Translator Disclaimer
1 December 2010 A Second Cretaceous Ornithuromorph Bird from the Changma Basin, Gansu Province, Northwestern China
Author Affiliations +

Finely-bedded lacustrine deposits of the Aptian (Lower Cretaceous) Xiagou Formation exposed in the Changma Basin of Gansu Province, northwestern China, have yielded numerous fossil vertebrate remains, including approximately 100 avian specimens. Though the majority of these birds appear referable to the ornithuromorph Gansus yumenensis, a number of enantiornithine fossils have also been recovered. Here we report on a specimen consisting of a complete, three-dimensionally preserved sternum, furcula, and sternal ribs that represents a second ornithuromorph taxon from the Xiagou Formation at Changma. The fossil exhibits morphologies that distinguish it from all previously-known Xiagou birds and demonstrate that it represents a derived non-ornithurine member of Ornithuromorpha. Though it is morphologically distinct from the equivalent elements of all other described ornithuromorphs, the material is too incomplete to justify the erection of a new taxon. Nonetheless, it increases the taxonomic diversity of the Xiagou avifauna, thereby expanding our knowledge of Early Cretaceous avian diversity and evolution.


In recent decades, Lower Cretaceous deposits have yielded spectacular fossil discoveries that have provided critical insight into early avian evolution and diversification (Hou 1997a; Chiappe and Dyke 2002, 2006; Sanz et al. 2002; Zhou and Hou 2002; Zhou and Zhang 2006a). The majority of these fossils pertain to Enantiornithes, which is widely regarded as the dominant Cretaceous avian clade; Ornithuromorpha, the group that includes modern birds (Neornithes) and their nearest relatives, is much more poorly represented. Due to the relative scarcity of archaic ornithuromorph fossils, the paleoecological, temporal, and phylogenetic contexts of the origin and early diversification of this clade remain unclear. Consequently, new Early Cretaceous ornithuromorph material is important for an increased understanding of the early evolution of the modern bird lineage.

Most Early Cretaceous avian fossils have come from strata of the Jehol Group, which are primarily exposed in Liaoning and Hebei provinces of northeastern China. The Jehol avifauna is dominated in both numbers and diversity by basal (i.e., non-ornithothoracine) and enantiornithine taxa, but it has also yielded several basal ornithuromorphs, including Archaeorhynchus spathula (Zhou and Zhang 2006b), Chaoyangia beishanensis (Hou and Zhang 1993), Hongshanornis longicresta (Zhou and Zhang 2005), Jianchangornis microdonta (Zhou et al. 2009), Longicrusavis houi (O'Connor et al. 2010), Songlingornis linghensis (Hou 1997a), Yanornis martini (Zhou and Zhang 2001), and Yixianornis grabaui (Zhou and Zhang 2001).

Fig. 1.

Geographic location of the Changma Basin (indicated by avian silhouette), northwestern Gansu Province, China.


Situated some 2000 km west of Jehol Group localities, outcrops of the Lower Cretaceous Xiagou Formation in the Changma Basin of Gansu Province in northwestern China (Fig. 1) have also yielded a significant assemblage of avian remains. The first bird fossil discovered in this basin was the holotypic distal pelvic limb of the ornithuromorph Gansus yumenensis, found in 1981 (Hou and Liu 1984). Renewed fieldwork in the Changma Basin beginning in 2002 has yielded approximately 85 partial to nearly complete ornithuromorph skeletons, as well as roughly a dozen enantiornithine fossils (You et al. 2005; Harris et al. 2006a; Lamanna et al. 2006b, 2009; unpublished data) representing at least two taxa (Lamanna et al. 2006b; unpublished data). A significant number of these specimens preserve carbonized remnants of soft-tissues, such as feathers, keratin, or skin. However, despite this wealth of material, until recently Gansus remained the only ornithuromorph taxon identified in the Xiagou Formation avifauna (You et al. 2006).

Recent preparation of many Xiagou avian specimens collected since 2004 has allowed their more precise identification and analysis. Among these is FRDC-05-CM-021, an associated sternum, furcula, and sternal ribs that are neither enantiornithine nor referable to Gansus (Fig. 2). Although the specimen is incomplete, it demonstrates that Gansus was not the only ornithuromorph taxon in the Xiagou avifauna. Compared to other currently known Early Cretaceous avian assemblages, as presently understood, that of the Xiagou Formation is unique in that fossils of ornithuromorphs numerically dominate over those of enantiornithines. With the addition of the taxon represented by FRDC-05-CM-021, the Xiagou avifauna can be shown to further differ from that of the Jehol Group in exhibiting subequal low-level taxonomic diversity within Enantiornithes and Ornithuromorpha.

Institutional abbreviations.—BPV, Beijing Natural History Museum, Paleovertebrate Collection, Beijing, China; CAGS-IG, Chinese Academy of Geological Sciences, Institute of Geology, Beijing, China; DNHM, Dalian Natural History Museum, Dalian, China; FRDC, Fossil Research and Development Center, Third Geology and Mineral Resources Exploration Academy, Gansu Provincial Bureau of Geo-Exploration and Mineral Development, Lanzhou, China; IGM, Institute of Geology, Mongolian Academy of Sciences, Ulaan Bataar, Mongolia; IVPP, Institute of Vertebrate Paleontology and Paleoanthropology, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing, China; LH, Las Hoyas Collection, Museo de Cuenca, Cuenca, Spain; LHV, Department of Land and Resources of Liaoning Province, Shenyang, China; NIGPAS, Nanjing Institute of Geology and Paleontology, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Nanjing, China; PKUP, Peking University Paleontological Collection, Beijing, China; SMM, Sternberg Museum of Natural History, Fort Hays State University, Hays, USA; YPM, Peabody Museum of Natural History, Yale University, New Haven, USA.

