Open Access
How to translate text using browser tools
1 October 1997 Winter Survival and Freeze Tolerance in a Northern Cockroach, Periplaneta japonica (Blattidae: Dictyoptera)
Kazuhiro Tanaka, Seiji Tanaka
Author Affiliations +

Cold tolerance of overwintering nymphs of a cockroach, Periplaneta japonica, was examined in terms of the supercooling capacity and lower lethal temperature. The supercooling point of overwintering nymphs fell in a relatively narrow range of temperature from -6 to -9°C and no correlation was observed between the supercooling point and body size. In the temperature range from -5 to -8°C, a significant proportion of cockroaches could tolerate a 12 hr period of tissue freezing. The freeze tolerance capacity differed between nymphal instars, but the supercooling capacity was similar for all nymphs. In a freezing trial at -6 and -7°C, none of the first instar nymphs recovered after tissue freezing, whereas many mid (from 3rd to 5th) and final (8th) instar nymphs survived freezing. Glucose, myo-inositol, scyllo-inositol and trehalose were found in overwintering nymphs, but neither the array nor the content except for trehalose differed among the nymphal instars. Unexpectedly, the concentration of trehalose was negatively correlated to freeze tolerance. Winter survival of this cockroach may be based on both the freeze tolerance and microhabitat selection.


Periplaneta japonica Karny occurs in cool-temperate regions and is common in northern Japan. It is semivoltine and overwinters twice as a nymph in northern areas (Tsuji and Mizuno, 1972; Shindo and Masaki, 1995), but partly univoltine in a southern population (Tanaka and Uemura, 1996). Nymphal development is under the control of photoperiod and temperature, and all nymphal instars except for the first one have an ability to enter diapause (Tsuji and Mizuno, 1972; Shindo and Masaki, 1995), although this species may overwinter in any nymphal instar including the first one (Tanaka and Uemura, 1996).

Overwintering nymphs of P. japonica are found in decayed wood material or under the bark of trees (Tabaru and Kobayashi, 1971; Tsuji and Tabaru, 1974; Shindo and Masaki, 1995; Tanaka and Uemura, 1996). Since such hibernacula are not always covered by insulative snow (K.Tanaka, unpublished observations), overwintering individuals may encounter a subzero temperature. Thus, it seems essential for this cockroach to have cold tolerance for successful overwintering.

Although P. japonica is the most northern species of all Japanease cockroaches, its cold hardiness has received relatively little attention. Tsuji and Mizuno (1973) assessed the cold hardiness of last instar nymphs and adults to test their possible overwintering success under outdoor conditions in central Japan. In their study, however, the lowest temperature used was +5.5°C and no investigation was carried out at subzero temperatures. The purpose of the present study is to examine the cold tolerance of this cockroach in more detail, particularly whether or not they can survive freezing. Here, we determined the supercooling point (SCP), the temperature at which spontaneous freezing occurs, and the lower lethal temperature of nymphs overwintering in Tsukuba, central Japan.



Our stock cultures of P. japonica used for the present study originated from adults and nymphs collected in an oak forest of the Toyosato Park, Ibaraki in June 1993. They were reared in plastic containers (20 × 35 × 26 cm) and were fed insect feed (Oriental Yeast Co. Tokyo, Japan) and slices of carrot by the method of Shindo and Masaki (1995). Newly hatched nymphs were placed on a veranda facing north on the 3rd floor of a building of NISES, Tsukuba, Japan on different dates from spring to autumn in 1995. Nymphs encountered winter at different instars, depending on the date of hatching: the later the time of hatching the earlier the nymphal instar in winter (Tanaka and Uemura, 1996). In the present study, cockroaches in January and February were regarded as overwintering individuals.

Supercooling point (SCP)

To determine the SCP, cockroaches were individually put into a test tube (10 mm diam. × 40 mm height) in which the specimen was in contact with the tip of a thermocouple connected to a computer (PC-9801F). The test tube was covered twofold with a glass vial (30 mm diam. × 65 mm height) and a plastic vial (60 mm diam. × 100 mm height) to reduce the cooling rate to ca. 1°C/min when placed in a freezer (ca. -24°C). The SCP was determined by a release of the latent heat due to ice formation within the body of the test animal. The same method was used to determine the SCP of haemolymph. 1 μl of haemolymph was collected in a glass capillary (Drummound 5 μl) by cutting a leg of the cockroaches. The glass capillary was then attached to the thermocouple to record the SCP of haemolymph.

