The fossiliferous Upper Varswater Formation at Langebaanweg (South Africa) produced remains of at least five species of owls (Strigiformes). Tyto richae sp. nov. is the first palaeospecies of Tytonidae described from an African fossil site, though indeterminate remains referable to the genus Tyto are known from the Middle Miocene of Morocco, the early Pliocene of Ethiopia, and the Pliocene of Tanzania. Athene inexpectata sp. nov. is not only the earliest documented fossil evidence for the genus worldwide, but also the first record of a species of Athene in Africa south of the Sahara. Proportions of its hind limb indicate that At. inexpectata sp. nov. probably has been as terrestrial as its modern relative At. cunicularia. A few additional remains represent the earliest fossil evidence for the genera Asio and Bubo on the African continent, though the poor preservation of these bones prevents more detailed identifications. A distal tibiotarsus of a small owl about the size of At. inexpectata sp. nov. indicates the presence of a fifth, as yet indeterminate, species of owl at Langebaanweg. Biogeographical and palaeoecological implications of this assemblage of owls are discussed.
The early Pliocene Upper Varswater Formation (Lange baanweg, West Coast of South Africa) is one of the most important pre-Pleistocene fossil localities in Africa. It has produced a very rich fossil bird bone assemblage with more than 90 species of 35 bird families, and is thus one of the richest fossil avifaunas in the world (Manegold et al. 2013). The study of the fossil birds from this extremely rich fossil locality started at the beginning of the 1980s, when Rich (1980) reported the presence of at least 60 species representing 28 bird families. Several papers were published on various bird groups since then, reviewed in Manegold et al. (2013, 2014), but studies on many taxa are still in progress. Presence of at least two species of Strigidae in the fossil assemblage has already been reported by Rich (1980) and Hendey (1981), though without further details. Thereafter Pippa Haarhoff sorted and identified 39 fossil bones of Strigiformes, which can be referred to a species of Tytonidae and four species of Strigidae. The fossil material is sufficient for describing a new species of Tyto as well as a new species of Athene and for distinguishing remains of as yet indeterminate species of the extant genera Asio and Bubo. A distal tibiotarsus of a small owl about the size of Athene noctua can only be referred to Strigidae.
The early Neogene fossil record of Tyto, Athene, Bubo, and Asio.—Strigiforms are quite common in the Cenozoic fossil record of birds. The oldest occurrence is dated to the Palaeocene. Strigiformes became quite common during the Eocene and Oligocene in the Northern Hemisphere (Mayr 2009). The order Strigiformes includes six families: four of them (Ogygoptyngidae, Palaeoglaucidae, Protostrigidae, and Sophiornithidae) only contain fossil taxa of Paleogene distribution, while the other two (Strigidae and Tytonidae) comprising fossil and extant species, forming together the crown group Strigiformes (Mayr 2009). The oldest Strigidae dates back to the Early Miocene, while the Tytonidae are known since the Paleogene (Kurochkin and Dyke 2011; Göhlich and Ballmann 2013). All but one of the fossil remains of strigiforms found at Langebaanweg are referable to modern genera of both Tytonidae and Strigidae: Tyto, Athene, Bubo, and Asio.
The fossil history of Tyto has been recently summarized by Pavia and Mourer-Chauviré (2011). In particular, starting from the oldest species Tyto sanctialbani, it comprises several extinct species, both continental and insular, from the Middle Miocene onwards. All the Neogene fossil species of Tyto have been found in Europe or in North Africa together with all the earlier Tytonidae (Mourer-Chauviré and Geraads 2010; Kurochkin and Dyke 2011; Pavia and Mourer-Chauviré 2011; Göhlich and Ballmann 2013), suggesting a Western Palaearctic origin of the genus. The first record of Tyto alba is from the late Pliocene-Early Pleistocene of Morocco (Mourer-Chauviré and Geraads 2010), while the earliest record of T. capensis is represented by tentatively referred bones from the Late Pleistocene of Tanzania (Harrison 1980).
The first unambiguous record of Athene (sensu König and Weick 2008) is represented by the Nearctic Athene megalopeza from the late early Pliocene of Idaho and early late Pliocene of Kansas (Ford 1966; Ford and Murray 1967; Bell et al. 2004), a palaeospecies similar in size and proportion to the extant Athene cunicularia but more robust. The oldest occurrence of the Recent At. cunicularia is found in the late Pliocene of Nebraska, where Feduccia (1970) described At. c. intermedia, slightly more robust than the modern At. cunicularia. Apart from an as yet unsubstantiated, questionable record of Athene from the late Miocene of Hungary (Jánossy in Bernor et al. 2002), the first Palaearctic record of the genus dates from the late Pliocene of Bulgaria (Boev 2002). Athene noctua is known since the Early Pleistocene of Italy (Bedetti and Pavia 2013) and for other European localities (Mlíkovský 2002). It is worth mentioning that the islands of Mediterranean Basin during the Middle and Late Pleistocene were inhabited by several endemic forms of Athene with different morphological adaptations: At. angelis, At. cretensis, At. trinacriae, and At. vallgornerensis (Pavia and Mourer- Chauviré 2002; Guerra et al. 2012).
The genus Bubo is known since the early Pliocene of Ukraine and later reported from several Pliocene and Early Pleistocene localities (Mlíkovský 2002). Kurochkin and Dyke (2011) also listed Bubo florianae and B. perpasta from the Late Miocene of Hungary and Italy respectively, but the identification of the former is doubtful (see Mlíkovský 1998: 13) and the transfer of Strix? perpasta into Bubo (Mlíkovský 1998: 14) is questionable (MP personal observation). Thus, we note that no fossil species of Bubo have been described from the Neogene and that only four fossil species are known from the Pleistocene worldwide, two of them endemic (Kurochkin and Dyke 2011).
The oldest records of Asio are from the Western Palaearctic, with Asio sp. from the Early Miocene of Germany (Ballmann 1969) and Asio? ignotus from the Middle Miocene of France (Cheneval 2000). They are followed by the record of Asio brevipes from the early late Pliocene of Idaho (Ford and Murray 1967) and Asio sp. from the late Pliocene of Kansas (Ford 1966). Two other fossil species of Asio are listed by Kurochkin and Dyke (2011): Asio longaevus and Asio pygmaeus from the Late Miocene and early Pliocene of Ukraine respectively (Serebrovsky 1941; Umanskaya 1979), with the former originally described as Bubo longaevus and subsequently moved to Asio by Mlíkovský (1998). The original description of these two taxa does not clarify their taxonomic affinities, and it is impossible to consider these species in any meaningful comparisons of other fossil Asio remains. The Recent Asio flammeus is known since the late Pliocene of Poland, even if dubitatively (Jánossy 1974), while the oldest record of Asio otus is from the Early Pleistocene of Romania (Tyrberg 1998).
However, the identification of most of the fossil Strigidae from the Neogene has to be considered with great caution, because many specimens are only poorly preserved and most of them were only superficially described, as it was already pointed out by Göhlich and Ballmann (2013).