Geological setting

Mesozoic strata exposed in the Changma Basin pertain to the Lower Cretaceous Xiagou and Zhonggou formations, which together constitute the Xinminpu Group (Bureau of Geology and Mineral Resources of Gansu Province 1989, 1997; Editorial Committee of Chinese Stratigraphic Standard: Cretaceous 2000; Tang et al. 2001). The avian fossil described herein comes from laminated brownish-yellow shales of the Xiagou Formation. The Xiagou Formation has yielded numerous specimens of plants, bivalves, gastropods, ostracodes, conchostracans, insects, fishes (Ma 1993; Murray et al. 2010), a salamander, turtles, and birds (You et al. 2005, 2006; Harris et al. 2006a; Lamanna et al. 2006a, b, 2009; unpublished data). Though much of it has not yet been studied in detail, the fossil assemblage of the Xiagou Formation at Changma is generally perceived to be comparable to the EosestheriaEpicharmeropsis (= Ephemeropsis sensu Huang et al. [2007])—Lycoptera fauna of the Jehol Biota of eastern Asia (Chang et al. 2003), though it lacks the latter taxon. However, the Chijinpu Formation, which underlies the Xiagou Formation, has reportedly produced specimens of Lycoptera (Editorial Committee of Chinese Stratigraphic Standard: Cretaceous 2000). Together with recent radiometric dates (Li and Yang 2004) and chemo-stratigraphic age estimates (Suarez et al. 2008), this evidence suggests that the Xiagou Formation is slightly younger than the Jehol Biota, probably pertaining to the lower or middle portion of the Aptian Stage of the Lower Cretaceous (∼120–115 Mya; Ogg et al. 2008).

Systematic paleontology

Aves Linnaeus, 1758
Ornithothoraces Chiappe, 1996
Ornithuromorpha Chiappe, 2002
Gen. et sp. indet.
Fig. 2.

  • Material.—FRDC-05-CM-021, a complete, associated sternum and furcula, with sternal ribs and possible thoracic rib fragments.

  • Description.—FRDC-05-CM-021 remains embedded in the matrix in which it was found; the dorsal surface of the sternum has been exposed via preparation, and the furcula is exposed in cranial view. All elements are preserved in three dimensions with minimal crushing and distortion. The furcula has been displaced from its position in life to lie obliquely on the cranial portion of the sternum; the preserved sternal ribs have been disarticulated from their corresponding costal facets and rest in the dorsal concavity of the sternum just caudal to the furcula.

    Ribs: The ribs are slender elements, triangular in cross section proximally and rounding to a more oval cross section distally. It appears that all preserved ribs and rib fragments are of sternal ribs, though it is possible that some of the smaller, thinner fragments pertain to thoracic ribs.

    Furcula: The furcula is exposed in cranial view. The general morphology of the element is reminiscent of that in many basal ornithuromorphs such as Archaeorhynchus spathula (IVPP V14287; Zhou and Zhang 2006b), Gansus yumenensis (CAGS-IG-04-CM-003, CAGS-IG-04-CM-004; You et al. 2006), Jianchangornis microdonta (IVPP V16708; Zhou et al. 2009), and Yanornis martini (IVPP V12558, V13358; Zhou and Zhang 2001; Zhou et al. 2002, 2004). It is narrow (having a low interclavicular angle), U-shaped, and lacks a hypocleideum. The latter morphology is characteristic of most non-neornithine ornithuromorphs, including Archaeorhynchus, Gansus, Jianchangornis, Yanornis, Yixianornis grabaui (IVPP V12631 [Zhou and Zhang 2001; Clarke et al. 2006]), and probably Ichthyornis dispar (YPM 1755 [Marsh 1880; Clarke 2004]), but it differs from the small hypocleideum present in Hongshanornithidae (Hongshanornis longicresta + Longicrusavis houi; O'Connor et al. 2010) and is highly distinct from the hypertrophied hypocleideum of enantiornithines such as Eoalulavis hoyasi (LH 13500; Sanz et al. 1996, 2002) and Sinornis santensis (BPV 538; Sereno and Rao 1992; Sereno et al. 2002). The sternal extremity is convex in cranial view, as opposed to the straighter margins present in Gansus and Yixianornis. The rami are oval in cross-section at mid-shaft, with the long axis oriented obliquely such that the caudal margin lies in a plane medial to that of the cranial margin. Omally, the rami curve and expand caudally as in Gansus and modern birds. The rami gently increase in size caudally over their omal one-third; the omal tips also expand medially. Due to the essentially two-dimensional preservation of most other Cretaceous ornithuromorphs, we are unable to determine whether or not most of these morphologies are present in other taxa, though medial expansions are lacking in Gansus, Ichthyornis (SMM 2503; Clarke 2004), and Yixianornis. The interior of the furcula, visible in a break at midshaft of the right ramus (Fig. 2), is apneumatic.

