison of Contrasting Organic Weed Management Strategies
Bryan Brown, Eric R. Gallandt
Author Affiliations +

Weed management strategies differ in their ability to control weeds, and often have unique agroecological implications. To provide growers with an improved sense of trade-offs between weed control and ecological effects, we implemented several prominent organic weed management strategies in yellow onion in 2014 and 2015. Strategies included cultivation of weed seedlings during the early, weed-sensitive “critical period” of the crop; frequent cultivation events to ensure “zero seed rain”; and weed suppression with polyethylene or natural mulches. As expected, end-of-season weed biomass and weed seed production were greatest in the critical period system and nearly zero for the zero seed rain system. Weeds were also well controlled in natural mulch systems. Average onion yield per treatment was 50.7Mg ha-1. In 2014, the critical period system and the polyethylene mulch systems demonstrated yield loss, likely due to weed competition and excessive soil temperature, respectively. Onion soluble solids content was also diminished in these systems in 2014, but bulb firmness was greatest in unmulched systems. Carabid beetles, earthworms, soil compaction, soil nitrate, and microbial biomass were affected by weed management strategy, with naturalmulched systems generally performing most favorably. However, these effects were not substantial enough to affect yield of a subsequent sweet corn crop grown in weed-free conditions. In contrast, sweet corn managed with only early-season cultivations demonstrated yield loss (P = 0.004) in plots where the critical period treatment was implemented the prior year, indicating that weed competition resulting from abundant weed seed production in that system was the most influential legacy effect of the weed management strategies.

Nomenclature: Onion, Allium cepa L.; corn, Zea mays L.

© Weed Science Society of America, 2017
Bryan Brown and Eric R. Gallandt "A Systems Comparison of Contrasting Organic Weed Management Strategies," Weed Science 66(1), 109-120, (1 January 2018).
Received: 16 January 2017; Accepted: 1 May 2017; Published: 1 January 2018
critical period
organic management
systems comparison
weed management
zero seed rain
Get copyright permission
Back to Top