Translator Disclaimer
24 April 2013 Terrestrial Mollusc Species Richness and Diversity in Omo Forest Reserve, Ogun State, Nigeria
Author Affiliations +
Abstract

The terrestrial mollusc species richness and diversity in Omo Forest Reserve, Ogun State, Nigeria, was studied using a combination of direct search and leaf-litter sieving techniques. In total, 28 species and 639 individuals in 7 molluscan families were collected from 17 plots of 400 m2 each. Species richness varied from 3 to 14 (mean 8.59) and the number of individuals from 8 to 67 (mean 37.59) per plot. Species richness was dominated by the carnivorous Streptaxidae (36%) and herbivorous Subulinidae (32%), and numerical abundance by the Subulinidae (56%) and Streptaxidae (32%). The most abundant species was the large subulinid, Subulona pattalus, contributing almost 25% of the total number of individuals. Terrestrial molluscs with small populations and narrow distributional ranges are at great risk of local extinction if forest destruction continues unabated. Studies on the molluscan diversity in Omo Forest Reserve will assist in producing an inventory for biodiversity conservation management in Nigeria.

INTRODUCTION

Knowledge of the biodiversity in different ecosystems in tropical rainforest is urgently needed, given the high rate of deforestation and species loss as a result of anthropogenic activities. In most African forests, the fauna (especially invertebrates) is poorly studied and many species are yet to be described (Lydeard et al. 2004). Hence, the destruction of a small patch of rainforest will invariably lead to the extinction of many unidentified species. Omo Forest Reserve is one of such reserves seriously threatened by conversion to plantations of arable and cash crops (Persson & Warner 2003; Ojo 2004), with serious consequences for the biodiversity.

Omo Forest Reserve is one of six large contiguous forest reserves in Ogun State, south-western Nigeria, established to protect the biodiversity of the region (Persson & Warner 2003). The reserve is one of the few remaining habitats with old-growth tropical rainforest in Ogun State and is severely threatened by logging, poaching and plantation agriculture. Plantations of the exotic gmelina trees (Gmelina arborea) were begun over 40 years ago, with a view to supplying pulpwood to the nearby paper mill (Lowe 1993). Previous studies on biodiversity of the reserve focused on large vertebrates (Johansen 1994; Persson & Warner 2003), and little is known about the numerous invertebrates that constitute the majority of the fauna.

Presently, the reserve is in a poor state, lacking government funding, basic infrastructure, and facilities to protect the fauna and flora. Although Omo Forest Reserve has a moderately rich biodiversity, we do not know how long the forest will remain intact, because of the high demand for arable land and wood (Ojo 2004).

Molluscs are good indicators of environmental history and conditions because of their low mobility, long evolutionary history and calcareous shells that have a good preservation potential. The highest number of recorded extinctions in modern times have been amongst molluscs (Strayer et al. 1986; Lydeard et al. 2004; Régnier et al. 2009) and many more species are threatened. Molluscs are easy to sample and their calcareous shells remain relatively intact for some time before disintegrating. Land snail shells serve as a calcium source for various organisms that feed on them, especially for eggshell formation, muscle contraction, and osmoregulation (Graveland & van der Wal 1996; Hottop 2002). In the forest ecosystem, land snails are preyed upon by a number of organisms including insects (beetles), amphibians, reptiles, birds and mammals. Hence, loss of land snail species as a result of deforestation has more far-reaching consequences on other organisms than can be imagined.

In continuation of my biodiversity studies on the land mollusc faunas in Nigeria, I collected samples from the old-growth rainforest reserve in Omo, Ogun State, southwestern Nigeria. Previous studies on land molluscs in the region include the description of a new species, Ptychotrema shagamuense (Oke & Odiete 1996), and research carried out in Erin Ijesha (Oke 2007), Okomu Forest Reserve (Oke & Alohan 2006), Ekpoma (Oke et al. 2007b), Egbeta (Oke et al. 2008), and Idanre hills (Oke & Chokor 2010). In this paper, I report on the species richness and diversity of land molluscs collected from Omo Forest Reserve, Ogun State, Nigeria.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Study area