Freeze tolerance

To assess the lower lethal temperature, test animals were cooled at 1°C/min to a certain temperature within the range from -5 to -12°C. When body temperature of the test animals reached the desired level, they were removed from the freezer. Both frozen and non-frozen individuals were transferred to 25°C and supplied with food for 30 days. Survival was assessed by observing their walking activity or moulting during this period; only those which showed normal walking or moulting to the next nymphal instar or the adult stage were regarded as survivors. To assess the long-term freeze tolerance, the test animals were cooled at 1 °C/min to a certain temperature ranging from -5 to -8°C and kept at that temperature for 12 hr. After the freezing trials, the test specimens were transferred to 25°C and supplied with food for 30 days. Their survival was assessed as described above. In addition, subsequent reproductive capability of some females that had been frozen at either-6 or-7°C as final instar nymphs was monitored. During the 12 hr freezing trials, the body temperature of test animals was individually monitored to determine when freezing occurred. To compare the freeze tolerance among nymphal in-stars, first (1st), mid (from 3rd to 5th) and final (8th) instar nymphs were applied to 12 hr freezing trials.

Sugar and polyol contents

Cockroaches were homogenized individually with 4 ml of 80% ethanol in a glass homogenizer and then 1 mg of erythritol was added as an internal standard according to the method of Shimada et al. (1984). The homogenate was centrifuged at 3,000 × g for 15 min and the supernatant evaporated in a stream of N2 gas at 59.5°C until dry. To the residue, 0.05 ml of trimethylsilylating reagent (TMSI-C, GL Science Inc., Tokyo) was added and the solution heated at 65°C for 40 min. The resulting derivative was injected into a gas chromato-graph (GC-4CMPF, Shimadzu, Kyoto) with a glass column (3 mm × 3 m) containing 1.5% OV-1. The column was heated from 130 to 270°C at 5°C/min and then kept at the final temperature for 10 min. Compounds were identified based on the retention time of standard mixtures of known carbohydrates.


Thermal conditions

Ambient temperatures recorded at a research plot of NiSES during the study period are given in Table 1. The lowest temperature recorded in the winter of 1995-96 was -8,5°C on 22 February. Daily maximum temperature was always above 0°C, thus indicating that subzero temperatures never lasted 24 hr.

Table 1

A summary of temperature records at a research plot of NISES, Tsukuba in the winter of 1995-96


Supercooling points

Figure 1 plots the SCPs of overwintering nymphs against their body weight. In spite of the large variation in body weight (range: 3.7-589.8 mg), the SCPs fell in a relatively narrow range of temperature from -6 to -9°C and no significant correlation was observed between SCPs and body weight (r2 = 0.011, P>0.05). Thus, the SCP of this cockroach was not influenced by the nymphal stage. A comparison between SCPs of the whole animals and haemolymph indicated that the SCP was about 16 deg lower for the haemolymph (-23.1 ± 1.8°C [mean ± s.d], n = 7) than for the whole cockroach (-7.4 ± 0.5°C, n = 6) (t-test, t = 19.1, P<0.01).

Fig. 1

Effect of body size (wet weight) on individual supercooling points of P. japonica nymphs in January and February.


Freeze tolerance

The proportion of cockroaches which froze increased as the temperature decreased (Fig. 2). In this experiment, a frozen individual was first obtained at -6°C and all individuals were frozen at -9°C. After an exposure to a temperature below -9°C, however, a significant portion of individuals resumed activity and development at 25°C. This means that this cockroach has some degree of freeze tolerance. The calculated median lower lethal temperature, the temperature at which 50% of test individuals died, was -8.3°C, while the mean SCP was -6.7°C.

Fig. 2

Proportions of final instar nymphs of P. japonica that remain unfrozen by a short-term exposure to sub-zero temperatures (continuous line and circles) and subsequent survival (dashed line and triangles) assessed after transfer to 25°C. All unfrozen animals survived in this experiment. N = 9 -18 per temperature.


To elucidate the freeze tolerant ability in more detail, final instar nymphs were exposed to various sub-zero temperatures for 12 hr and then their survival was assessed at 25°C. During the freezing trial, all test individuals were frozen at least within the first 3 hr. The results are summarized in Fig. 3. Even after the relatively long-term tissue freezing, a significant portion of individuals resumed activity and development at 25°C. The survival of frozen individuals was dependent on the temperature experienced. It exceeded 73% at -5°C, but fell to 33% at -8°C.

