How to translate text using browser tools
1 December 2004 Evaluation of deterrent techniques and dogs to alter behavior of “nuisance” black bears
Jon P. Beckmann, Carl W. Lackey, Joel Berger
Author Affiliations +

The general public often prefers nonlethality when dealing with problem black bears (Ursus americanus). We evaluated the efficacy of nonlethal deterrent techniques on 62 bears in the Lake Tahoe Basin of the Sierra Nevada range. We contrasted animals randomly assigned to a control (no treatment) group (n = 21), an experimental (treatment) group (n = 21), or a treatment dog group (n = 20). Experimental bears were peppersprayed, shot with 12-gauge rubber buckshot and a rubber slug, and exposed to cracker shells. Bears in the treatment dog group were chased by hounds in addition to the combination of other deterrents. We tested and modeled the effectiveness of deterrents and dogs using a survival analysis with Cox proportional hazards and ANOVA. Relative success was evaluated by the latency of time (days) between treatment and return to the urban patch (RUP). Predictor variables in the saturated model included age, weight, season, sex, distance moved, and treatment. Only treatment remained in the most parsimonious model. However, mean number of days until RUP did not vary among the 3 treatment levels (ANOVA, P = 0.55). In all but 5 of 62 cases, bears eventually returned to the urban patch in which they were captured; 33 of 62 bears (53%) returned within 1 month and 70% (n = 44) of all bears returned in ≤40 days. We conclude that in the Lake Tahoe Basin the most common nonlethal deterrents, used by agencies responsible for black bear management, are not very effective at altering bear behavior over periods of time >1 month.

Jon P. Beckmann, Carl W. Lackey, and Joel Berger "Evaluation of deterrent techniques and dogs to alter behavior of “nuisance” black bears," Wildlife Society Bulletin 32(4), 1141-1146, (1 December 2004).[1141:EODTAD]2.0.CO;2
Published: 1 December 2004

This article is only available to subscribers.
It is not available for individual sale.

black bears
Lake Tahoe
Sierra Nevada
Ursus americanus
Get copyright permission
Back to Top