    Sternum: The sternum is exposed in dorsal view, with much of its morphology preserved in three dimensions (Fig. 2). It is comparable in size to a small (presumably juvenile or subadult) Gansus sternum, FRDC-06-CM-011 (Fig. 3), which demonstrates that FRDC-05-CM-021 does not represent an early stage in the ontogeny of that genus. The cranial margin bears deep, mediolaterally wide sulci for the articulation of the coracoids. This suggests that the sternal margin of the coracoid was also wide, as in most other basal ornithuromorphs (e.g., Gansus, Songlingornis linghensis [IVPP V10913; Hou 1997a], Yanornis) but in contrast with the narrower coracoidal sternal margins of Apsaravis ukhaana (IGM 100/1017 [Norell and Clarke 2001; Clarke and Norell 2002]) and most enantiornithines. The coracoidal sulci meet craniomedially, with the left and right margins of the sternum intersecting at an angle of approximately 100°, constituting an unusually sharp craniomedial apex. This morphology is similar to those of Archaeorhynchus, Jianchangornis, Songlingornis, and the probable basal ornithuromorph Aberratiodontus wui (LHV 0001; Gong et al. 2004). Conversely, in Apsaravis and Gansus, the cranial margin of the sternum lacks this “peaked” appearance because the coracoidal sulci meet at a much greater angle (approximately 160° in Gansus; Fig. 3B). The dorsal margin of each coracoidal facet projects cranially relative to the ventral margin, as in Yixianornis. The cranial midline of the sternum is abraded and was almost certainly flattened during diagenesis, but the broad base of an internal spinous rostrum (Baumel and Witmer 1993) is preserved. It appears to have been more robust than those of Apsaravis or Archaeorhynchus, but similar to that present in Jianchangornis.

    The cranial and craniolateral margins of the sternum bound the concave dorsal surface. The craniolateral corners of the margin form sharp processes, as in some other basal ornithuromorphs (e.g., Jianchangornis, Songlingornis, Yanornis). In Gansus (e.g., FRDC-05-CM-005), these processes are proportionally more robust and may have projected dorsolaterally (Fig. 3B). The lateral margin of the sternum bears at least four costal facets separated by spaces approximately 1.5 times greater in craniocaudal length than the facets themselves. The total number of costal facets may have been higher: five sternal ribs are preserved on each side, but the obscured caudal portion of the left costal articular region makes an exact facet count difficult. Gansus (FRDC-04-CM-020) appears to possess six costal facets (contra Harris et al. 2006b); the cranial two facets are shallow and not as well-defined as the caudal four. Furthermore, the facets are almost directly adjacent, as opposed to the widely separated facets of FRDC-05-CM-021. Immediately caudal to the costal region, and visible only on the right side of the sternum, the lateral margin appears to be attenuated into a laterally projecting, triangular process (the “zyphoid process” of Clarke et al. 2006). Similar processes are present in Gansus (Fig. 3B), Songlingornis (Hou 1997a), and Yixianornis (Clarke et al. 2006), but are larger and more rounded in these genera.

    Caudally, the sternum is deeply excavated by four V-shaped incisures bounded by elongate, strap-like lateral, intermediate, and medial trabeculae. The incisures are much deeper than in other known basal ornithuromorphs, with the exception of Archaeorhynchus (Zhou and Zhang 2006b). In this latter taxon, however, the transverse distance between the lateral trabeculae is considerably greater than the width of the sternal body at its craniocaudal midpoint, while this intertrabecular space is approximately as wide as the sternal body in FRDC-05-CM-021. In addition, Archaeorhynchus appears to lack intermediate trabeculae (Zhou and Zhang 2006b: fig. 3).

    Though the total craniocaudal length of the sternum of FRDC-05-CM-021 is comparable to those of other basal ornithuromorphs (Table 1), the sternal body is comparatively much shorter than in most of these taxa. Indeed, this relatively short sternal body with long trabeculae is reminiscent of the morphology observed in some enantiornithines (e.g., Longipteryx chaoyangensis [IVPP V12325; Zhang et al. 2001], Vescornis hebeiensis [NIGPAS 130722; Zhang et al. 2004]). We hypothesize that, in life, the lateral trabeculae projected caudodorsally as in modern birds, but that they were broken and flattened during diagenesis. The lateral and intermediate trabeculae project caudally past the caudal end of the medial trabecula, and are of approximately equal length (the lateral trabeculae are slightly longer). Many other basal ornithuromorphs (e.g., Gansus, Songlingornis, Yanornis, Yixianornis), in contrast, are characterized by a single set of free trabeculae (the lateral pair), while the strap-like intermediate trabeculae curve toward the sternal midline to contact and fuse with the medial trabecula, enclosing caudal fenestrae. Like FRDC-05-CM-021, Hongshanornis and Jianchangornis also exhibit intermediate trabeculae that do not merge with the medial trabecula; in these taxa, however, the intermediate trabeculae are much shorter than the lateral trabeculae. In FRDC-05-CM-021, the lateral trabeculae are craniocaudally oriented and straight, while the intermediate trabeculae project caudomedially, approaching the midline but remaining distinct from the medial trabecula. The lateral trabeculae appear to have been moderately expanded at their caudal tips, but this is uncertain because the caudal morphologies of the two trabeculae differ: the right trabecula exhibits an expansion in the shape of a sharp, reverse L-shaped “boot” that tapers medially, but on the left side, the expansion is much more subtle. Additionally, the caudal margin of the left expansion appears to be excavated by a groove (although this is possibly an artifact resulting from damage to a morphology more similar to that preserved in the right lateral trabecula). Caudal expansions of the lateral trabeculae are common among enantiornithines and present in some basal ornithuromorphs (e.g., Jianchangornis, Songlingornis, Yanornis, Yixianornis) but absent in others (e.g., Archaeorhynchus, Hongshanornis). The medial trabecula is laterally convex cranially, but sharply tapers caudally into a narrow, pointed, V-shaped process. The median sternal sulcus is visible along the length of the sternum, and is especially prominent along the medial trabecula (likely emphasized by crushing here). This midline groove is also present in some specimens of Gansus (e.g., FRDC-05-CM-005, FRDC-06-CM-011) and in modern birds.