The fossil record of Strigiformes in Africa.—Apart from the owl remains from Langebaanweg, the fossil record of Strigiformes in the Neogene of Africa is poor and only spans the time from the Early Miocene to the Middle Pleistocene. The Miocene record is very sparse. It includes a distal humerus from the Lower Miocene of Songhor, Kenya, which was questionably referred to Otus (Walker and Dyke 2006), and a proximal phalanx of digitus majoris from the Middle Miocene of Beni Mellal, Morocco, which was originally assigned to T. alba (Brunet 1961, 1971), but probably belongs to an extinct species of Tyto (Pavia and Mourer-Chauviré 2011). Most of the African Strigiformes have been found in Pliocene and Pleistocene sites, such as the lower Pliocene of Aramis, Ethiopia, where a new, still undescribed, species of Tyto has been reported by Louchart et al. (2009) together with a single bone of an indeterminate species of Strigidae. However, the richest Pliocene site in terms of diversity of Strigiformes is Laetoli, Tanzania, with at least four taxa found in the various layers of the succession (Louchart 2011): Tyto sp., Bubo cf. lacteus, Asio sp., and an indeterminate small species of Strigidae about the size of Athene, Glaucidium, or Taenioglaux. Tyto balearica, T. alba, and Surnia robusta are documented from the late Pliocene of Ahl al Oughlam, Morocco, each of them by various skeletal elements of several individuals (Mourer-Chauviré and Geraads 2010).
A species of Tyto comparable in size to T. alba, but morphologically distinct from this species as well as from T. capensis, is reported from the Early Pleistocene of Kromdraai, South Africa (Pocock 1970), and Tytonidae are also listed in the preliminary record of birds from the Early Pleistocene of Swartkrans (Watson 1993). Bubo leakeyae has been described on the basis of a disarticulated skeleton and some isolated bones of at least 12 individuals from the Early Pleistocene of Olduvai, Tanzania (Brodkorb and Mourer- Chauviré 1984), together with other remains referable to T. alba cf. affinis and Bubo cf. lacteus. A complete skull of a small owl from the Early Pleistocene of Buxton quarry (Taung), South Africa (Rich 1974: 179) has been tentatively referred to Glaucidium perlatum by Cooke (1990: 130). The author correctly pointed out the similarities of the fossil with G. perlatum, but erroneously listed the skull as cf. At. noctua (Cooke 1990: 132). This error was later iterated by Berger and Clarke (1995). Additional remains of owls referable to extant taxa are mentioned for several Pleistocene sites in Africa (Harrison 1980; Watson 1993; Plug and Clark 2008 and references therein), but a review of all these findings was beyond the scope of our study.
Institutional abbreviations.—MGPT-MPOC, Marco Pavia Ornithological Collection, Dipartimento di Scienze della Terra, Torino University, Italy; SAM-PQ-L, Iziko South African Museum Paleontology Quaternary Langebaanweg, Cape Town, South Africa.
Material and methods
The fossil bones described in the following pages are part of the Cenozoic collections of the Iziko South African Museum, Cape Town, South Africa. Osteological comparisons were made with representatives of all Western Palaearctic and African genera of Strigiformes, except for the African endemic and monotypic genus Jubula, and the genus Taenioglaux. The fossil bones were compared to the Recent skeletons housed in Museo Civico di Storia Naturale (Carmagnola, Torino, Italy), Museo Civico di Lentate sul Seveso (Monza, Italy), MGPT-MPOC, Natural History Museum (London/Tring, UK), and Senckenberg Forschungsinstitut und Naturmuseum (Frankfurt/Main, Germany) collections. Comparisons with fossil owls from other African localities were made on the basis of published photographs and sketches (Brunet 1961, 1971; Harrison 1980; Brodkorb and Mourer-Chauviré 1984; Cooke 1990; Mourer-Chauviré and Geraads 2010; Louchart 2011).
The nomenclature of the Strigiformes follows Bruce (1999), Marks et al. (1999) and König and Weick (2008). The anatomical terminology follows Baumel and Witmer (1993). The measurements were taken by using vernier callipers accurate to 0.1 mm in accordance to von den Driesch (1976) and Louchart (2002).
List of Recent taxa used for comparative analyses.— Tytonidae: Tyto alba alba, T. a. guttata, T. capensis. Strigidae: Aegolius funereus, Asio flammeus, As. otus, As. capensis, Athene cunicularia, At. noctua, Bubo africanus, B. ascalaphus, B. bubo, B. capensis, B. cinerascens, B. (Nyctea) scandiacus, B. (Ketupa) ketupu, B. (Scotopelia) bouvieri, Glaucidium passerinum, Ninox novaeseelandiae, Otus scops, Ptilopsis granti, P. leucotis, Strix aluco, S. nebulosa, S. uralensis, S. woodfordi, Surnia ulula.
Class Aves Linnaeus, 1758
Order Strigiformes Wagler, 1830
Family Tytonidae Ridgway, 1914
Genus Tyto Billberg, 1828
Type species: Tyto alba (Scopoli, 1769); Recent, Friuli, Italy.
Tyto richae sp. nov.
Etymology: Dedicated to Patricia Vickers-Rich, who carried out the preliminary analysis of the Langebaanweg avifauna in 1980 and who has contributed significantly to the record of African fossil birds.
Type material: Holotype: right tarsometatarsus, SAM-PQ-L50354B, distal end. Paratypes: left coracoid, SAM-PQ-L23436, complete; left ulna, SAM-PQ-L50411L, distal end; left tibiotarsus, SAM-PQL28197AU, distal end; left tibiotarsus, SAM-PQ-L50022ZA, distal end; right tibiotarsus, SAM-PQ-L50022ZB, distal end.
Type locality: Langebaanweg, South Africa.
Referred material.—Right coracoids, SAM-PQ-L30104, cranial end; right tarsometatarsus, SAM-PQ-L28199DT, distal end; right pedal phalanx III/2, SAM-PQ-L56207G; terminal pedal phalanges, SAM-PQ-L56212 A and F.
Diagnosis.—Medium-sized species of Tyto, distinctly larger than T. alba, coracoid relatively slender showing a wellmarked facies articularis clavicularis with a tuberculum on its ventral side, and tarsometatarsus with the trochlea III protruding more distally than the trochlea II and IV.
Description.—Tyto richae sp. nov. is described on the basis of eleven more or less fragmentary bones that show a combination of characters previously described as being diagnostic for Tyto and which allow the distinction between this genus and Phodilus as well as other Tytonidae (Mourer-Chauviré 1987; Pavia 2004; Pavia and Mourer-Chauviré 2011; Göhlich and Ballmann 2013). In particular, coracoid: (i) tuberculum brachiale absent, (ii) processus procoracoideus short and wide at its base, (iii) cranial part of sulcus musculi supracoracoidei not pneumatised, (iv) shaft ventro-dorsally flattened, (v) processus lateralis wide in cranial view; ulna: (vi) condylus dorsalis ulnaris oblique in ventral view, (vii) condylus ventralis ulnaris pointed and distally well developed; tibiotarsus: (viii) distal part of sulcus extensorius shallow, (ix) condyli caudally extended forming a square angle with the shaft, (x) condyli of similar thin shape in distal view; tarsometatarsus: (xi) trochlea metatarsi III protruding more distally than the remaining trochleae, (xii) medial groove on trochlea metatarsi III limited to the distal part, (xiii) distal edge of trochlea metatarsi IV wide and distally concave in lateral view; pedal phalanx III/2: (xiv) not as shortened as in Strigidae with blunt rather than pointed dorsoproximal process.