Omo Forest Reserve is located in Ijebu Province of Ogun State, south-western Nigeria (6°35′–7°05′N 4°19′-4°40′E; Fig. 1). The reserve was established in 1925 and covers about 130,500 ha. The terrain is undulating with occasional rocky outcrops and inselbergs and with a maximum elevation of 300 m above sea level. Geologically, the reserve lies on crystalline rocks of undifferentiated basement complex, which in the southern parts is overlain by Eocene deposits of sand, clay and gravel (Onyekwelu 2005). The reserve is drained by River Omo that flows south, where it joins River Oni before flowing into the Lekki Lagoon, then into the Atlantic Ocean. The climate is tropical, with two distinct seasons: rainy (March—October) and dry (February—October). Mean annual rainfall ranges from 1600–2000 mm (Allison 1955; Ojo 2004). The vegetation is characterised by a mixture of dry and moist evergreen rainforest (Lowe 1993).

Fig. 1.

The location of Omo Forest Reserve in Ogun State, Nigeria. Site I includes plots (1–12) sampled in 2009 and site II plots (13–17) sampled in 2010.

f01_93.jpg

Sample collection

Land mollusc samples were collected during the rainy season in June 2009 and 2010 using a combination of direct search and litter-sieving techniques (e.g. Tattersfield 1996). Direct searching involved examination in a plot of 20×20 m of all potential molluscan microhabitats that could be accessed, such as fallen tree trunks, deep litter beds, rock faces, etc.

Seventeen plots were sampled, 12 in 2009 (site I; Fig. 1) and five in 2010 (site II). The plots (1–12) in site I were located in a portion of the reserve that is regenerating after selective logging activities about 40 years ago, while those in site II (13–17) were situated near a cocoa plantation within the reserve. Each plot was approximately 50 m apart from the next one, placed alternately from the previous one. At each plot, we searched intensively for molluscs for two person-hours (i.e. two searchers active for one hour). In addition, we collected an average of 50 litres of litter and topsoil from 10 randomly selected 1×1 m sites within each plot. Litter samples and top soil were exhaustively searched in the laboratory for land molluscs. All live slugs and snails, and all empty shells were collected. Live specimens were drowned and preserved in 70% ethanol.

Data analysis

The diversity was measured as overall species richness (S) and Whittaker's index (T), which is the total number of species recorded (S) divided by the mean number of species per site (α), providing a measure of diversity difference between sites (Schilthuizen & Rutjes 2001). The true diversity was estimated by performing 100 randomisations on the data and calculating S using the Chao 2 and second-order jackknife richness estimators in the program Estimates 7.5 (Colwell 2006). We used sample-based rarefaction curves to produce a smooth curve that estimates the number of species that would be observed for any smaller number of samples, assuming random mixing of sample order (Colwell & Coddington 1994; Gotelli & Colwell 2001). We defined sample intensity as the ratio of individuals to species and inventory completeness as the percentage of observed number of species over the expected number of species as estimated by Chao2 or Jack2 (Coddington et al. 1996; Soberón et al. 2007). Statistical analyses were performed using the PAST software (Hammer et al. 2001). Hierarchical clustering (Bray-Curtis similarity measure) was used to identify natural groupings among the sampled points according to similarities in their species composition. Cluster analysis is the arrangement of samples into groups (cluster), so that samples within the same cluster are more similar to each other than to samples from different clusters (Gauch & Whittaker, 1981). The non-parametric one-way Analysis of Similarity (ANOSIM; Clarke 1993) was used to test for statistical differences in species composition between clusters. Similarity Percentage (SIMPER; Clarke 1993) analysis, using the Bray-Curtis similarity measure, was used to assess which taxa are responsible for an observed difference between groups of samples.

RESULTS

In total, 639 individuals belonging to 28 species in 18 genera and 7 families of pulmonate molluscs were collected (Figs 326). Each plot yielded between 8 and 67 individuals (mean 37.57, standard deviation 19.33) and between 3 and 14 species (mean 8.59, standard deviation 3.36). The species collected from all the sample plots are listed in Table 1. Two families are most species-rich and abundant: Streptaxidae, represented by 10 (36%) species and 202 (32%) individuals, and Subulinidae with 9 (32%) species and 361 (56%) individuals.