    Stratigraphical and geographical range.—Near the town of Changma, in the Changma Basin, Gansu Province, north-western China (Fig. 1). Precise locality information is available to qualified researchers upon request. Lower Cretaceous (lower—middle? Aptian) Xiagou Formation, lower unit of the Xinminpu Group.

  • Fig. 2.

    Ornithuromorpha gen. et sp. indet. (FRDC-05-CM-021) from the Early Cretaceous of the Changma Basin, northwestern Gansu Province, China: associated furcula (in cranial view), sternum (in dorsal view), and ribs. Photograph (A), interpretive drawing (B). Dashed lines in B represent points of breakage; gray areas represent holes.


    Fig. 3.

    Early Cretaceous ornithuromorph birds from the Changma Basin, northwestern Gansu Province, China: reconstructed sterna in dorsal view. A. Ornithuromorpha gen. et sp. indet. (FRDC-05-CM-021). B. Gansus yumenensis (FRDC-06-CM-011, small [presumably juvenile or subadult] individual).


    Table 1.

    Measurements (mm) of pectoral elements in selected Early Cretaceous Chinese basal ornithuromorphs: Ornithuromorpha gen. et sp. indet. (FRDC-05-CM-021), Gansus yumenensis (CAGS-IG-04-CM-003), Sunglingornis linghensis (IVPP V10913; Hou 1997a: table 17), Yanornis martini (IVPP V12558; Zhou et al. 2002: supplementary information), and Yixianornis grabaui (IVPP V12631; Clarke et al. 2006: table 1).


    Phylogenetic analysis

    A phylogenetic analysis was performed using the dataset of O'Connor et al. (2009), with the deletion of Longicrusavis houi and Rapaxavis pani (presented therein as PKUP V1069 and DNHM D2522, respectively) and the addition of FRDC-05-CM-021, Archaeorhynchus spathula, Liaoningornis longidigitris, Songlingornis linghensis, and three undescribed Xiagou Formation enantiornithine specimens (see Supplementary Online Material at The large number of enantiornithine taxa incorporated into the analysis was intended to provide a substantial representation of this avian clade so as not to bias FRDC-05-CM-021 toward Ornithuromorpha on the basis of morphological inferences. Neornithes was represented by Anas platyrhynchos and Gallus gallus; Dromaeosauridae was scored as the outgroup. A matrix of 214 characters (31 ordered; 28 uninformative characters removed from data set of 242, see Supplementary Online Material 2) and 34 taxa was evaluated using NONA ver. 2.0 (Goloboff 1993); optimal trees were identified by a heuristic search implementing 1000 replicates of the Tree Bisection and Reconnection (TBR) algorithm, retaining the 10 shortest trees from each replication. Additional TBR branch-swapping was not required.

    The analysis resulted in two most parsimonious trees (MPTs) of 592 steps, the strict consensus of which (Fig. 4) supports FRDC-05-CM-021 as a member of Ornithuromorpha. Within this clade, Patagopteryx deferrariisi and Archaeorhynchus are recovered as successive outgroups to a large polytomy formed by Hongshanornis longicresta, Gansus yumenensis, Apsaravis ukhaana, FRDC-05-CM-021, a Yixianornis grabaui + (Songlingornis + Yanornis martini) clade, and Ornithurae (Hesperornis regalis + [Ichthyornis dispar + Neornithes]). The Yixianornis + (Songlingornis + Yanornis) clade differs in structure from previous analyses (Clarke et al. 2006) in that Yanornis and Songlingornis share a more exclusive relationship with each other than either does with Yixianornis; this pairing is supported by three synapomorphies (char. 62: 1→2; char. 109: 1→0; char. 111: 1→2). In the analysis of Clarke et al. (2006), Songlingornis was recovered as more closely related to Yixianornis than to Yanornis.

    The two MPTs differ only in the placements of FRDC-05CM-021, Apsaravis, and Gansus (see Supplementary Online Material 1). In both trees, Hongshanornis is basal to these taxa and the Yixianornis + (Songlingornis + Yanornis) clade. In one tree, Apsaravis and FRDC-05-CM-021 form a polytomy with Ornithurae, with Gansus as the outgroup. This large clade forms a dichotomy with the Yixianornis + (Songlingornis + Yanornis) clade, to which Hongshanornis is the outgroup. In the second tree, Apsaravis and Gansus form successive outgroups to Ornithurae. This clade forms a dichotomy with the Yixianornis + (Songlingornis + Yanornis) clade. Specimen FRDC-05-CM-021 and Hongshanornis together constitute a clade that falls outside this large dichotomy.

    The largely incomplete nature of FRDC-05-CM-021 makes it difficult to resolve its phylogenetic position relative to other taxa, and support for the consensus tree is weak (see Supplementary Online Material). However, the placement of the new specimen within Ornithuromorpha, as suggested by the morphology of its furcula, is confirmed. Gansus is recovered as earlier diverging than in the analysis of You et al. (2006), where this taxon was hypothesized as a member of Ornithurae. The revised position of Gansus proposed here may reflect our incorporation of previously unavailable morphological information gleaned from newly prepared specimens of this genus, the inclusion of a greater diversity of basal ornithuromorph taxa in our analysis, or both.