Tyto richae sp. nov. is larger than T. a. alba, T. a. guttata, and T. a. ernesti (see Louchart 2002) the extant European subspecies of cosmopolitan T. alba, which lack sexual size dimorphism, and also exceeds T. a. affinis of sub-Saharan Africa in size (König and Weick 2008) (Tables 1–3). The new Tyto species is similar-in-size to the few T. capensis available for comparison, but has stouter coracoid and hind limb bones. Tyto richae sp. nov. is larger than T. sanctialbani and slightly larger than T. campiterrae, but smaller than T. balearica and other palaeospecies of Tyto described from Europe and North America (Mourer-Chauviré et al. 1980; Louchart 2002; Pavia 2004; Pavia and Mourer-Chauviré 2011).
The coracoid of Tyto richae sp. nov. is more slender than in T. sanctialbani, T. balearica, and T. campiterrae, thus more similar in structure to that of T. alba, and is stouter than in T. capensis (Table 1). The cranial end of the coracoid in the new species is characterized by a well developed facies articularis clavicularis, with an irregular surface that terminates ventrally into a tuberculum. The facies articularis sternalis is narrower than in T. alba and T. sanctialbani. Compared to T. alba, the condylus ventralis ulnae of T. richae sp. nov. does not protrude as far ventrally and the incisura tuberculi carpalis is less marked. In cranial view, the distal tibiotarsus of Tyto richae sp. nov. is characterized by a small crest proximal to the medial side of the condylus lateralis. A similar crest is also present in T. sanctialbani, but is absent in all the other Tyto species, both fossil and extant. The caudal side of the condylus medialis is wider than in T. alba, and the depression situated proximally to the trochlea cartilaginis tibialis is not deep as in other Tyto species, both living and fossil. The two condyli are similar in size and shape and the incisura intercondylaris is proportionately wider than in T. alba. Although only the distal part of the tarsometatarsus of the new species is known, this bone is apparently stouter than that of T. capensis, T. alba, and T. campiterrae (Table 2). The trochlea metatarsi III extends further distally than the other trochleae, as is the case with T. sanctialbani, but not as in other Tyto species. The fossil pedal phalanx III/2 is larger and more robust than the corresponding bone of T. alba and it is stouter with larger epiphyses than T. capensis (Table 3). The terminal pedal phalanges are compatible to the other referred material to T. richae sp. nov. They are only slightly curved and equipped with a proximodistally elongated processus extensorius as is typical for Strigiformes in general (Ballmann 1973). The processus flexorius is very small in both specimens as is the case with Tytonidae (Ballmann 1973).
Stratigraphic and geographical range.—Langeberg Quartz Sand Member and Muishond Fontein Pelletal Phosphorite Member of the Upper Varswater Formation at Langebaanweg, early Pliocene of South Africa (Table 4).
Measurements (in mm) of the coracoid SAM-PQ-L23436 (paratype) of Tyto richae sp. nov. from Langebaanweg in comparison to corresponding measurements of extant T. alba and fossil Tyto species. Measurements of slightly worn or damaged bones are given in square brackets. Paratype is indicated by an asterisk; 1 measurements after Brodkorb and Mourer-Chauviré (1984); 2 measurements after Pavia and Mourer-Chauviré (2011); 3 measurements after Louchart (2002); n, sample size.
Measurements (in mm) of ulna, tibiotarsus, and tarsometatarsus of Tyto richae sp. nov. from Langebaanweg in comparison to corresponding measurements of extant T. alba and fossil Tyto species. Measurements of slightly worn or damaged bones are given in square brackets. The holotype is highlighted in bold, paratypes are indicated by an asterisk; 1 measurements after Brodkorb and Mourer-Chauviré (1984); 2 measurements after Pavia and Mourer-Chauviré (2011); 3 measurements after Jánossy (1991); 4 measurements after Louchart (2002); 5 measurements after Pavia (2004); n, sample size.
Measurements (in mm) of pedal phalanx III/2 SAM-PQ-L56207G of Tyto richae sp. nov. from Langebaanweg in comparison to corresponding measurements of extant T. alba, T. capensis, and fossil T. b. cyrneichnusae. 1 measurements after Brodkorb and Mourer-Chauviré (1984); 2 measurements after Louchart (2002); n, sample size.
Horizon of specimens of Tyto richae sp. nov. from the early Pliocene, Upper Varswater Formation at “E” Quarry, Langebaanweg, South Africa.
Family Strigidae Ridgway, 1914
Genus Athene Boie, 1822
Type species: Athene noctua (Scopoli, 1769); Recent, Carnia, Friuli, Italy.
Athene inexpectata sp. nov.
Fig. 2A, C–F, G.
Etymology: From Latin inexpectatus, unexpected, because it is the first African record of Athene South of the Sahara.
Type material: Holotype: right tarsometatarsus, SAM-PQ-L13052N2, complete. Paratypes: sternum, SAM-PQ-L24592J, cranial part; right scapula, SAM-PQ-L25390GA, cranial end; right humerus, SAMPQ- L33540C, distal half; right ulna, SAM-PQ-L14846, distal half; left tibiotarsus, SAM-PQ-L20700M, almost complete, only lacking proximal end; right tibiotarsus, SAM-PQ-L28927, proximal end; right tibiotarsus, SAM-PQ-L42828A, distal end; left tarsometatarsus, SAMPQ- L20926, distal half right tarsometatarsus, SAM-PQ-L43568, complete.
Type locality: Langebaanweg, South Africa.
Referred material.—Left humerus, SAM-PQ-L20691YE, distal end; left humerus, SAM-PQ-L43566, distal end; right humerus, SAM-PQ-L43565, distal end; left ulna, SAMPQ- L14849, distal end; right femur, SAM-PQ-L33521H, proximal end; left tarsometatarsus, SAM-PQ-L20691H3, distal end; left tarsometatarsus, SAM-PQ-L20701X, distal half; left tarsometatarsus, SAM-PQ-L56223, proximal end; right tarsometatarsus, SAM-PQ-L25293DZ, proximal end; right tarsometatarsus, SAM-PQ-L25293GM, distal end; right tarsometatarsus, SAM-PQ-L28199FN, distal end; right tarsometatarsus, SAM-PQ-L33704A, distal half; right tarsometatarsus, SAM-PQ-L43569, distal half.
Diagnosis.—Species of the genus Athene slightly larger and stouter than At. noctua (Tables 5–7). Athene inexpectata sp. nov. is distinguished from At. noctua by the scapula having pneumatic foramen on the acromion, a pronounced epicondylus dorsalis on the distal humerus, an elongated tibiotarsus, and a stout tarsometatarsus with wide cotylae. The new species also differs from At. cunicularia by its less elongated tibiotarsus and stouter tarsometatarsus, from At. megalopeza by its stouter tarsometatarsus, and from the various extinct Mediterranean insular species of Athene, such as At. angelis, At. cretensis, At. trinacriae, and At. vallgornerensis by the different proportions of the hind limb bones (Tables 5–7) and some morphological characters in the various long bones (Weesie 1982; Mourer-Chauviré et al. 1997; Pavia and Mourer-Chauviré 2002; Guerra et al. 2012).
