Open Access
1 January 2005 Hybrid Male Sterility between the Fresh- and Brackish-water Types of Ninespine Stickleback Pungitius pungitius (Pisces, Gasterosteidae)
Hiroshi Takahashi, Terumi Nagai, Akira Goto
Author Affiliations +

Two ecologically distinct forms, fresh- and brackish-water types, of ninespine stickleback coexist in several freshwater systems on the coast of eastern Hokkaido. Recent genetic analyses of 13 allozyme loci revealed genetic separation between the two types even though their spawning grounds were in close proximity. On the other hand, there is only a small difference in mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) sequence between the two types suggesting that they diverged quite recently or that mtDNA introgression occurred between them. To test for postzygotic reproductive isolating mechanisms and hybrid mediated gene flow, we examined the viability and reproductive performance of reciprocal F1 hybrids. The hybrids grew to the adult size normally and both sexes expressed secondary sexual characters in the reciprocal crosses. The female hybrids were reciprocally fertile, while the male hybrids were reciprocally sterile. Histological and flow-cytometric analyses of the hybrid testis revealed that the sterility pattern was classified as ‘gametic sterility,’ with gonads of normal size but abnormal spermatogenesis. To our knowledge, the present finding is a novel example of one sex hybrid sterility in the stickleback family (Gasterosteidae).


The ninespine stickleback Pungitius pungitius is a small euryhaline fish belonging to the family Gasterosteidae (Pisces) known as sticklebacks, an important model system in evolutionary biology (Mattern, 2004). This species has a nearly continuous circumpolar distribution, occurring in fresh and coastal waters of northern Eurasia and North America (Münzing, 1969; Wootton, 1976). Although its widespread distribution and morphological variability are comparable to those of the threespine stickleback Gasterosteus aculeatus, the ninespine stickleback has received less attention from biologists than the latter species (Wootton, 1976).

Takata et al. (1987) revealed that there are two ecologically and morphologically distinct forms, which co-occur abundantly in several freshwater systems on the coast of eastern Hokkaido, Japan. The two forms are identified as “freshwater type” and “brackish-water type,” though taxonomically undefined, based on the spawning habitat (Takata et al., 1987). They differ from one another in three meristic characters; the freshwater type has a high number of dorsal spines and gill-rakers, and a low number of vertebrae, when compared with the brackish-water type (Takata et al., 1987). The body color of the brackish-water type is typically silvery, and the freshwater type is usually yellowish or greenish brown. Although their habitats frequently overlap in lower reaches, discrete habitat preferences are generally maintained throughout the year. The freshwater type exclusively occupies freshwater areas within river systems, whereas the brackish-water type occupies brackish-water areas, such as estuaries and lagoons. Since these two forms are reciprocally monophyletic (Takahashi et al., 2003), the evolutionary background is differ from that of the anadromous–freshwater system in the threespine stickleback of which freshwater forms were considered to have multiple, independent origins (McKinnon and Rundle, 2002).

Takata et al. (1987) examined allozyme variations between the two types in the Biwase River, eastern Hokkaido, and revealed complete allelic displacement at three of 13 loci examined. They claimed that the two types should be regarded as independent species, according to the biological species concept (Mayr, 1963). On the other hand, Takahashi and Goto (2001) suggested that the fresh- and brackish-water types had diverged quite recently or otherwise exchanged mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) through introgressive hybridization, on the grounds that there was no obvious difference in their mtDNA control region sequences. Similar examples of discordant patterns of nuclear and mtDNA are abundant in sticklebacks (e.g., Taylor and McPhail, 1999, 2000; Takahashi and Takata, 2000). These studies suggested that mtDNA introgression has erased mtDNA history of the recipient population. Although information about the postzygotic reproductive isolating mechanisms will provide insight into the discrepancy between the allozyme and mtDNA data (e.g., Takahashi and Takata, 2000), little is known about such mechanisms between the two types.