    The recent surge in discovery of Early Cretaceous ornithothoracine fossils has resulted in an improved understanding of basal ornithuromorph sternal anatomy, since most recently-described specimens preserve this element (e.g., the holotypes of Archaeorhynchus spathula, Hongshanornis longicresta, Jianchangornis microdonta, Longicrusavis houi, Songlingornis linghensis, Yanornis martini, Yixianornis grabaui, and new specimens of Gansus yumenensis). As presently understood, the morphology of archaic ornithuromorph sterna is fairly conservative, with several taxa (Gansus, Songlingornis, Yanornis, Yixianornis) exhibiting caudal fenestrae and craniocaudally abbreviate lateral trabeculae. The sternum of FRDC-05-CM-021 represents one of the most distinctive departures from this morphology yet observed within basal Ornithuromorpha.

    The revised phylogenetic position of the Early Cretaceous Chinese bird Liaoningornis longidigitris proposed here (Fig. 4) is a striking reflection of our increased knowledge of early ornithothoracine sternal morphology and diversity. At the time that the only known, incomplete Liaoningornis specimen was described (Hou 1997b), with the sternum as its best-preserved and only truly diagnostic element, just a few definitive Early Cretaceous ornithuromorph fossils had been discovered (e.g., the holotypes of Ambiortus dementjevi [Kurochkin 1982], Chaoyangia beishanensis [Hou and Zhang 1993], and Gansus [Hou and Liu 1984]), none of which included well-preserved sternal material, thus rendering meaningful morphological comparisons difficult. Liaoningornis was placed within Ornithurae (Hou 1997b), though the distribution of the character states used to support this assignment (e.g., the presence of a sternal carina) is now known to extend beyond this clade.

    If the position of Liaoningornis within Ornithurae, or even the more inclusive group Ornithuromorpha, were to be strongly supported, then the morphology of this genus would represent a significant divergence from that of other ornithuromorphs. Instead, the skeleton of Liaoningornis closely resembles that of the bizarre Spanish Early Cretaceous enantiornithine Eoalulavis hoyasi (Sanz et al. 1996) while simultaneously lacking clear ornithuromorph morphologies such as the presence of two cnemial crests or a well developed intercotylar eminence on the proximal tarsometatarsus. In our analysis (Fig. 4), Eoalulavis and Liaoningornis form a clade within Enantiornithes, supported by a single character state (char. 117: 2→3) that reflects the similar morphology of the caudal half of the sternum in both genera. This position of Liaoningornis within Enantiornithes differs from those retrieved by previous studies, which also vary widely in the placement of this taxon. One analysis resolved Liaoningornis as a basal ornithuromorph (Zhou and Zhang 2006b), consistent with the original description of the taxon, while another postulated this genus as outside of Pygostylia (You et al. 2006). Nevertheless, the position recovered by the present study is currently the most strongly supported by empirical morphological comparisons with other birds. As demonstrated by Liaoningornis, when combined with detailed analyses of existing specimens, the discovery of additional Cretaceous ornithothoracine fossils such as FRDC-05-CM-021 can significantly affect systematic assessments of previously-described taxa.

    The phylogenetic positions of FRDC-05-CM-021 and Gansus emphasize the importance of the Xiagou Formation avifauna for deciphering the early evolution and diversification of Ornithuromorpha, and, ultimately, of the extant avian clade Neornithes. In the Jehol Group, representatives of Enantiornithes are both numerically and taxonomically dominant over their ornithuromorph counterparts. In contrast, ornithuromorph fossils from the Xiagou Formation greatly outnumber those of enantiornithines, suggesting that, in the Xiagou paleoecosystem, representatives of the former clade were more common than those of the latter. Until the discovery of FRDC-05-CM-021, however, it appeared that the taxonomic diversity of Xiagou enantiornithines was higher than that of sympatric ornithuromorphs, with probably two enantiornithine taxa (Lamanna et al. 2006b: 430; unpublished data) to only one ornithuromorph (Gansus) recorded. Because it pertains to a second Xiagou ornithuromorph taxon, the specimen described here tentatively suggests that enantiornithines and ornithuromorphs were of comparable diversity in the paleoecosystem of this unit. This, in turn, constitutes further evidence that this unit may record the initial stages of the eventual rise of ornithuromorphs to taxonomic and numerical dominance over enantiornithines (You et al. 2006).

    Discoveries of additional specimens referable to the ornithuromorph taxon presently represented solely by FRDC-05-CM-021 would provide additional phylogenetic and ecomorphological information regarding the early evolution and diversification of Ornithuromorpha, and potentially the origins of Ornithurae. For instance, an important aspect of the paleobiology of Gansus is its presumed aquatic or semiaquatic lifestyle, which has been inferred from its prominent, proximally-projecting cnemial crest on the tibiotarsus, proximal position of the metatarsal II trochlea, and elongate, webbed pedal digits (You et al. 2006; Hinic-Frlog 2007). Coupled with the phylogenetic position of Gansus as an advanced non-ornithurine ornithuromorph or basal ornithurine, this was considered to support the hypothesis that Cretaceous ornithuromorphs may have been largely aquatic in habits, and that neornithines may have originated in water-based niches (You et al. 2006). Whether or not the taxon represented by FRDC-05-CM-021 possessed similar aquatic adaptations can only be determined by the discovery of more complete specimens, because no sternal or furcular characters have yet been determined to be indicative of an aquatic ecology. It is interesting to note, however, that sterna with short bodies and long trabeculae bordering deep incisures (closed in vivo by fibrous membranes) convergently occur in terrestrial, largely cursorial galliforms. Furthermore, a similar sternal morphology is also observed in the Mongolian Late Cretaceous enantiornithine Elsornis keni (Chiappe et al. 2006), a taxon hypothesized (based on its pectoral limb proportions) to have been terrestrial, and possibly flightless. This does not imply that such sternal morphology is present in all terrestrial birds (many other landbirds—excepting ratites—have more typical sternal morphologies), though the association of this morphology with reduced flight capabilities is noteworthy.