Description.—Athene inexpectata sp. nov. is described on the basis of 23 more or less complete bones. It can be referred to Athene on the basis of the following morphological characters previously pointed out by Pavia and Mourer-Chauviré (2002): scapula: (i) facies articularis humeralis rounded and mainly mediolaterally oriented, (ii) articular facet on the medial side of the facies articularis humeralis wide, (iii) crista ligamenti acrocoracoacromiali absent; humerus: (iv) fossa musculi brachialis wide and shallow, (v) condylus dorsalis proximally well developed; ulna: (vi) condylus dorsalis ulnaris ventrally well developed and joining the shaft with a square angle; femur: (vii) crista trochanteris weakly developed; tibiotarsus: (viii) proximal part of the crista fibularis separated from the proximal end, (ix) incisura intercotylaris narrow and deep, (x) condylus lateralis wide and expanded laterally in caudal view; tarsometatarsus: (xi) lateral side of the cotyla lateralis rounded in proximal view; (xii) sulcus extensorius exceeding the middle of the shaft; (xiii) tuberositas musculi tibialis cranialis weakly developed; (xiv) medial groove on the trochlea metatarsi III deep; (xv) trochlea metatarsi III protruding more distally than the others.
The area of the foramina pneumatica as well as the labrum internum of the fragmentary sternum of At. inexpectata sp. nov. are both wider than in At. noctua. The facies articularis humeralis of the scapula of the new species is more square than in At. noctua, and the articular facet on the medial side of the facies articularis humeralis is wider. In At. inexpectata sp. nov., there is a pneumatic foramen on the medial side of the acromion that is absent in At. noctua but present in At. cunicularia. The facies articularis clavicularis is more developed in At. inexpectata sp. nov. than in At. noctua. The sulcus scapulotricipitalis and epicondylus dorsalis of the humerus of the new species are more pronounced than in At. noctua. The distal end of the ulna of At. inexpectata sp. nov. is characterized by the tuberculum on the ventral side of the condylus ventralis ulnaris being much more obvious than in At. noctua. The facies articularis acetabularis and the fovea ligamentum capitis of the femur are larger in At. inexpectata sp. nov. than in At. noctua. The linea intermusculi cranialis is more pronounced and more medially situated than in At. noctua and the facies articularis antitrochanterica is caudally less developed. The trochanter femoris is generally more developed and more separated from the impressiones obturatoriae in the new species. Although incompletely preserved, the tibiotarsus of At. inexpectata sp. nov. is much more elongated than that of At. noctua. In fact, the tibiotarsus of At. inexpectata can be estimated to have been as long as 70 mm, whereas the mean for the length of the tibiotarsus in At. noctua is 57.5 mm, the minimal width of the tibiotarsus is similar in both species (Fig. 2, Table 6). The proximal tibiotarsus of the new species is characterized by a more distally oriented crista patellaris and a more developed distal part of the crista cranialis lateralis, which also has a deeper sulcus intercnemialis. The crista cnemialis lateralis is more medially oriented than in At. noctua. The sulcus extensorius on the distal end of the tibiotarsus in the new species is more defined, triangular-shaped, and originates further proximal on the shaft. The medial and lateral margins of the sulcus extensorius are thinner than in At. noctua. The tarsometatarsus of At. inexpectata sp. nov. is slightly larger and stouter than that of At. noctua (Fig. 2, Table 7). The proximal end of the new species is characterized by the cotyla lateralis being wider and more rounded, and by the eminentia intercotylaris also being wider and less pointed compared with At. noctua. The cotyla medialis is less rounded but more extended plantarly in At. inexpectata sp. nov. than in At. noctua. The trochleae metatarsi are more robust in the new species. In particular, the trochlea metatarsi II of At. inexpectata sp. nov. shows the area of the fovea ligamenti collateralis to be more developed whilst the plantar side of the same trochlea is thinner than in At. noctua.
Measurements.—Right tarsometatarsus SAM-PQ-L13052N2 (holotype): total length 38.0 mm; distal width 9.1 mm; distal depth 6.4 mm; minimum width of shaft 4.1. For additional measurements, see Tables 5–7.
Stratigraphic and geographical range.—Langeberg Quartz Sand Member and Muishond Fontein Pelletal Phosphorite Member of the Upper Varswater Formation at Langebaanweg, early Pliocene of South Africa (Table 8).
Measurements (in mm) of humerus and ulna of Athene inexpectata sp. nov. from Langebaanweg compared with the corresponding bones of extant and fossil Athene species. Measurements of slightly worn or damaged bones are given in square brackets. Paratypes are indicated by an asterisk; 1 measurements after Mourer-Chauviré et al. (1997); 2 measurements after Pavia and Mourer-Chauviré (2002); n, sample size.
Measurements (in mm) of femur and tibiotarsus of Athene inexpectata sp. nov. from Langebaanweg compared with the corresponding bones of various living and fossil Athene species. Measurements of slightly worn or damaged bones are given in square brackets. Paratypes are indicated by an asterisk; 1 measurements after Mourer-Chauviré et al. (1997); 2 measurements after Louchart (2002); 3 measurements after Pavia and Mourer-Chauviré (2002); n, sample size.
Measurements (in mm) of the tarsometatarsus of Athene inexpectata sp. nov. from Langebaanweg compared with the corresponding bones of various living and fossil Athene species. Measurements of slightly worn or damaged bones are given in square brackets. The holotype is highlighted in bold, paratypes are indicated by an asterisk. 1 measurements after Mourer-Chauviré et al. (1997); 2 measurements after Louchart (2002); 3 measurements after Pavia and Mourer-Chauviré (2002); 4 measurements after Guerra et al. (2012); n, sample size.
Horizon of specimens of Athene inexpectata sp. nov. from the early Pliocene, Upper Varswater Formation at “E” Quarry, Langebaanweg, South Africa.
Genus Bubo Duméril, 1806
Type species: Bubo bubo (Linnaeus, 1758); Recent, Sweden.
Material.—Left tibiotarsus, SAM-PQ-L28439C, distal end from Langeberg Quartz Sand Member or Muishond Fontein Pelletal Phosphorite Member of the Upper Varswater Formation at Langebaanweg, early Pliocene of South Africa.
Measurements.—Distal width 13.3 mm; distal depth >10.5 mm (see Table 9).