As a first step to examine postzygotic reproductive isolating mechanisms between the two stickleback types, we examined the viability, growth potential, and reproductive performance of their artificial hybrids. It should be noted that these fitness components are part of postzygotic reproductive isolating mechanisms. Although, postzygotic reproductive isolating mechanisms are classified into extrinsic and intrinsic barriers (Coyne and Orr, 2004), the former such as ecological inviability, behavioral sterility (e.g., Rundle and Whitlock, 2001; Vamosi and Schluter, 1999) were not tested in the present study. To elucidate the cause of hybrid sterility found in the present study, we also made histological observation of gonads and comparison of the DNA contents between the gonad and somatic cells.


Rearing of hybrid stocks

Mature fishes of the fresh- and brackish water types of Pungitius pungitius were collected from the Bekanbeushi River, eastern Hokkaido, Japan, in June 2000. Three females and six males of each type were used as parents of artificial hybrids and of controls. We used the semidry method for artificial insemination, because of limited amounts of sperm in sticklebacks. The eggs were pressed out with fingers from a single mature female and halved into two Petri dishes. The testes were surgically removed from a single male and cut with scissors in a drop of normal saline. The halves of the eggs were fertilized with sperm suspensions obtained from a single different type male and with a single same type male as a control. The fertilization rate was estimated by the frequency of eggs that had undergone cleavage at 3 h after fertilization (2- or 4-cell stages). The fertilized eggs gathering in a cluster were detached from each other to avoid suffocation, and then maintained in a Petri dish at 15°C until they hatched. The hatching rate was calculated as the relative percentage of the initial eggs incubated.

Each full sib stock was kept in a separate aquarium (15×10 cm and 10 cm high) for about two months, and then 20 fishes were chosen randomly and transferred to a larger aquarium (60×30 cm and 30 cm high). They were maintained at 15°C with a 14L:10D cycle and initially fed one to two times a day with freshly hatched Artemia (brine shrimp) until they were large enough to accept frozen bloodworms (larval chironomids). Thereafter fishes were fed with frozen bloodworms and live tubifexes once a day. After about six months, the fish rearing condition was switched to a lower temperature 10°C with a 12L:12D cycle to simulate winter. The condition was shifted once again to warmer temperature 15°C with a 14L: 10D cycle in April 2001 to facilitate the final maturation of the fish. Water salinity was maintained at 1–3 ‰ throughout the experiment.

To test the reproductive performance of the F1 hybrids, the fertilization and hatching rates for those gametes were examined by artificial fertilization with the normal control gametes. Three mature individuals were randomly chosen for both sexes in each full sib stock of F1 hybrids, and backcrossed to the controls. The fertilization and hatching rates were estimated in a similar manner as above. The experiments were finished when all of the eggs hatched or deceased.

Gonad histology

Histological observation of gonads was made on F1 hybrid that expressed a reduced survival rate in the backcross experiment. Additional three mature individuals were used for each full sib stock of F1 hybrids and of both types of controls in gonad histology and flow-cytometric analysis. A small part of each gonad sample was used in flow-cytometric analysis (see below), the remainder being fixed overnight with Bouin's fixative and dehydrated in a butyl alcohol series for gonad histology. After embedding in paraffin, the entire gonad was sectioned transversally at 8 μm thickness and stained with Delafield's hematoxylin and eosin according to the standard procedures. Histological nomenclatures followed Ruby and McMillan (1970).

Flow-cytometric analysis

Flow cytometry to detect the DNA content of testis cells was used to elucidate the stage of spermatogenesis in the hybrids and controls using the Partec PA flow cytometer (Partec GmbH, Münster, Germany). Approximately 10 mg of testis were incubated for 5 min. in 100 ml of Partec Cystain solution A (Partec) at room temperature. After filtration of the cell suspension, the nuclei were stained by adding Partec Cystain solution B (Partec) according to the manufacture's instructions. Relative DNA content of testis cells was measured as fluorescence intensity with respect to reference diploid cells (fin).