    Fig. 4.

    Hypothesized phylogenetic position of Ornithuromorpha gen. et sp. indet. (FRDC-05-CM-021 [indicated by sternum]) from the Early Cretaceous of the Changma Basin, northwestern Gansu Province, China. Strict consensus of two most parsimonious trees of 592 steps (CI = 47; RCI = 47; RI = 67) recovered by cladistic analysis. FRDC-07-CM-001, FRDC-06-CM-012, and FRDC-05-CM-004 are as-yet undescribed enantiornithine fossils in the FRDC collection.



    The authors contributed to the manuscript in the following ways: H-LY oversaw the preparation and curation of FRDC-05-CM-021, provided the remaining authors with access to the specimen and laboratory facilities, and edited the manuscript; JA led the anatomical study of the specimen, wrote the majority of the initial manuscript draft, and composed Figs. 2, 3, and Table 1; JKO conducted the phylogenetic analysis, wrote the corresponding text, Supplementary Online Material, and drafted Fig. 4; JDH extensively contributed to analysis of the specimen, edited the manuscript, provided the measurements of FRDC-05-CM-021 and CAGS-IG-04-CM-003 included in Table 1, and took the photograph for Fig. 2; MCL also extensively edited the manuscript, contributed to specimen analysis, and drafted the figure included in the Supplementary Online Material; and D-QL supervised the field effort in the Changma Basin that resulted in the discovery of the specimen. We thank the personnel of the Fossil Research and Development Center, Third Geology and Mineral Resources Exploration Academy, Gansu Provincial Bureau of Geo-Exploration and Mineral Development (Lanzhou, China) for discovering the specimen, and Yu-Qing Zhang (Institute of Geology of the Chinese Academy of Geological Sciences, Beijing, China) for preparation. This paper benefitted from technical reviews by Luis Chiappe (Dinosaur Institute of the Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County, Los Angeles, USA) and Gareth Dyke (University College Dublin, Dublin, Ireland). Funding was provided by grants from the Ministry of Science and Technology and the National Natural Science Foundation of China (40672007) to H-LY and Shu-An Ji, the Gansu Provincial Bureau of Geo-Exploration and Mineral Development to D-QL, Sinofossa Institute to MCL and JDH, the University of Pennsylvania Paleobiology Research Fund to JA, and The Dinosaur Institute of the Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County to JKO.



    J.J. Baumel and L.M. Witmer 1993. Osteologia. In : J.J. Baumel , A.S. King , J.E. Breazile , H.E. Evans , and J.E. Vanden Berge (eds.), Handbook of Avian Anatomy: Nomina Anatomica Avium , 45–132. Nuttall Ornithological Club, Cambridge. Google Scholar


    Bureau of Geology and Mineral Resources of Gansu Province. 1989. Regional Geology of Gansu Province [in Chinese with English summary], 692 pp. Geological Publishing House, Beijing. Google Scholar


    Bureau of Geology and Mineral Resources of Gansu Province. 1997. Stratigraphy (Lithostratigraphic) of Gansu Province [in Chinese]. 314 pp. China University of Geosciences Press, Shanghai. Google Scholar


    M.-M. Chang , P.-J. Chen , Y.-Q. Wang , and Y. Yang 2003. The Jehol Biota. 209 pp. Shanghai Scientific and Technical Publishers, Shanghai. Google Scholar


    L.M. Chiappe 1996. Late Cretaceous birds of southern South America: anatomy and systematics of Enantiornithes and Patagopteryx deferrariisi. Münchner Geowissenschaftliche Abhandlungen 30: 203–244. Google Scholar


    L.M. Chiappe 2002. Basal bird phylogeny: problems and solutions. In : L.M. Chiappe and L.M. Witmer (eds.), Mesozoic Birds: Above the Heads of Dinosaurs , 448–472. University of California Press, Berkeley. Google Scholar


    L.M. Chiappe and G.J. Dyke 2002. The Mesozoic radiation of birds. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 33: 91–124.  Google Scholar


    L.M. Chiappe and G.J. Dyke 2006. The early evolutionary history of birds. Journal of the Paleontological Society of Korea 22: 133–151. Google Scholar


    L.M. Chiappe , S. Suzuki , G.J. Dyke , M. Watabe , K. Tsogtbaatar , and R. Barsbold 2006. A new enantiornithine bird from the Late Cretaceous of the Gobi Desert. Journal of Systematic Palaeontology 5: 193–208.  Google Scholar


    J.A. Clarke 2004. Morphology, phylogenetic taxonomy, and systematics of Ichthyornis and Apatornis (Avialae: Ornithurae). Bulletin of the American Museum of Natural History 286: 1–179.;2  Google Scholar


    J.A. Clarke and M.A. Norell 2002. The morphology and phylogenetic position of Apsaravis ukhaana from the Late Cretaceous of Mongolia. American Museum Novitates 3387: 1–46.;2  Google Scholar