Remarks.—The distal tibiotarsus can be referred to Strigidae rather than to Tytonidae because of the following morphological characteristics: (i) two condyli parallel and wide in distal view; (ii) condylus medialis not tilted medially; (iii) depression on the distal part of the shaft just above the trochlea cartilaginis tibialis deep in caudal view; (iv) epicondylus lateralis well developed. The specimen is comparable in size to the extinct B. leakeyae from the Early Pleistocene of Olduvai (Brodkorb and Mourer-Chauviré 1984), thus bigger than the Recent B. africanus and smaller than B. lacteus (Table 9). According to Brodkorb and Mourer-Chauviré (1984: 22), B. leakeyae and B. africanus are distinguished from B. bubo by a more developed and more medially situated tuberositas retinaculi medialis, but, unfortunately, this character is not discernible in the Langebaanweg specimen. The fossil here described is also not comparable to Bubo cf. lacteus from the Pliocene of Laetoli and the Pleistocene of Olduvai (Brodkorb and Mourer-Chauviré 1984; Louchart 2011) as no distal tibiotarsi are known for these taxa from the aforementioned localities. The fossil tibiotarsus from Langebaanweg is thus referable to a medium-sized species of the genus Bubo, apparently smaller than the largest extant species of eagle owls in Africa, i.e., B. lacteus, B. shelleyi, and B. (Scotopelia) peli. Because the specimen is only poorly preserved, we abstain from referring it to any particular species of this genus.
Measurements (in mm) of the tibiotarsus of Bubo sp. from Langebaanweg in comparison with corresponding measurements of extant and extinct Bubo species. Measurements of slightly worn or damaged bones are given in square brackets. 1 measurements after Brodkorb and Mourer-Chauviré (1984); n, sample size.
Measurements (in mm) of the tibiotarsus of Asio sp. from Langebaanweg in comparison with corresponding measurements of extant Asio species; n, sample size.
Material.—Left tibiotarsus (SAM-PQ-L20691L3, shaft) from Langeberg Quartz Sand Member; right tibiotarsus (SAM-PQ-L33521I, distal part) from Muishond Fontein Pelletal Phosphorite Member; the Upper Varswater For mation at Langebaanweg, early Pliocene of South Africa.
Measurements.—Distal right tibiotarsus SAM-PQ-L33521I: distal width 8.4 mm; distal depth 7.2 mm; minimal width of shaft 3.5 mm (see Table 10).
Description.—The two tibiotarsi from Langebaanweg are more similar to the corresponding bones of Asio than to that of other Strigidae in having: (i) distal attachment of the fibula very close to the distal end of the bone; (ii) proximal part of the trochlea cartilaginis tibialis terminates in a ridge in caudal view; (iii) tuberculum retinaculi musculi fibularis prominent. The fossils are distinguished from As. otus, but are similar to As. flammeus and As. capensis, because of the less medially tilted condylus medialis and of the general shape of the epicondylus ventralis and medialis. It is further distinguishable from As. flammeus and As. capensis by its narrower incisura intercotylaris. The fossil specimens could not be compared with corresponding bones of the extant As. abyssinicus, a species endemic to the East African rift and often considered a subspecies of As. otus, and their preservation does not allow their assignment to any particular taxon of Asio. The ungueal phalanx of Asio sp. reported from Laetoli is comparable in size with As. capensis, As. abyssinicus and As. flammeus, shows no diagnostic feature that would allow an assignment to a particular species of long-eared owl (Louchart 2011).
Strigidae gen. et sp. indet.
Material.—Left tibiotarsus, SAM-PQ-L28479 C, distal end from Langeberg Quartz Sand Member or Muishond Fontein Pelletal Phosphorite Member of the Upper Varswater Formation at Langebaanweg, early Pliocene of South Africa.
Measurements.—Distal width 8.0 mm; distal depth 6.5 mm.
Remarks.—The distal tibiotarsus is similar in size to At. inexpectata sp. nov., but can be distinguished from Athene by its wider epicondylus medialis and wider condylus medialis. It further differs from Asio, Otus, and Ptilopsis by a differently shaped condylus medialis and a distally very deep sulcus extensorius. This tibiotarsus thus indicates the presence of another small species of Strigidae at Langebaanweg, but due to its fragmentary preservation, it cannot be referred to any taxon of owl below the family level.
The extraordinarily rich fossil avifauna found at Lange baanweg makes it one of the most important bird localities of the world (Manegold et al. 2013), but, despite this great diversity, it has a relatively low number of owl taxa. This could be related to the fact that the fossil bearing sediments of the Upper Varswater Formation were deposited in coastal and fluviatile environments. It appears that the fossil strigiforms are generally better represented, in terms of species diversity and number of bones, in karst-related fossil localities, such as Quercy, France, and Gargano, Italy, where at least 11 and 7 owl taxa have been found respectively (Ballmann 1973, 1976; Mourer-Chauviré 1987), than in non-cavity sites, such as Saint-Gérand-le-Puy, France, where only 3 owl taxa are recorded (Mourer-Chauviré et al. 2013). Furthermore, several insular fossil bird associations are especially complex as it comes to the diversity of owls represented therein (Louchart 2005; Pavia 2008; Guerra et al. 2013). However, the diversity of owl species recorded at Langebaanweg is comparable, even higher, than that of most of the Neogene and Early Pleistocene African and European continental fossil localities (e.g., Ballmann 1969; Brodkorb and Mourer- Chauviré 1984; Tyrberg 1998; Louchart et al. 2009; Bedetti and Pavia 2013; Mourer-Chauviré et al. 2013). Four owl species, referable to Tyto, Asio, Bubo and at least one additional indeterminate taxon, are also recorded from the Pliocene of Laetoli (Louchart 2011).
Palaeoenvironmental implications.—Extant species of the owl genera Tyto, Asio, Athene, and Bubo are rather generalist taxa occurring in various environments ranging from open grasslands to tropical rainforests and taiga forests. Thus, evidence for these genera at Langebaanweg provides no indication for any particular palaeoenvironments in this area during the early Pliocene. Many extant owl species, in fact, breed in tree cavities or adopt abandoned nests built in trees by other bird species, while a few species, such as As. flammeus and As. capensis breed on the ground in open grasslands as well as in thick bush lands. We suppose that the proportionally more elongated hind limb elements of At. inexpectata (Fig. 2A, F) indicate that this species was more terrestrial than At. noctua. Similarly elongated hind limbs are known for the fossil taxa At. cretensis, At. megalopeza, and At. trinacriae, and especially pronounced in the extant terrestrial At. cunicularia (Pavia and Mourer-Chauviré 2002; Louchart 2005; König and Weick 2008). Unfortunately, no complete tibiotarsus is known for the fossil species making more detailed comparisons of hind limb proportions in fossil and modern Athene species impossible. The tarsometatarsus of At. inexpectata seems to be as robust as in At. angelis from the Pleistocene of Corsica (Antoine Louchart, written communication 2014), which is supposed to have been an arboreal species as suggested by the stoutness of the hind limb bones (Louchart 2002). In general the strigiforms found at Langebaanweg agree with the palaeoenvironmental reconstruction, based on the other vertebrate taxa, of mosaic of different habitats ranging from almost arid areas and open grasslands to fresh- and saltwater wetlands, and woodlands (Manegold et al. 2013).