Growth and maturation of hybrids

The fertilization and hatching rates were more than 95% in all of the F1 hybrids and controls, and these rates were not significantly different between the hybrids and controls (Wilcoxon signed-ranks test with exact probability, Z=−1.00, P=1.00; Z=−0.37, P=0.86). The fish grew normally to the adult size (approx. 4–6 cm, SL), and all of them expressed secondary sexual characters such as a head-up display in female and a nest construction behavior in male with nuptial coloration at the next year breeding season (May to July). No mortality was observed in larger aquariums for each full sib stock, with the exception of a single dead fish observed in two of six control stocks.

In the backcross experiments, the fertilization and hatching rates in some crosses were lowered (Table 1) as compared to those in controls (more than 95%). The rates for the F1 hybrid females were as high as those in controls (more than 90%) except for one of six cases (56.3% in hatching rate, Table 1). Extremely low hatching rates (0%–3.7%) were observed for the progeny of F1 hybrid male crossed with both pure types although fertilization rates were high (68.3%–100%). All of these embryos exhibited the typical haploid syndrome (arrested development, distorted body axis, small eyes) (Onozato and Yamaha, 1982), and died at hatching with the exception of one backcross progeny, of which four out of 107 eggs were successfully hatched. These four had a curved body axis, small eyes, and died within two days of hatching.

Table 1.

Fertilization and hatching rates for gametes of the F1 hybrids between the fresh- and brackish-water types of ninespine stickleback, Pungitius pungitius.


Histological observation of hybrid testes

Since reduced reproductive performance was observed only in F1 hybrid males, histological observations were made only in the males. No significant difference was observed between the samples in outside appearances of testis such as shape and size except for the color of epiorchium. Melanophores on the epiorchium were highly developed in the freshwater type, rendering the testes dark gray, while those were reduced in the brackish-water type testes, rendering it white. Both of the reciprocal F1 hybrids represented intermediate testes with grayish color.

Microscopically, the majority of seminiferous tubules in testes of both controls were occupied by mature sperm and by spermatids with condensed nuclei that stained strongly with hematoxylin (Fig. 1a, b). Mature sperm also occupied the interior of the seminal ducts. A regular array of phagocytes containing sperm nuclei was observed on the interior wall of some tubules. A relatively small number of cysts involving primary or secondary spermatocytes were observed in putative secondary seminiferous tubules located near the outside of testis. No obvious difference was detected in the histological features of the fresh- and brackish-water type controls.

Fig. 1.

Transverse sections through seminiferous tubules of the testes in both controls (a: the freshwater type, b: the brackish-water type) and hybrids (c: the freahwater type female and the brackish-water type male; d: the brackish-water type female and the freshwater type male), showing spermatids (S), phagocytes (arrow head), and cysts with spermatocytes (SC). Both hybrids testes consisted of seminiferous tubules without mature sperm, many vacant spaces being observed. Scale bars indicate 0.05 mm.


The testes of reciprocal F1 hybrids consisted of seminiferous tubules without mature sperm (Fig. 1c, d). Many vacant spaces were observed in the interior of tubules. A relatively large number of tubules contained cysts with spermatocytes and/or a small number of spermatids. The nuclei of such spermatids were stained in various strengths with hematoxlin and these cells had an irregular shape. Phagocytes containing spermatid nuclei were observed in several tubules. The configuration of such phagocytes was irregular, and these cells were liberated from the interior wall of the tubules.

Flow-cytometric analysis for hybrid testes

A single sharp peak in fluorescence intensity was present in the flow-cytometric histogram for each fin sample. This fluorescence intensity was regarded as an indication of 2n DNA content (Fig. 2c). In the testis, three distinct peaks are expected: spermatozoa (1n), static and replicated phases of spermatocytes (2n or 4n), and somatic cells (2n). The flow-cytometric analyses revealed that the testes of both controls consisted of a prominent 1n-cell population (spermatozoa) and a lower 2n-cell population (Fig. 2a). On the other hand, the testis cells of reciprocal hybrids showed only a prominent 2n-cell population with no 1n spermatozoa (Fig. 2b). In addition, a small 4n-cell population was detected in some fish.

Fig. 2.