A few species were very abundant, few very rare, while most were intermediate in abundance (Fig. 2). Five species occurred with more than 50 individuals, 15 species occurred with fewer than 10 individuals, two as doubletons, and two as singletons. The most abundant species contributed about 69% of the total number of individuals: Subulona pattalus (Pilsbry) (25.20%), Ptychotrema shagamuense Oke & Odiete (12.21%), Striosubulina striatella (Rang) (12.05%), Subulona involuta (Gould) (10.02%), and Gonaxis camerunensis (d'Ailly) (9.39%).

The rarefaction curves (Fig. 27) almost reached an asymptote when sampling stopped and the number of species recorded was not different from that obtained by the nonparametric estimators. Estimated species richness based on Chao 2 and Jack 2 gave values of 28.35 and 27.68 species respectively. ‘Sample intensity’ (ratio of individuals to species) was 22.82:1, while inventory completeness was 98.77% using Chao2 estimator. Whittaker's index was 3.26, indicating high differentiation among plots.

Although inventory completeness was 90% and 98% for site I and site II, respectively, using Chao2 estimator, comparatively more species were collected from site I (25 species) than site II (18 species), and there was a significant difference in species composition between the two sites. Moreover, the dendrogram of similarity dividedthe plots into two distinct groups at 50% similarity (Fig. 28). Plots (1–4, 6–8) in site I formed one cluster, and plots (13–17) in site II formed the second group. Analysis of Similarity, using the Bray-Curtis similarity index, revealed significant differences in species composition between the two clusters (R=0.99, p=0.0009), indicating that the sites were well separated. SIMPER analysis revealed that the taxa primarily responsible for the observed difference between the two groups include S. pattalus (24.72%), G. camerunensis (16.62%), P. shagamuense (12.05%), S. involuta (10.37%), and S. striatella (9.85%).

Fig. 2.

Rank abundance curve for terrestrial snails from Omo Forest Reserve in Ogun State, Nigeria.

f02_93.jpg

Figs 3–12.

(3) Achatinidae, Lignus sp., H 46 mm; (4–12) Subulinidae: (4) Subulona pattalus, H 36 mm; (5)Striosubulina striatella, H 21.1 mm; (6) Subulona involuta, H 24 mm; (7) Kempiochoncha stuhlmanni, H 11 mm; (8) Pseudopeas curvelliforme, H 10.2 mm; (9) Curvella feai, H 4.8 mm; (10) Curvella ovata, H 5.6 mm; (11) Curvella sp. juvenile, H 5.52 mm; (12)Pseudopeas cf. ukaguruense, H 5.52mm. Scale bars = 10 mm (Figs 3–8) and 1 mm (Figs 9–12).

f03_93.jpg

Figs 13–22.

Streptaxidae: (13) Gonaxis camerunensis, H 9 mm; (14) Ptychotrema okei, H 9.9 mm; (15) Ptychotrema sp., H 9.8 mm; (16) Ptychotrema shagamuense, H 15.8 mm; (17) Gulella monodon, H 6.48 mm; (18) Gulella reesi, H 5.92 mm; (19) Gulella io, H 3.64 mm; (20) Gulella jongkindi, H 4.08 mm; (21) Gulella cf. opoboensis, H 3.24 mm; (22) Tomostele musaecola, H 3.84 mm. Scale bars = 5 mm (Figs 13–16) and 1 mm (Figs 17–22).

f13_93.jpg

Figs23–26. (23–25)

Urocyclidae: (23) Thapsia oscitans, H 8.8 mm; (24) Trochozonites talcosus, H 8.3mm; (25) Trochozonites adansoniae, H 6.3 mm; (26) Aillyidae, Aillya camerunensis, H 4.4 mm. Scale bars = 5 mm (Figs 23–25) and 1 mm (Fig 26).

f23_93.jpg

Fig. 27.