Palaeobiogeographical implications.—Although it is very difficult to understand the relationships between Tyto richae sp. nov. and the other species of Tyto, both living and fossil, on the basis of the known material from Langebaanweg, it seems reasonable to speculate that the closest relatives of T. richae sp. nov. are the Neogene Palaearctic Tyto species such as T. sanctialbani and T. campiterrae rather than T. alba or T. capensis, which are known only from the upper Pliocene and Upper Pleistocene respectively (Harrison 1980; Mourer-Chauviré and Geraads 2010). Aside its age, such a relationship of T. richae sp. nov. is suggested by its greater resemblance to T. sanctialbani than to T. alba and T. capensis. Tyto richae sp. nov. is biogeographically well separated from its Palaearctic counterparts by the Sahara, which affected the past and current distributions of African taxa since its formation during the Middle-Late Miocene (Douady et al. 2003; Schuster et al. 2006; Brito et al. 2011). As a yet undescribed Tyto remains from the Pliocene of Ethiopia (Louchart et al. 2009), which was larger than T. alba (Antoine Louchart personal communication), might be referable to T. richae sp. nov., it would further suggest that this species had have a much wider distribution on the African continent.
Evidence for a species of Athene in southern Africa challenges earlier hypotheses on the early diversity and centre of origin of this taxon. The previously known pre-Pleistocene fossil record of Athene was limited to a few taxa with probable close affinities to At. cunicularia from the early Pliocene of Idaho and the early late Pliocene of Kansas and Nebraska (Ford 1966; Ford and Murray 1967; Feduccia 1970; Bell et al. 2004), and Athene sp. from the late Pliocene of Bulgaria (Boev 2002). The fossil record of At. noctua does not predate the Early Pleistocene and is limited to European localities (Mlíkovský 2002; Bedetti and Pavia 2013), as is the case with the additional four palaeospecies of Athene from the Mediterranean Basin (Guerra et al. 2012). Thus, it was hitherto reasonable to suppose that Athene originated in the Northern Hemisphere and became a typical element of the Palaearctic fauna. This hypothesis is also supported by the great diversification of the genus in the Western Palaearctic from the Pleistocene onwards, as testified by the recognition of several fossil and living taxa (Pavia and Mourer-Chauviré 2002; König and Weick 2008; Guerra et al. 2012; Pellegrino et al. 2014). Athene inexpectata sp. nov. now provides evidence for a former much wider distribution of the genus and one could speculate that this taxon in fact originated in Africa. Be that as it may, the presence of an otherwise primarily Eurasian taxon such as Athene in the extreme South of Africa is not without parallels: Langebaanweg has also produced remains of the bear Agriotherium africanum and the wolverine Plesiogulo monspessulanus (Hendey 1980; Werdelin and Peigné 2010), whose closest relatives were once widespread in the Northern Hemisphere. This fact can be interpreted as additional evidence of the biogeographical links between Eurasia and South Africa subsequent to the Late Miocene collision of the African and Eurasian plates that allowed the mixing of taxa previously endemic to each of these continents (Roberts et al. 2011). Finally, it is noteworthy that evidence for owl taxa now endemic to Africa, such as Ptilopsis, is still lacking for any African fossil sites including Langebaanweg.
We would like to thank Sven Tränkner (Senckenberg Forschungsinstitut und Naturmuseum Frankfurt/Main, Germany) for taking photographs, Romala Govender (SAM) for the loan of fossil material, Giovanni Boano (Museo Civico di Storia Naturale, Carmagnola, Torino, Italy), Angelo Lietti (Museo Civico di Lentate sul Seveso, Monza, Italy), Mark Adams and Judith White (both Natural History Museum, London/ Tring, UK), and Gerald Mayr (Senckenberg Forschungsinstitut und Naturmuseum) for allowing access to collections and specimens. We also thank Cecile Mourer-Chauviré (UCB, Lyon, France) and Antoine Louchart (CNRS, Lyon, France), whose critical comments helped to improve an earlier version of our manuscript, and the Editor Stephen Brusatte (University of Edinburgh, UK) for his support. MP was supported by the Italian MIUR PRIN 2012MY8AB2 (resp. Massimo Delfino). AM was supported by DFG grant MA 4809/1-1 and by Synthesys grant GB-TAF-2785.
- P. Ballmann 1969. Die Vogel aus der Altburdigalen Spaltenfullung van Wintershof (West) bei Eichstätt in Bayern. Zitteliana 1: 5–60. Google Scholar
- P. Ballmann 1973. Fossile Vögel aus dem Neogen der Halbinsel Gargano (Italien). Scripta Geologica 17: 1–57. Google Scholar
- P. Ballmann 1976. Fossile Vögel aus dem Neogen der Halbinsel Gargano (Italien). Zweiter Teil. Scripta Geologica 38: 1–59. Google Scholar
- J.J. Baumel and L.M. Witmer 1993. Osteologia. In : J.J. Baumel (ed.), Handbook of Avian Anatomy: Nomina Anatomica Avium. Second Edition , 45–132. Nuttall Ornithological Club, Cambridge. Google Scholar
- C. Bedetti and M. Pavia 2013. Early Pleistocene birds from Pirro Nord (Puglia, southern Italy). Palaeontographica Abteilung A-Palaozoologie- Stratigraphie 298: 31–53. Google Scholar
- C.J. Bell , E.L.J. Lundelius , A.D. Barnosky , R.W. Graham , E.H. Lindsay , D.R.J. Ruez , H.A.J. Semken , D.S. Webb , and R.J. Zakrzewski 2004. The Blancan, Irvingtonian, and Rancholabrean Mammal Ages. In : M.O. Woodburne (ed.), Late Cretaceous and Cenozoic Mammals of North America , 232–314. Columbia University Press, New York. Google Scholar
- L.R. Berger and R.J. Clarke 1995. Eagle involvement in accumulation of the Taung child fauna. Journal of Human Evolution 29: 275–299. Google Scholar
- R.L Bernor , L. Kordos , L. Rook et al. 2002. Recent Advances on Multidisciplinary Research at Rudabánya, Late Miocene (MN9), Hungary: a compendium. Palaeontographia Italica 89: 3–36. Google Scholar
- G.J. Billberg 1828. Synopsis Faunae Scandinaviae, Tomo 1, Part 2 (Aves). 208 pp. Holmiae ed., Stockholm. Google Scholar
- Z. Boev 2002. Neogene avifauna of Bulgaria. In : Z. Zhou and F. Zhang (eds.), Proceedings of the 5th Symposium of the SAPE , 29–40. Beijing Science Press, Beijing. Google Scholar
- F. Boie 1822. Isis (Oder Encyclopädische Zeitung von Oken 1820–1848) , 545–564. Expedition der Isis, Jena. Google Scholar