Fig. 3

Effect of 12 hr tissue freezing at various sub-zero temperatures on survival of final instar nymphs of P. japonica. After freezing, nymphs were transferred to 25°C and checked for survival. N = 11-22 per temperature.


To assess the influence of tissue freezing on future reproductive capability, newly emerged females that had been frozen for 12 hr at -6 or -7°C as final instar nymphs were mated with a male and subsequent hatching success of eggs produced was measured at LD, 16:8 and 25°C. All females monitored (N=9) produced viable eggs, thus suggesting that tissue freezing at the nymphal stage did not influence the reproductive capability.

A comparison of freezing tolerance among the first, mid (3rd to 5th) and finai (8th) instar nymphs is shown in Fig. 4. In this experiment, all individuals were kept at -6 or -7°C for 12 hr before they were transferred to 25°C. After an exposure to either -6 or -7°C, none of the first instar nymphs recovered after relatively long-term tissue freezing, whereas a significant portion of the mid and last instar nymphs did recover. The values for last instar nymphs in this experiment were greater than those in Fig. 3. However, the differences between the two experiments based on rather small sample sizes were statistically insignificant (Fisher's exact test, P>0.05 in either case).

Fig. 4

Effect of 12 hr tissue freezing on survival of first, mid (from 3rd to 5th) and final (8th) instar nymphs of P. japonica at -6 or -7°C. N = 6-14 per instar.


Sugar and polyol contents

Gas chromatography assays indicated that at least four compounds were present in the whole body extracts of P. japonica. From the retention time, they were identified as glucose, myo-inositol, scyllo-inositol and trehalose (Table 2). Among the nymphal instars examined, no apparent difference was found in the array and content of carbohydrates except for trehalose which tended to decrease as nymphs grew older (F=20.158, P<0.01).

Table 2

Mean ± S.D. concentrations of polyhydric alcohols and sugars in whole body extracts of first, mid (from 3rd to 5th) and final (8th) instar nymphs of P. japonica in late January. Values are expressed as μg/mg wet weight



To tolerate subzero temperatures, at least two options have been exploited by terrestrial arthropods (see recent re-Table 2. Mean ± S.D. concentrations of polyhydric alcohols and sugars in whole body extracts of first, mid (from 3rd to 5th) and final (8th) instar nymphs of P. japonica in late January. Values are expressed as μg/mg wet weight views by Block, 1990; Duman et al., 1991). One is freeze tolerance in which the animal can tolerate extracellular freezing, and the other is supercooling because animals are susceptible to freezing.

The present results indicate that overwintering nymphs of P. japonica have some degree of freeze tolerance and a significant portion of individuals survived freezing lasting at least 12 hr (Fig. 3). This result may be ecologically relevant because sub-zero temperatures occur only during certain hours of the day even in mid-winter (Table 1). We used successful moulting to the next instar or normal walking as a criterion of survival in test animals. This method should be sufficient to draw the above conclusion, but one may argue that reproductive capability should also be checked for these animals to define the significance of the freeze tolerance observed in the present study. We monitored subsequent reproductive capability of some females that had been frozen as final in-star nymphs. As expected, such individuals produced viable eggs after mating with a male. To our knowledge, this is a third example of freeze tolerant cockroach following the previous two species; Parcoblatta pennsylvanica (Duman, 1979) and Cryptocercus punctulatus (Hamilton et al., 1985), although the reproductive capability post-thaw was not assessed in these two species.

In January and February, overwintering nymphs of P. japonica retained a relatively high SCP (Fig. 1) compared to other overwintering insects (see Somme, 1982; Zachariassen, 1980, 1985). This fact may indicate that they have some active ice-nucleating agent in their body. It has been well known that some freeze-tolerant species produce ice nucleating agents or proteins in the haemolymph, and these agents are thought to control ice formation and the rate of its spread over the body, thereby avoid lethal intracelluler freezing (see reviews by Zachariassen, 1985; Duman et al., 1995). In P. japonica, however, no ice nucleating activity was observed in the haemolymph which had a SCP of as low as -23°C (Table 2). Thus, ice nucleators may exist in other tissues. In other freeze-tolerant insects, ice nucleators are found in the alimentary canal (Shimada, 1989), muscle tissue (Tsumuki and Konno, 1991), fat body cells and Malpighian tubules (Mugano et al., 1996).