Sample-based species accumulation curves for terrestrial molluscs in Omo Forest Reserve, Ogun State, Nigeria. Plotted values are means based on 100 randomisations of sample accumulation order (without replacement). Solid line, species observed; dashed lines, 95% confidence limit.

f27_93.jpg

Fig. 28.

Dendrogram of Bray-Curtis similarity between plots in sites I and II.

f28_93.jpg

DISCUSSION

The sampling protocol was adequate in capturing most of the species recorded in sites within the study area in that the number of species recorded was similar to that obtained using the Chao 2 and Jackknife 2 non-parametric richness estimators (Colwell & Coddington 1994). However, when the two sites sampled were compared using ANOSIM, the faunal composition between the two sites was clearly different (R=0.99, p=0.0009). This means that other parts of the forest may be inhabited by an entirely different set of species and more species could still be found, despite the high inventory completeness recorded. Therefore, in order to get a complete inventory of the entire reserve, more samples may have to be collected. This is also borne out by the fact that some species commonly found in south-western Nigeria were missed by our sampling methods or may be locally extinct in the area sampled. For example, Archachatina papyracea, Rachistia sp. and Quickia sp. were not encountered during the collection in Omo Forest Reserve before (Oke & Chokor 2010) or during the present study.

Comparatively, the number of species recorded in Omo was higher than those recorded from agricultural plantations and some secondary forests within the region (Oke & Ugiagbe 2007; Oke et al. 2008), but lower than those obtained from lowland rainforest reserves and hills in Nigeria and other parts of western Africa (de Winter & Gittenberger 1998; Oke & Alohan 2006; Oke et al. 2007a ; Fontaine et al. 2007; Oke 2007). Nevertheless, Omo Forest Reserve is moderately rich in mollusc species, especially the streptaxids and subulinids, given the high heterogeneity between plots (Whittaker's Index, 3.26) and between sites. Each site within the reserve has its own unique set of fauna and species richness. Considering the high heterogeneity between plots and between sites, destruction of a small patch of the remaining rainforest within the reserve may lead to the loss of some species.

Interestingly, the abundance of Subulona pattalus is unique for the region. This species is the largest subulinid snail recorded in Nigeria (shell length >40 mm) and has been uncommonly found previously in low numbers within the rainforest zone extending from Shagamu to Benin City (Oke & Alohan 2006; Oke 2007; Oke et al. 2007b , 2008; Oke & Chokor 2010; Chokor & Oke 2011). In a similar study carried out in Gabon, Fontaine et al. (2007) also found a subulinid to be the most abundant species. Hence, it will be of great value to monitor the population of this species in order to evaluate its conservation status.

The threats to biological diversity fall into several categories, including habitat loss and degradation, over-exploitation of natural resources, climate change, pollution, the spread of invasive species, and lack of effective policies (Pullin 2002). The land mollusc fauna of Omo Forest Reserve face a number of threats, including clearing the few remaining lowland forests for agricultural purposes or for timber. Timber harvesting not only degrades the habitats directly but also involves the construction of pathways and roads which further degrades other components of the ecosystem. Land molluscs with small populations and narrow ranges are at great risk of local extinction if the forest is destroyed. For example, the giant African land snail, Archchatina marginata, a delicacy and source of protein for the humans in the region, used to be very abundant in the past but is now becoming rare in many parts of southern Nigeria as a result of habitat destruction and degradation (Segun 1975; Ajayi et al. 1978; Oke & Odiete 2007).

In conclusion, the collecting effort put in has ensured that the survey was effective in obtaining a first inventory of terrestrial molluscs in Omo Forest Reserve. Furthermore, it has provided basic data on heterogeneity and the abundance or rarity of species, and has revealed the presence of potentially undescribed molluscs. This knowledge will help reserve managers to monitor the populations of various mollusc species that may be threatened in the future and also assist conservation planners to know the importance of incorporating invertebrates in reserve selection and management. Further studies on invertebrates will enable determination of the extent to which species and secondary production are lost as a result of forest destruction or degradation.