- M.J. Brisson 1760. Ornithologie ou méthode contenant la division des oiseaux en ordres, sections, genres, especes & leurs variétés. A laquelle on a joint une description exacte de chaque espece, avec les citations des auteurs qui en ont traité, les noms qu'ils leur ont donnés, ceux que leur ont donnés les différentes nations, & les noms vulgaires. 544 pp. Bauche, Paris. Google Scholar
- J.C. Brito , F. Martinez-Freiria , P. Sierra , N. Sillero , and P. Tarroso 2011. Crocodiles in the Sahara Desert: an update of distribution, habitats and population status for conservation planning in Mauritania. Plos One 6 (2): e14374. Google Scholar
- P. Brodkorb and C. Mourer-Chauviré 1984. Fossil owls from early man sites of Olduvai Gorges, Tanzania. Ostrich 55: 17–27. Google Scholar
- M.D. Bruce 1999. Family Tytonidae (Barn-owls). In : J. del Hoyo , A. Elliott , and J. Sargatal (eds.), Handbook of the Birds of the World. Vol. 5. Barn-Owls to Hummingbirds , 34–75. Lynx Edicion, Barcelona. Google Scholar
- J. Brunet 1961. Oiseaux. In : R. Lavocat (ed.), Le gisement de Vertébrés miocènes de Beni-Mellal (Maroc). Etude systématique de la Faune de mammifères et conclusions générales. Notes et Mémoires du Service Géologique du Maroc 237: 105–108. Google Scholar
- J. Brunet 1971. Oiseaux miocènes de Beni-Mellal (Maroc); un complément à leur étude. Notes et Mémoires du Service Géologique du Maroc 237: 109–111. Google Scholar
- J. Cheneval 2000. L'avifaune de Sansan. Mémoires du Muséum National d'Histoire Naturelle 183: 321–388. Google Scholar
- H.B.S. Cooke 1990. Taung fossils in the University of California collections. In : G.H. Sperber (ed.), From Apes to Angels: Essay in Anthropology in honor of Phillip V. Tobias , 119–134. Wiley-Liss, New York. Google Scholar
- C.J. Douady , F. Catzeflis , J. Raman , M.S. Springer , and M.J. Stanhope 2003. The Sahara as a vicariant agent, and the role of Miocene climatic events, in the diversification of the mammalian order Macroscelidea (elephant shrews). Proceedings of the National Academy of Science 100: 8325–8330. Google Scholar
- A. von den Driesch 1976. A guide to the measurements of animal bones from archaeological sites. Peabody Museum Bulletin 1: 1–129. Google Scholar
- C.A.M. Duméril 1806. Zoologie Analityque. 344 pp. Libraire Allais, Paris. Google Scholar
- A.J. Feduccia 1970. The avifauna of the Sand Draw local fauna (Aftonian) of Brown County, Nehraska. The Wilson Bulletin 82: 332–334. Google Scholar
- N.L. Ford 1966. Fossil owls from the Rexroad fauna of the Upper Pliocene of Kansas. The Condor 68: 472–475. Google Scholar
- N.L. Ford and B.G.J. Murray 1967. Fossil Owls from the Hagerman Local Fauna (Upper Pliocene) of Idaho. The Auk 84: 115–117. Google Scholar
- U.B. Göhlich and P.A. Ballmann 2013. A new barn owl (Aves: Strigiformes: Tytonidae) from the Middle Miocene of the Nördlinger Ries (Germany) with remarks on the history of the owls. In : U.B. Göhlich and A. Kroh (eds.), Paleontological Research 2013—Proceedings of the 8th International Meeting of the Society of Avian Palaeontology and Evolution , 103–122. Naturhistorisches Museum Wien, Wien. Google Scholar
- C. Guerra , P. Bover , and J.A. Alcover 2012. A new species of extinct little owl from the Pleistocene of Mallorca (Balearic Islands). Journal of Ornithology 153: 347–354. Google Scholar
- C. Guerra , M. McMinn , and J.A. Alcover 2013. The Upper Pleistocene- Holocene raptorial bird guild from Eivissa Island (Pityusic Archipelago, Western Mediterranean Sea). Geobios 46: 491–502. Google Scholar
- C.J.O. Harrison 1980. Fossil birds from afrotropical Africa in the collection of the British Museum (Natural History). Ostrich 51: 92–98. Google Scholar
- Q.B. Hendey 1974. The late Cenozoic Carnivora of the southwestern Cape Province. Annals of the South African Museum 63: 1–369. Google Scholar
- Q.B. Hendey 1980. Agriotherium (Mammalia, Ursidae) from Langebaanweg, South Africa, and relationships of the genus. Annals of the South African Museum 81: 1–109. Google Scholar
- Q.B. Hendey 1981. Palaeoecology of the late Tertiary fossil occurrences in “E” Quarry, Langebaanweg, South Africa, and a reinterpretation of their geological context. Annals of the South African Museum 84: 1–104. Google Scholar
- D. Jánossy 1974. Upper Pliocene and Lower Pleistocene bird remains from Poland. Acta zoologica cracoviensia 19: 531–566. Google Scholar
- D. Jánossy 1991. Late Miocene bird remains from Polgardi (W Hungary). Aquila 98: 13–35. Google Scholar
- C. König and F. Weick 2008. Owls of the World. Second Edition. 528 pp. Christopher Helm, London. Google Scholar
- E.N. Kurochkin and G.J. Dyke 2011. The First Fossil Owls (Aves: Strigiformes) from the Paleogene of Asia and a Review of the Fossil Record of Strigiformes. Palaeontological Journal 45: 445–458. Google Scholar
- C. von Linnaeus 1758. Systema naturae per regna tria naturae, secundum classes, ordines, genera, species, cum characteribus, differentiis, synonymis, locis. Tenth Edition. 824 pp. Laurentii Salvii, Stockholm. Google Scholar
- A. Louchart 2002. Les oiseaux du Pléistocène de Corse et de quelques localités sardes. Écologie, évolution, biogéographie et extinctions. Documents des Laboratoires de Géologie de Lyon 155: 1–287. Google Scholar
- A. Louchart 2005. Integrating the fossil record in the study of insular body size evolution: example of owls (Aves, Strigiformes). In : J.A. Alcover and P. Bover (eds.), International Symposium “Insular Vertebrate Evolution: the Paleontological Approach”. Monografies de la Societat d'Historia Natural de le Balears 12: 155–174. Google Scholar
- A. Louchart 2011. Aves. In : T.H. Harrison (ed.), Paleontology and Geology of Laetoli: Human Evolution in Context. Volume 2: Fossil Hominins and the Associated Fauna. Vertebrate Paleobiology and Paleoanthropology , 505–533. Springer Science, New York. Google Scholar
- A. Louchart , H. Wesselman , R.J. Blumenschine , L.J. Hlusko , J.K. Njau , M.T. Black , M. Asnake , and T.D. White 2009. Taphonomic, avian, and small-vertebrate indicators of Ardipithecus ramidus habitat. Science 326: 66 (66e1–66e4). Google Scholar
- A. Manegold , A. Louchart , J. Carrier , and A. Elzanowski 2013. The early Pliocene avifauna of Langebaanweg (South Africa): a review and update. In : U.B. Göhlich and A. Kroh (eds.), Paleontological Research 2013—Proceedings of the 8th International Meeting of the Society of Avian Palaeontology and Evolution , 135–152. Naturhistorisches Museum Wien, Wien. Google Scholar
- A. Manegold , M. Pavia , and P. Haarhoff 2014. A new species of Aegypius vulture (Aegypiinae, Accipitridae) from the early Pliocene of South Africa. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 34: 1394–1407. Google Scholar