In P. japonica, the median lower lethal temperature of overwintering nymphs after a brief exposure to sub-zero temperatures was -8.3°C. Because this value is close to the minimum ambient temperature in Tsukuba (-8,5°C) (Table 1), it is possible that overwintering nymphs suffer some freezing injury. To avoid such a risk and overwinter successfully, micro-habitat selection in seeking for a protected hibernaculum may be an important strategy. This cockroach is known to overwinter in decayed wood material or under the bark of trees (Tabaru and Kobayashi, 1971; Tsuji and Tabaru, 1974). Although we do not have precise data for the microhabitat temperature of this species, such hibernacula would provide some protection against freezing temperatures. Winter survival of P. japonica is thus likely to be ensured by both behavioural microhabitat selection and freeze tolerance capacity.

It is noteworthy that none of the first instar nymphs recovered after freezing trials at -6 and -7°C, while some mid and final instar nymphs survived freezing (Fig. 4). This may suggest that first instar nymphs are susceptible to freezing. At present, however, we cannot rule out completely the possibility that they are potentially tolerant to freezing because various other factors often influence the expression of freeze tolerance. In the carabid beetle, Upis ceramboides, for example, the cooling rate is critical for freezing survival at -50°C for 1 hr, and a slight change in cooling rate from 0.3 to 0.5°C/min resulted in a change in the survival rate from 100 to 0% (Miller, 1978). Recent studies also demonstrated that several arthropod species survive freezing only when inoculative freezing occurs (e.g. Tanno, 1977; Shimada and Riihimaa, 1988; Gehrken et al., 1991; Tursman et al., 1994). In the present study, the test animals were cooled relatively rapidly (ca. 1 °C/min) and inoculative freezing was not applied. Our results have also demonstrated that the array and content of sugars and polyols, potential cryoprotectants, did not differ greatly among the nymphal instars (Table 2). In fact, the concentration of trehalose in the most susceptible stage, i.e., the first instar, was the highest. Therefore, the quantity or quality of cryoprotectants does not explain the observed high susceptibility of first instar nymphs to sub-zero temperatures.

The above finding that first instar nymphs are less cold-hardy than others, together with the fact that the former lack the capacity to enter diapause (Shindo and Masaki, 1995), might suggest some differences in overwintering success between the first and the other nymphal instars in P. japonica. However, first instar nymphs hatching late in the growing season can overwinter in central Japan (Tanaka and Uemura, 1996). This also appears to be true for northern populations because a sample collected in mid-October in Hirosaki (40.3°N) contained first instar nymphs, which could overwinter successfully when reared under outdoor conditions in central Japan (36.1°N) (Tanaka and Uemura, 1996). It is likely that first instar nymphs avoid the risk of freezing by remaining deep inside their winter hibernacula. During the growing season, nymphs normally remain hidden during the day, but appear on the bark of trees at night. However, first instar nymphs, which show a relatively strong tendency to aggregate, are seldom found at exposed sites at night. This behavioural difference may have left the first nymphal instar devoid of freeze tolerance. To understand the thermal adaptation of this insect fully, more information about behaviour of the nymphs and the thermal conditions of their microhabitats is necessary.


This research was supported by a KA-SHIN-CHOU project of the Science and Technology Agency of Japan. Experiments were undertaken while KT was a research fellow at the Department of Insect Physiology and Behavior, National Institute of Sericultural and Entomological Science, Tsukuba, Japan. Thanks are also due to Nobuo Morimoto, National Institute of Agro-environmental Science, for letting us use the apparatus for SCP determinations and Noriko Kenmochi, Sumi Ogawa and Hiroko Ikeda for technical assistance. Finally, we wish to thank Kimio Shimada, Hokkaido University, for giving us invaluable suggestions throughout the present study and kindly reviewing the manuscript, and two anonymous reviewers for helping to improve the presentation of our data and to sharpen our arguments.



W. Block 1990. Cold tolerance of insects and other arthropods. Phil Trans R Soc Lond 326 B:613–633. Google Scholar


J. G. Duman 1979. Thermal-hysteresis-factors in overwintering insects. J Insect Physiol 25:805–810. Google Scholar


J. G. Duman, D. W. Wu, L. Xu, D. Tursman, and T. M. Olsen . 1991. Adaptation of insects to subzero temperature. Quart Rev Biol 66:387–410. Google Scholar


J. G. Duman, T. M. Olsen, K. L. Yeung, and F. Jerva . 1995. The role of ice nuclea-tors in cold tolerant invertebrates. In “Biological Ice Nucleation and Its Application”. Ed by R. E. Lee, G. J. Warren, and L. V. Gusta , editors. APS Press. St Paul, Minnesota. pp. 201–219. Google Scholar