Examples for the Partec PA flow cytometer output showing flow-cytometric histogram in testis of the freshwater type control (top) and the F1 hybrid between the freshwater type female and the brackish-water type male (middle). Relative DNA contents of testis cells were measured as fluorescence intensity (x-axis) with respect to the reference of fin as diploid cells (bottom).



Three points will be helpful in discussing the characteristics of fish hybrids: viability, growth potential, and reproductive performance (Chevassus, 1983). In the present study, no significant difference in the former two was observed between reciprocal F1 hybrids and controls. In the hybrid females, the last characteristic (reproductive performance) was also normal, although the viability of the back-crosses has been examined only through the hatching period. On the other hand, extremely low hatching rates were observed in the backcrosses of male hybrids, indicating that the reciprocal hybrid males were sterile. Relatively high fertilization rates were expressed in the hybrid male experiments, but all backcross embryos exhibited typical haploid syndrome. Furthermore, eggs laid by control females under natural mating with hybrid males showed no fertilization in an aquarium experiment (Takahashi, unpublished data). For these reasons, the relatively high fertilization rates were probably due to the artificial insemination method by which the parthenogenetic activation of the eggs was induced.

In fish hybrids, various sterility patterns have been observed, but these patterns fall roughly into three types: zygotic sterility, gametic sterility and gonadic sterility (Chevassus, 1983). “Zygotic sterility” is that the conditions where the gametes are viable (normal in size and structure) and fertilization occurs but results embryos fail to develop. In the present study, as noted above, estimates of fertilization rate were uncertain, because of possible parthenogenetic activation of eggs. However, no mature sperm was observed in seminiferous tubules of the testes in reciprocal F1 hybrids and flow-cytometric analyses revealed the absence of 1n. These observations indicate the sterility pattern of the hybrid males was more serious one than the zygotic sterility.

In “gametic sterility” the gonads are normal in size but abnormal in gametogenesis. Histology indicated that a large number of tubules contained cysts with spermatocytes in the hybrid males, but only a small number of such tubules located near the outside of testis in the controls. In a closely related gasterosteid fish, brook stickleback (Culaea inconstans), spermatocyte formation completed in the first autumn of life, and most of the cysts filled with spermatocytes broke down prior to the winter season for spermiogenesis (Ruby and McMillan, 1970). Taking into account the similarity in the life cycles between the brook and ninespine sticklebacks (Ruby and McMillan, 1970; Goto et al., 1979), the present result for hybrid males suggested delay or arrest of spermatogenesis reducing the number of spermatids and distorting their shape.

“Gonadic sterility” is characterized by reduced gonad size. Since the testes of hybrid males were normal in size, the sterility pattern of the hybrids was determined to be the gametic sterility characterized by abnormal spermatogenesis. The male hybrids exhibited the secondary sexual characteristics similar to the controls, suggesting that the testis retained endocrine functions (i.e., producing androgens) essential for the development of secondary characteristics (Wootton, 1976). Similar examples are abundant: Suzuki and Fukuda (1973), for example, reported that the hybrids of salmonid fishes with zygotic or gametic sterility generally exhibit secondary sexual characteristics.

In the present study, hybrid sterility was observed only in the male hybrids. To our knowledge, the present finding is a novel example of one sex (male) hybrid sterility in gasterosteid fishes. Few different patterns of intrinsic postzygotic isolation have been observed. Honma and Tamura (1984), for example, reported that F1 hybrids between female marine and male landlocked forms of threespine stickleback (Gasterosteus aculeatus) were sterile in both sexes, while hybrids of the opposite direction were fertile in both sexes. These marine and landlocked forms correspond to the Japan Sea and Pacific Ocean groups, respectively, suggested by Higuchi and Goto (1996). A different pattern, breakdown in backcrosses, was observed in the well-studied limnetic and benthic forms of threespine stickleback. Hatfield and Schluter (1999) revealed that hatching success of the benthic backcrosses was significantly lower than that of the limnetic, F1 and F2 crosses in a laboratory cross experiment between the two forms.