    J.A. Clarke , Z.-H. Zhou , and F.-C. Zhang 2006. Insight into the evolution of avian flight from a new clade of Early Cretaceous ornithurines from China and the morphology of Yixianornis grabaui. Journal of Anatomy 208: 287–308.  Google Scholar


    Editorial Committee of Chinese Stratigraphic Standard: Cretaceous. 2000. Chinese Stratigraphic Standard: Cretaceous [in Chinese]. 124 pp. Geological Publishing House, Beijing. Google Scholar


    P. Goloboff 1993. NONA: A Tree Searching Program. Program and documentation distributed by P. Goloboff, San Miguel de Tucumán, Argentina. Google Scholar


    E.-P. Gong , L.-H. Hou , and L.-X. Wang 2004. Enantiornithine bird with diapsidian skull and its dental development in the Early Cretaceous in Liaoning, China. Acta Geologica Sinica (English Edition) 78: 1–7. Google Scholar


    J.D. Harris , M.C. Lamanna , H.-L. You , S.-A. Ji , and Q. Ji 2006a. A second enantiornithean (Aves: Ornithothoraces) wing from the Early Cretaceous Xiagou Formation near Changma, Gansu Province, People's Republic of China. Canadian Journal of Earth Sciences 43: 547–554.  Google Scholar


    J.D. Harris , H.-L. You , Q. Ji , and M.C. Lamanna 2006b. New specimens of the ornithuran bird Gansus yumenensis from the Xiagou Formation (Lower Cretaceous) of Gansu Province, China. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 26 (Supplement to No. 3): 72A. Google Scholar


    S. Hinic-Frlog 2007. Aquatic locomotion in basal Ornithurae and their transition from aquatic to terrestrial habitats. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 27 (Supplement to No. 3): 89A. Google Scholar


    L.-H. Hou 1997a. Mesozoic Birds of China [in Chinese with English summary]. 221 pp. Feng-huang-ku, Taiwan. Google Scholar


    L.-H. Hou 1997b. A carinate bird from the Upper Jurassic of western Liaoning, China. Chinese Science Bulletin 42: 413–417.  Google Scholar


    L.-H. Hou and Z. Liu 1984. A new fossil bird from Lower Cretaceous of Gansu and early evolution of birds. Scientia Sinica (Series B) 27: 1296–1302. Google Scholar


    L. Hou and J. Zhang 1993. A new fossil bird from Lower Cretaceous of Liaoning [in Chinese with English summary]. Vertebrata PalAsiatica 31: 217–224. Google Scholar


    J. Huang , D. Ren , N.D. Sinitshenkova , and C. Shih 2007. New genus and species of Hexagenitidae (Insecta: Ephemeroptera) from Yixian Formation, China. Zootaxa 1629: 39–50. Google Scholar


    E.N. Kurochkin 1982. New order of birds from the Lower Cretaceous in Mongolia. Paleontological Journal 1982: 214–218. Google Scholar


    M.C. Lamanna , D.-Q. Li , H.-L. You , Q. Ji , and J.D. Harris 2006a. An emerging fossil biota from the Early Cretaceous of northwestern China. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 26 (Supplement to No. 3): 88A. Google Scholar


    M.C. Lamanna , H.-L. You , J.D. Harris , L.M. Chiappe , S.-A. Ji , J.-C. Lü , and Q. Ji 2006b. A partial skeleton of an enantiornithine bird from the Early Cretaceous of northwestern China. Acta Palaeontologica Polonica 51: 423–434. Google Scholar


    M.C. Lamanna , D.-Q. Li , J.D. Harris , J. Atterholt , and H.-L. You 2009. Exceptionally-preserved Enantiornithes (Aves: Ornithothoraces) from the Early Cretaceous of northwestern China. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 29 (Supplement to No. 3): 131A. Google Scholar


    H.-B. Li and J.-S. Yang 2004. Evidence for Cretaceous uplift of the northern Qinghai-Tibetan plateau [in Chinese with English summary]. Earth Science Frontiers 11: 345–359. Google Scholar


    C. Linnaeus 1758. Systema naturae per regna tria naturae, secundum classes, ordines, genera, species, cum characteribus, differentiis, synonymis, loci. Vol. 1: Regnum animale. Editio decima, reformata. 824 pp. Laurentii Salvii, Stockholm. Google Scholar


    F. Ma 1993. Late Mesozoic Fossil Fishes from the Jiuquan Basin of Gansu Province, China [in Chinese with English summary]. 118 pp. Ocean Press, Beijing. Google Scholar


    O.C. Marsh 1880. Odontornithes: a monograph on the extinct toothed birds of North America. Professional Papers of the Engineer Department, US Army 18: 1–201. Google Scholar


    A.M. Murray , H.-L. You , and C. Peng 2010. A new Cretaceous osteoglossomorph fish from Gansu Province, China. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 30: 322–332.  Google Scholar


    M.A. Norell and J.A. Clarke 2001. Fossil that fills a critical gap in avian evolution. Nature 409: 181–184.  Google Scholar


    J.K. O'Connor , X.-R. Wang , L.M. Chiappe , C.-L. Gao , Q.-J. Meng , X.-D. Cheng , and J.-Y. Liu 2009. Phylogenetic support for a specialized clade of Cretaceous enantiornithine birds with information from a new species. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 29: 188–204.  Google Scholar


    J.K. O'Connor , L.M. Chiappe , and K.-Q. Gao 2010. A new ornithuromorph (Aves: Ornithothoraces) bird from the Jehol Group indicative of higherlevel diversity. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 30: 311–321. Scholar