TABLE 1

List of terrestrial molluscs recorded in Omo Forest Reserve, with number of specimens collected. Families, genera and species appear alphabetically.

t01a_93.gif

TABLE 1continued

t01b_93.gif

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

I wish to thank Dr Igor Muratov for identifying some specimens and taking the photographs of the shells and also for his comments and patience in reviewing this paper. I thank Dr Ben Rowson for his comments and contributions. I also thank in a special way the authorities of Omo Forest Reserve for granting me permission to carry out this study.

REFERENCES

1.

S.S. Ajayi , O.O. Tewe , C. Moriarty & M.O. Awesu 1978. Observations on the biology and nutritive value of the African giant snail Archachatina marginata. East African Wildlife Journal 16: 85–95. Google Scholar

2.

P.A. Allison 1955. Omo-Oshun Working Plan. Nigeria: Western Region Forestry Department. Google Scholar

3.

J.U. Chokor & O.C. Oke 2011. Effect of soil properties on the abundance and diversity of land molluscs in south western Nigeria. International journal of Tropical Medicine and Public Health 1: 36–44. Google Scholar

4.

K.R. Clarke 1993. Non-parametric multivariate analyses of change in community structure. Australian Journal of Ecology 18: 117–143. Google Scholar

5.

J.A. Coddington , L.H. Young & F.A. Coyle 1996. Estimating spider species richness in a southern Appalachian cove hardwood forest. Journal of Arachnology 24: 111–128. Google Scholar

6.

R.K. Colwell 2006. EstimateS: Statistical estimation of species richness and shared species from samples. Version 7.5. User's Guide and application,  http://purl.oclc.org/estimates (accessed 26/03/2013). Google Scholar

7.

R.K. Colwell & J.A. Coddington 1994. Estimating terrestrial biodiversity through extrapolation. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society (Series B) 345: 101–118. Google Scholar

8.

A.J. de Winter & E. Gittenberger 1998. The land snail fauna of a square kilometer patch of rainforest in southwestern Cameroon: high species richness, low abundance and seasonal fluctuations. Malacologia 40: 231–250. Google Scholar

9.

B. Fontaine , O. Gargominy & E. Neubert 2007. Land snail diversity of the savanna/ forest mosaic in Lopé National Park, Gabon. Malacologia 49: 313–338. Google Scholar

10.

H.G. Gauch & R.H. Whittaker 1981. Hierarchical classification of community data. Journal of Ecology 69: 537–557. Google Scholar

11.

N. Gotelli & R.K. Colwell 2001. Quantifying biodiversity: procedures and pitfalls in the measurement and comparison of species richness. Ecology Letters 4: 379–391. Google Scholar

12.

J. Graveland & R. Van Der Wal 1996. Decline in snail abundance due to soil acidification causes eggshell defects in forest passerines. Oecologia 105: 351–360. Google Scholar

13.

O. Hammer , D.A.T. Harper & P.D. Ryan 2001. PAST: Paleontological Statistics Software package for education and data analysis. Palaeontologia Electronica 4 (1): 1–9. Google Scholar

14.

K.P. Hotopp 2002. Land snails and soil calcium in central Appalachian Mountain forest. Southeastern Naturalist 1: 27–44. Google Scholar

15.

S. Johansen 1994. Comprehensive report of primate investigation in Omo Forest. Unpublished report. Nigerian Forest Elephant Group. Google Scholar

16.

R.G. Lowe 1993. More experiences of a forest officer in western Nigeria — part II. Forest monitoring in Omo Forest Reserve. The Nigerian Field 58: 137–156. Google Scholar

17.

C. Lydeard , R.H. Cowie , W.F. Ponder , A.E. Bogan , P. Bouchet , S.A. Clark , K.S. Cummings , T.J. Frest , O. Gargominy , D.G. Herbert , R. Hershler , K.E. Perez , B. Roth , M. Seddon , E.E. Strong & F.G. Thompson 2004. The global decline of nonmarine mollusks. Bioscience 54: 321–330. Google Scholar

18.

L.O. Ojo 2004. The fate of a tropical rainforest in Nigeria: Abeku sector of Omo Forest Reserve. Global Nest 6: 116–130. Google Scholar

19.