Similar observations to that found in the present study are abundant in a broad array of animal taxa, a general rule known as Haldane's rule (Haldane, 1922). This rule states that when in the F1 offspring of two species or populations, one sex is inviable or sterile, that sex is usually the hetero-gametic sex. Taking the remarkable consistency of this rule among taxa into consideration (Coyne, 1992), the present sterility pattern suggests that ninespine sticklebacks have XY heterogametic males, even with homomorphic sex chromosomes (e.g., Klinkhardt and Buuk, 1990). Indeed, male-specific DNA sequence was identified by the amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) method in the close relative, the threespine stickleback (Griffiths et al., 2000). As outlined by Orr (1997), the faster evolution of hybrid male sterility (faster-male theory) likely plays an important role in Haldane's rule for hybrid male ‘sterility’ in addition to the fundamental dominance theory. The faster-male theory explains the Haldane's rule on the basis of following two reasons: (i) spermatogenesis is particularly sensitive to perturbation in gene expression, perhaps due to lack of post-meiotic transcription regulation; and (ii) sexual selection might cause faster evolution of male-than female-expressed genes (Wu and Davis, 1993). The current results would seem to be consistent with the former, because of hybridization defects were observed only in the spermatogenesis but not in the other aspects of male reproduction. Further studies on genes associated with hybrid male sterility can provide many insights into the genetic bases of the reproductive isolating mechanisms, though such genes have never been identified in the ninespine sticklebacks.


We express our gratitude to Drs. Keisuke Takata (Shinshu University), Katsutoshi Arai, and Etsuro Yamaha (Hokkaido University) for their precise advice on this work. We are also grateful to Dr. Tetsuya Tsuruta, Messrs Takefumi Fujimoto, and Junichiro Nakajima (Hokkaido University) for their help in this study, and to Drs. Ryota Yokoyama (Toyama University), Harumi Sakai (National Fisheries University), and two anonymous reviewers for their helpful comments to improve our manuscript. This work was partly supported by grant-in-aid no. 15405008 to A.G. from the Ministry of Education, Science, Sports and Culture, Japan, and grants-in-aid to H.T. for Scientific Research in the Lake Akkeshi-Bekanbeushi Wetland from Akkeshi Town (1998 Akkeshi Town (1999), Japan.



B. Chevassus 1983. Hybridization in fish. Aquaculture 33:245–262. Google Scholar


J. A. Coyne 1992. Genetics and speciation. Nature 355:511–515. Google Scholar


J. A. Coyne and H. A. Orr . 2004. Speciation. Sinauer Associates. Massachusetts, USA. Google Scholar


A. Goto, K. Oishi, and K. Takata . 1979. Breeding habits, growth and food of the ninespine stickleback, Pungitius pungitius (L.) in an artificial waterway of the Kunebetsu River system, Hokkaido. Bull Fac Fish Hokkaido Univ 30:239–251. (in Japanese with English abstract). Google Scholar


R. Griffiths, K. J. Orr, A. Adam, and I. Barber . 2000. DNA sex identification in the three-spined stickleback. J Fish Biol 57:1331–1334. Google Scholar


J. B. S. Haldane 1922. Sex ratio and unisexual sterility in hybrid animals. J Genet 12:101–109. Google Scholar


T. Hatfield and D. Schluter . 1999. Ecological speciation in sticklebacks: environmental-dependent hybrid fitness. Evolution 53:866–873. Google Scholar


M. Higuchi and A. Goto . 1996. Genetic evidence supporting the existence of two distinct species in the genus Gasterosteus around Japan. Env Biol Fish 47:1–16. Google Scholar


Y. Honma and E. Tamura . 1984. Anatomical and behavioral difference among threespine sticklebacks: the marine form, the landlocked form and their hybrids. Acta Zool 65:79–87. Google Scholar


M. B. Klinkhardt and B. Buuk . 1990. Karyological studies in several species of fresh-water fishes from brackish coastal waters of southwestern Baltic. 3. The 3-Spined Stickleback (Gasterosteus aculeatus (Linnaeus, 1758)) and the 9-Spined Stickleback (Pungitius pungitius (Linnaeus, 1758)). Zool Anz 225:341–352. Google Scholar