    J.G. Ogg , G. Ogg , and F.M. Gradstein 2008. The Concise Geologic Time Scale. 184 pp. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Google Scholar


    J.L. Sanz , L.M. Chiappe , B.P. Pérez-Moreno , A.D. Buscalioni , J.J. Moratalla , F. Ortega , and F.J. Poyato-Ariza 1996. An Early Cretaceous bird from Spain and its implications for the evolution of avian flight. Nature 382: 442–445.  Google Scholar


    J.L. Sanz , B.P. Pérez-Moreno , L.M. Chiappe , and A.D. Buscalioni 2002. The birds from the Lower Cretaceous of Las Hoyas (Province of Cuenca, Spain). In : L.M. Chiappe and L.M. Witmer (eds.), Mesozoic Birds: Above the Heads of Dinosaurs , 209–229. University of California Press, Berkeley. Google Scholar


    P.C. Sereno and C. Rao 1992. Early evolution of avian flight and perching: new evidence from the Lower Cretaceous of China. Science 255: 845–848.  Google Scholar


    P.C. Sereno , C. Rao , and J. Li 2002. Sinornis santensis (Aves: Enantiornithes) from the Early Cretaceous of northeastern China. In : L.M. Chiappe and L.M. Witmer (eds.), Mesozoic Birds: Above the Heads of Dinosaurs , 184–208. University of California Press, Berkeley. Google Scholar


    M. Suarez , L. Gonzalez , G. Ludvigson , and H.-L. You 2008. Stable carbon isotope chemostratigraphy of the fossil bird-bearing Early Cretaceous Xiagou Formation in Changma Basin, Gansu Province, China. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 28 (Supplement to No. 3): 149A. Google Scholar


    F. Tang , Z.-X. Luo , Z.-H. Zhou , H.-L. You , J.A. Georgi , Z.-L. Tang , and X.-Z. Wang 2001. Biostratigraphy and palaeoenvironment of the dinosaur-bearing sediments in Lower Cretaceous of Mazongshan area, Gansu Province, China. Cretaceous Research 22: 115–129.  Google Scholar


    H.-L. You , J. O'Connor , L.M. Chiappe , and Q. Ji 2005. A new fossil bird from the Early Cretaceous of Gansu Province, northwestern China. Mstorical Biology 17:7–14.  Google Scholar


    H.-L. You , M.C. Lamanna , J.D. Harris , L.M. Chiappe , J. O'Connor , S.-A. Ji , J.-C. Lü , C.-X. Yuan , D.-Q. Li , X. Zhang , K.J. Lacovara , P. Dodson , and Q. Ji 2006. A nearly modern amphibious bird from the Early Cretaceous of northwestern China. Science 312: 1640–1643.  Google Scholar


    F.-C. Zhang , Z.-H. Zhou , L.-H Hou , and G. Gu 2001. Early diversification of birds: evidence from a new opposite bird. Chinese Science Bulletin 46: 945–949.  Google Scholar


    F.-C. Zhang , P.G.P. Ericson , and Z.-H. Zhou 2004. Description of a new enantiornithine bird from the Early Cretaceous of Hebei, northern China. Canadian Journal of Earth Sciences 41: 1097–1107.  Google Scholar


    Z.-H. Zhou and F.-C. Zhang 2001. Two new ornithurine birds from the Early Cretaceous of western Liaoning, China. Chinese Science Bulletin 46: 1–7.  Google Scholar


    Z.-H. Zhou and L.-H. Hou 2002. The discovery and study of Mesozoic birds in China. In : L.M. Chiappe and L.M. Witmer (eds.), Mesozoic Birds: Above the Heads of Dinosaurs , 160–183. University of California Press, Berkeley. Google Scholar


    Z.-H. Zhou and F.-C. Zhang 2005. Discovery of an ornithurine bird and its implication for Early Cretaceous avian radiation. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 102: 18998–19002.  Google Scholar


    Z.-H. Zhou and F.-C. Zhang 2006a. Mesozoic birds of China—a synoptic review. Vertebrata PalAsiatica 44: 74–98. Google Scholar


    Z.-H. Zhou and F.-C. Zhang 2006b. A beaked basal ornithurine bird (Aves, Ornithurae) from the Lower Cretaceous of China. Zoologica Scripta 35: 363–373.  Google Scholar


    Z.-H. Zhou , J.A. Clarke , and F.-C. Zhang 2002. Archaeoraptor's better half: the other component of this infamous fossil forgery is identified as a fish-eating bird. Nature 420: 285.  Google Scholar


    Z.-H. Zhou , J. Clarke , F.-C. Zhang , and O. Wings 2004. Gastroliths in Yanornis: an indication of the earliest radical diet-switching and gizzard plasticity in the lineage leading to living birds. Naturwissenschaften 91: 571–574.  Google Scholar


    Z.-H. Zhou , F.-C. Zhang , and Z.-H. Li 2009. A new basal ornithurine bird (Jianchangornis microdonta gen. et sp. nov.) from the Lower Cretaceous of China. Vertebrata PalAsiatica 47: 299–310. Google Scholar
    Hai-Lu You, Jessie Atterholt, Jingmai K. O'Connor, Jerald D. Harris, Matthew C. Lamanna, and Da-Qing Li "A Second Cretaceous Ornithuromorph Bird from the Changma Basin, Gansu Province, Northwestern China," Acta Palaeontologica Polonica 55(4), 617-625, (1 December 2010).
    Received: 27 September 2009; Accepted: 12 May 2010; Published: 1 December 2010
    9 PAGES

    Back to Top