U. Gehrken, A. Stromme, R. Lundheim, and K. E. Zachariassen . 1991. Inoculative freezing in overwintering Tenebrionid beetle, Bolitopphagus reticulatus Panz. J Insect Physiol 37:683–687. Google Scholar


R. L. Hamilton, D. E. Mullins, and D. M. Orcutt . 1985. Freeze-tolerance in the woodroach Cryptocercus punctulatus (Scudder). Experientia 41:1535–1537. Google Scholar


L. K. Miller 1978. Freezing tolerance in relation to cooling rate in an adult insect. Cryobiology 15:345–349. Google Scholar


J. A. Mugano, R. E. Lee, and R. T. Taylor . 1996. Fat body cells and calcium phosphate spherules induce ice nucleation in the freeze-tolerant larvae of the gall fly Eurosta solidaginis (Diptera, Tephritidae). J Exp Biol 199:465–471. Google Scholar


K. Shimada 1989. Ice-nucleating activity in the alimentary canal of the freeze-tolerant prepupae of Trichiocampus populi (Hy-menoptera: Tenthredinidae). J Insect Physiol 35:113–120. Google Scholar


K. Shimada and A. Riihimaa . 1988. Cold acclimation, inoculative freezing and slow cooling: Essential factors contributing to the freezing-tolerance in diapausing larvae of Chymomyza costata (Diptera: Drosophilidae). Cryo-Letters 9:5–10. Google Scholar


K. Shimada, S. F. Sakagami, K. Honma, and H. Tsutsui . 1984. Seasonal changes of glycogen/trehalose contents, supercooling point and survival rate in matured larvae of the overwintering soybean pod borer Leguminivora glycinovorella. J Insect Physiol 30:369–373. Google Scholar


J. Shindo and S. Masaki . 1995. Photoperiodic control of larval development in the semivoltine cockroach Periplaneta japonica (Blattidae: Dictyoptera). Ecol Res 10:1–12. Google Scholar


L. Somme 1982. Supercooling and winter survival in terrestrial arthropods. Comp Biochem Physiol 73A:519–543. Google Scholar


Y. Tabaru and A. Kobayashi . 1971. Outdoor hibernation of Periplaneta japonica (Blattaria: Blattidae) in snowy area. Jap J Sanit Zool 22:76–77. in Japanease with English summary. Google Scholar


S. Tanaka and Y. Uemura . 1996. Flexible life cycle of a cockroach Periplaneta japonica with nymphal diapause. J Orth Res 5:213–219. Google Scholar


K. Tanno 1977. Ecological observation and frost-resistance in overwintering prepupae, Sciara sp. (Sciaridae). Low Temp Sci 35B:63–74. In Japanease with English summary. Google Scholar


H. Tsuji and T. Mizuno . 1972. Retardation of development and reproduction in four species of cockroaches, Blattella germanica, Periplaneta americana, P. fuliginosa and P. japonica under various temperature conditions. Jap J Sanit Zool 23:101–111. Google Scholar


H. Tsuji and T. Mizuno . 1973. Effect of a low temperature on the survial and development of four species of cockroaches, Blattella germanica, Periplaneta americana, P. fuliginosa and P. japonica. Jap J Sanit Zool 23:185–194. Google Scholar


H. Tsuji and Y. Tabaru . 1974. Stage composition of overwintering field populations of the Japanease cockroach, Periplaneta japonica. Jap J Sanit Zool 24:215–218. Google Scholar


H. Tsumuki and H. Konno . 1991. Tissue distribution of the ice-nucleating agents in larvae of the rice stem borer, Chilo suppressalis Walker (Lepidoptera: Pyraalidae). Cryobiology 28:376–381. Google Scholar


D. Tursman, J. G. Duman, and C. A. Knight . 1994. Freeze tolerance adaptations in the centipede, Lithobius forficatus. J Exp Zool 268:347–353. Google Scholar


K. E. Zachariassen 1980. The role of polyols and nucleating agents in cold-hardy beetles. J Comp Physiol 140B:227–234. Google Scholar


K. E. Zachariassen 1985. Physiology of cold tolerance in insects. Physiol Rev 65:799–832. Google Scholar
Kazuhiro Tanaka and Seiji Tanaka "Winter Survival and Freeze Tolerance in a Northern Cockroach, Periplaneta japonica (Blattidae: Dictyoptera)," Zoological Science 14(5), 849-853, (1 October 1997).
Received: 24 April 1997; Accepted: 1 June 1997; Published: 1 October 1997
Back to Top