O.C. Oke 2007. Land snail diversity in a patch of cocoa plantation in Erin-Ijesha hills, Osun State, Nigeria. African Scientist 8 (2): 61–68. Google Scholar

20.

O.C. Oke & F.I. Alohan 2006. The land snail diversity in a square kilometre of tropical rainforest in Okomu National Park, Edo State, Nigeria. African Scientist 7 (3): 135–142. Google Scholar

21.

O.C. Oke , F.I. Alohan & W. Abhumlimen 2007a. Land-snail diversity in a threatened limestone formation in Odukapni, Cross River State, Nigeria. Global Journal of Pure and Applied Sciences 13 (4): 487–492. Google Scholar

22.

O.C. Oke , F.I. Alohan , & E.U. Edosomwan 2007b. Land snail diversity and abundance in a patch of secondary tropical rainforest in Ekpoma, Edo State, Nigeria. African Scientist 8 (2): 55–60. Google Scholar

23.

O.C. Oke , F.I. Alohan , M.O. Uzibor & J.U. Chokor 2008. Land snail diversity and species richness in an oil palm agroforest in Egbeta, Edo State, Nigeria. Bioscience Research Communications 20 (5): 249–256. Google Scholar

24.

O.C. Oke & J.U. Chokor 2010. Land snail species richness in Idanre hills, Ondo State, Nigeria. African Journal of Ecology 48: 1004–1008. Google Scholar

25.

O.C & Odiete Oke , W.O . 1996. New species of land molluscs from south western Nigeria. I. A new species attributed to Ptychotrema (Mollusca, Gastropoda). Journal of African Zoology 110: 61–64. Google Scholar

26.

O.C. Oke & W.O. Odiete 2007. Growth and reproduction in the giant African land snail Archachatina (Calachatina) marginata (Swainson) subspecies ovum. African Scientist 8: 209–217. Google Scholar

27.

O.C. Oke & O.O. Ugiagbe 2007. Land snail diversity in a patch of cocoa plantation in Usen, Edo State, Nigeria. Global Journal of Pure and Applied Sciences 13 (4): 481–485. Google Scholar

28.

J.C. Onyekwelu 2005. Site index curves for site quality assessment of Nauclea diderrichii monoculture plantations in Omo Forest Reserve, Nigeria. Journal of Tropical Forest Science 17: 532–542. Google Scholar

29.

H.M. Persson & M.D. Warner 2003. The chimpanzees and other primates of Omo Forest Reserve. The Nigerian Field 68: 160–167. Google Scholar

30.

A.S. Pullin 2002. Conservation biology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Google Scholar

31.

C. Régnier , B. Fontaine & P. Bouchet 2009. Not knowing, not recording, not listing: numerous unnoticed mollusk extinctions. Conservation Biology 23 (5): 1214–1221. Google Scholar

32.

M. Schilthuizen & H.A. Rutjes 2001. Land snail diversity in a square kilometre of tropical rainforest in Sabah, Malaysian Borneo. Journal of Molluscan Studies 67: 417–423. Google Scholar

33.

A. Segun 1975. The giant land snail, Archachatina (Calachatina) marginata (Swainson). Benin City: Ethiope Publishing House. Google Scholar

34.

J. Soberón , R. Jiménez , J. Golubov & G. Koleff 2007. Assessing completeness of biodiversity databases at different spatial scales. Ecography 30: 152–160. Google Scholar

35.

D. Strayer , D.H. Pletscher , S.P. Hamburg & S.C. Nodvin 1986. The effects of forest disturbance on land gastropod communities in northern New England. Canadian Journal Zoology 64: 2094–2098. Google Scholar

36.

P. Tattersfield 1996. Local patterns of land snail diversity in a Kenyan rain forest. Malacologia 38: 161–180. Google Scholar
Christopher Omamoke Oke "Terrestrial Mollusc Species Richness and Diversity in Omo Forest Reserve, Ogun State, Nigeria," African Invertebrates 54(1), 93-104, (24 April 2013). https://doi.org/10.5733/afin.054.0106
Published: 24 April 2013
JOURNAL ARTICLE
12 PAGES


SHARE
ARTICLE IMPACT
Back to Top