M. Y. Mattern 2004. Molecular phylogeny of the Gasterosteidae: the importance of using multiple genes. Mol Phylogenet Evol 30:366–377. Google Scholar


E. Mayr 1963. Animal species and evolution. Harverd University Press. Cambridge, UK. Google Scholar


J. S. McKinnon and H. D. Rundle . 2002. Speciation in nature: the threespine stickleback model systems. Trend Ecol Evol 17:480–488. Google Scholar


V. J. Münzing 1969. Variabilität, Verbreitung and Systematik der Arten und Unterarten in der Gatting Pungitius Coste, 1848 (Pisces, Gasterosteidae). Z Zool Syst Evol Forsh 7:208–233. Google Scholar


H. Onozato and E. Yamaha . 1983. Induction of gynogenesis with ultraviolet rays in four species of Salmoniformes. Bull Japan Soc Sci Fish 49:693–699. Google Scholar


H. A. Orr 1997. Haldane's rule. Annu Rev Ecol Syst 28:195–218. Google Scholar


S. M. Ruby and D. B. McMillan . 1970. Cyclic changes in the testis of the brook stickleback Eucalia inconstans (Kirtland). J Morph 131:447–466. Google Scholar


H. D. Rundle and M. C. Whitlock . 2001. A genetic interpretation of ecologically dependent isolation. Evolution 55:198–201. Google Scholar


R. Suzuki and Y. Fukuda . 1973. Appearance and numerical characters of F1 hybrids among salmonid fishes. Bull Freshwater Fish Res Lab 23:57–74. Google Scholar


H. Takahashi and A. Goto . 2001. Evolution of East Asian ninespine sticklebacks as shown by mitochondrial DNA control region sequences. Mol Phylogenet Evol 21:135–155. Google Scholar


H. Takahashi and K. Takata . 2000. Multiple lineages of the mitochondrial DNA introgression from Pungitius pungitius (L.) to Pungitius tymensis (Nikolsky). Can J Fish Aquat Sci 57:1814–1833. Google Scholar


H. Takahashi, T. Tsuruta, and A. Goto . 2003. Population structure of two ecologically distinct forms of ninespine sticklebacks, Pungitius pungitius: gene flow regimes and genetic diversity based on mtDNA sequence variations. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 60:421–432. Google Scholar


K. Takata, A. Goto, and F. Yamazaki . 1987. Biochemical identification of a brackish water type of Pungitius pungitius, and its morphological and ecological features in Hokkaido, Japan. Jpn J Ichthyol 34:176–183. Google Scholar


E. B. Taylor and J. D. McPhail . 1999. Evolutionary history of an adaptive radiation in species pairs of threespine sticklebacks (Gasterosteus): insight from mitochondrial DNA. Biol J Linn Soc 66:271–291. Google Scholar


E. B. Taylor and J. D. McPhail . 2000. Historical contingency and ecological determinism interact to prime speciation in sticklebacks, Gasterosteus. Proc R Soc Lond B 267:2375–2384. Google Scholar


S. M. Vamosi and D. Schluter . 1999. Sexual selection against hybrids between sympatric stickleback species: evidence from a field experiment. Evolution 53:874–879. Google Scholar


R. J. Wootton 1976. The biology of the sticklebacks. Academic Press. London. Google Scholar


C. I. Wu and A. W. Davis . 1993. Evolution of post-mating reproductive isolation—the composite nature of Haldane's rule and its genetic basis. Am Nat 142:187–212. Google Scholar
Hiroshi Takahashi, Terumi Nagai, and Akira Goto "Hybrid Male Sterility between the Fresh- and Brackish-water Types of Ninespine Stickleback Pungitius pungitius (Pisces, Gasterosteidae)," Zoological Science 22(1), 35-40, (1 January 2005).
Received: 3 June 2004; Accepted: 1 October 2004; Published: 1 January 2005
Haldane's rule
sterility pattern
Back to Top