- J.S. Marks , R.J. Cannings , and H. Mikkola 1999. Family Strigidae (Typical Owls). In : J. del Hoyo , A. Elliott , and J. Sargatal (eds.), Handbook of the Birds of the World. Vol. 5. Barn-owls to Hummingbirds , 76–242. Lynx Edicion, Barcelona. Google Scholar
- G. Mayr 2009. Paleogene Fossil Birds. 261 pp. Springer, Berlin. Google Scholar
- J. Mlíkovský 1998. Two new owls (Aves: Strigidae) from the early Miocene of the Czech Republic, with comments on the fossil history of the subfamily Striginae. Buteo 10: 5–22. Google Scholar
- J. Mlíkovský 2002. Cenozoic Birds of the World. Part 1: Europe. 406 pp. Ninox Press, Praha. Google Scholar
- C. Mourer-Chauviré 1987. Les Strigiformes (Aves) des phosphorites du Quercy (France): systématique, biostratigraphie, paléobiogéographie. Documents des Laboratoires de Géologie de la Faculté des Sciences de Lyon 99: 89–135. Google Scholar
- C. Mourer-Chauviré , J.A. Alcover , S. Moya , and J. Pons 1980. Une nouvelle forme insulaire d'effraie géante, Tyto balearica n. sp., du Plio- Pléistocène des Baléares. Geobios 13: 803–811. Google Scholar
- C. Mourer-Chauviré and D. Geraads 2010. The Upper Pliocene Avifauna of Ahl al Oughlam, Morocco. Systematics and Biogeography. Records of the Australian Museum 62: 157–184. Google Scholar
- C. Mourer-Chauviré , J.-B. Peyrouse , and M. Hugueney 2013. A new roller (Aves: Coraciiformes s. s.: Coraciidae) from the Early Miocene of the Saint-Gérand-le-Puy area, Allier, France. In : U.B. Göhlich and A. Kroh (eds.), Paleontological Research 2013-Proceedings of the 8th International Meeting of the Society of Avian Palaeontology and Evolution , 81–92. Naturhistorisches Museum Wien, Wien. Google Scholar
- C. Mourer-Chauviré , M. Salotti , E. Pereira , Y. Quinif , J.Y. Courtois , J.N. Dubois , and J.C. La Milza 1997. Athene angelis n. sp. (Aves, Strigiformes), nouvelle espèce endémique insulaire éteinte du Pléistocène moyen et supérieur de Corse (France). Comptes Rendus de l'Académie des Sciences Paris 324: 677–684. Google Scholar
- M. Pavia 2004. A new large barn owl (Aves, Strigiformes, Tytonidae) from the Middle Pleistocene of Sicily, Italy, and its taphonomical significance. Geobios 37: 631–641. Google Scholar
- M. Pavia 2008. The evolution dynamics of the Strigiformes in the Mediterranean islands with the description of Aegolius martae n. sp. (Aves, Strigidae). Quaternary International 182: 80–89. Google Scholar
- M. Pavia and C. Mourer-Chauviré 2002. An overview on the genus Athene in the Pleistocene Mediterranean Islands with the description of Athene trinacriae n. sp. (Aves, Strigiformes). In : Z. Zhou and F. Zhang (eds.), Proceedings of the 5th Symposium of the Society of Avian Paleontology and Evolution , 13–27. Beijin Science Press, Beijing. Google Scholar
- M. Pavia and C. Mourer-Chauviré 2011. Redescription of Tyto sanctialbani Lydekker, 1893 (Aves, Strigiformes), from its type locality of La Grive-Saint-Alban (middle Miocene, France). Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 31: 1093–1101. Google Scholar
- I. Pellegrino , A. Negri , M. Cucco , N. Mucci , M. Pavia , M. Salek , G. Boano , and E. Randi 2014. Phylogeography and Pleistocene refugia of the Little Owl (Athene noctua) as inferred from mtDNA sequence data. Ibis 156: 639–657. Google Scholar
- I. Plug and J.L. Clark 2008. In the air: a preliminary report on the birds from Sibudu Cave, Kwazulu-Natal, South Africa. South African Archaeological Society Goodwin Series 10: 133–142. Google Scholar
- T.N. Pockock 1970. Pleistocene bird fossils from Kromdraai and Sterkfontein. Ostrich 8 (Supplement): 1–6. Google Scholar
- P.V. Rich 1974. Significance of the Tertiary avifaunas from Africa (with emphasis on a Mid to Late Miocene avifauna from Southern Tunisia). Annals of the Geological Survey of Egypt 4: 167–210. Google Scholar
- P.V. Rich 1980. Preliminary report on the fossil avian remains from late Tertiary sediments at Langebaanweg (Cape Province), South Africa. South African Journal of Science 76: 166–170. Google Scholar
- R. Ridgway 1914. A descriptive catalogue of the higher genera, species, and subspecies of birds know to occur in North America, from the Arctic lands to the Isthmus of Panama the West Indies and other islands of the Caribbean Sea, and the Galapagos Archipelago. Bulletin of the United States National Museum 50: 1–886. Google Scholar
- D.L. Roberts , T. Matthews , A.I.R. Herries , C. Boulter , L. Scott , C. Dondo , P. Mtembi , C. Browning , R.M.H. Smith , P. Haarhoff , and M.D. Bateman 2011. Regional and global context of the Late Cenozoic Langebaanweg (LBW) palaeontological site: West Coast of South Africa. Earth-Science Reviews 106: 191–214. Google Scholar
- M. Schuster , P. Duringer , J.-F. Ghienne , P. Vignaud , H.T. Mackaye , A. Likius , and M. Brunet 2006. The age of the Sahara desert. Science 311: 821. Google Scholar
- G.A. Scopoli 1769. Annus I Historico Naturalis. 168 pp. Gottlob Hilscheri, Lipsia. Google Scholar
- P.V. Serebrovsky [Serebrovskij, P.V.] 1941. Birds from the Pliocene deposits of Odessa [in Russian]. Doklady Akademii Nauk SSSR (novaâ seriâ) 33: 476–479. Google Scholar
- T. Tyrberg 1998. Pleistocene Birds of the Palearctic: A Catalogue. 720 pp. Nuttall Ornithological Club, Cambridge. Google Scholar
- A.S. Umanskaya [Umanskaâ, A.S.] 1979. New species of Horned Owl (Bubo longaevus) from the late Neogene deposits of northern Pricernomor'e USSR [in Russian]. Dopovidi Akademiji Nauk Ukrains'koji RSR 1979: 779–782. Google Scholar
- J.G. Wagler 1830. Natürliches System der Amphibien mit vorangehender Classification der Säugethiere und Vögel. Ein Beitrag zur vergleichenden Zoologie. 354 pp. Cotta, Munich. Google Scholar
- C.A. Walker and G.J. Dyke 2006. New records of fossil birds of prey from the Miocene of Kenya. Historical Biology 18: 95–98. Google Scholar
- V. Watson 1993. Composition of the Swartkrans bone accumulations, in terms of skeletal parts and animals represented. In : C.K. Brain (ed.), A Cave Chronicle of Early Man , 35–73. Transvaal Museum, Pretoria. Google Scholar
- P.D.M. Weesie 1982. A Pleistocene endemic island form within the genus Athene: Athene cretensis n. sp. (Aves, Strigiformes) from Crete. Proceedings of the Koninklijke Nederlands Akademie van Wetenschappen Amsterdam. Series B 85: 323–336. Google Scholar
- L. Werdelin and S. Peigné 2010. Carnivora. In : L. Werdelin and W.J. Sanders (eds.), Cenozoic Mammals of Africa , 603–657. University of California Press, Berkley. Google Scholar