The causes of thermal tolerance limits in animals are controversial. In many aquatic species, it is thought that the inability to deliver sufficient oxygen at high temperatures is more critical than impairment of molecular functions of the mitochondria. However, terrestrial insects utilize a tracheal system, and the concept of a mismatch between metabolic demand and circulatory performance might not apply to them. Using thermo-limit respirometry, it has been shown earlier in Drosophila melanogaster that CO2 release rates at temperatures above the upper thermal limit (CTmax) exceed the rate at CTmax. The nature of this post-CTmax, or “post-mortal” peak, is unknown. Either its source is increased aerobic mitochondrial respiration (hyperthermic overdrive), or an anaerobic process such as liberation of stored CO2 from the hemolymph. The post-mortal peak of CO2 release was found to be oxygen dependent. As the rate of CO2 emission is a conservative indicator of rate of O2 consumption, aerobic flux at the thermal limit is submaximal, which contradicts the theory that oxygen availability limits metabolic activity at high temperatures in insects. Consequently, the tracheal system should be capable of delivering sufficient oxygen for aerobic activity of the mitochondria at and above Ctmax.
Maximal oxygen supply in various animals is restricted either by the physical properties of the environment in which they live, or by the need to balance the components of the respiratory cascade (Weibel et al. 1992), and often by both factors simultaneously. Aquatic species are affected by the low solubility and slow diffusion of O2 in water and body fluids as compared to air, approximately 30 and 105 times lower, respectively (Dejours 1975). Species relying on convective oxygen supply must modulate ventilation, circulation, and tissue perfusion in accord with mitochondrial activity.
Though ectotherms evolved to meet high metabolic demands during phases of aerobic activity, their respiratory and circulatory systems are substantially challenged by thermal stress. At high temperatures, oxygen delivery to the mitochondria may become insufficient to sustain aerobic metabolism. This is because the relationship between temperature and metabolic activity is exponential, at least until thermal stress, through whatever mechanism, causes a downward inflection in metabolic activity as CTmax is approached. The concept of oxygen-limited and capacity-limited thermal tolerance states that the capacities of oxygen supply systems at the whole-organism level, rather than temperature responses at the cellular or molecular level, confine the thermal windows within which metazoans operate (Pörtner 2001). Originally developed for marine invertebrates and fishes (Frederich and Pörtner 2000, Pörtner et al. 2004), this hypothesis may be more generally applicable to a number of air and water breathing species (Pörtner 2001).
However, insects circumvent the above mentioned respiratory restrictions for liquid phase oxygen transport. Their respiratory system, the tracheal system, consists of a finely branched, gas-filled tubular network, which directly connects the outside air with the target tissues. Given the relatively small size of insects, the tracheal system is highly effective. Except for special cell types (Locke 1997), hemolymph circulation is generally considered unnecessary for adequate oxygen supply. The hemolymph contains only a few O2-binding pigments, the function of which is unclear (Burmester and Hankeln 1999). At rest, ventilation often is discontinued, and diffusion in the tracheal system alone can supply adequate oxygen (Lighton 1996, Wobschall and Hetz 2004). Overall, the oxygen supply chain is highly simplified to a single transport system in insects. According to the theory of capacity-limited thermal tolerance, the performance of this system alone would then define the thermal limits of the animal.
It has been suggested that capacity limitation of thermal tolerance is not significant in at least some tracheate arthropods (Klok et al. 2004), using the new technique of thermolimit respirometry (Lighton and Turner 2004). Thermo-limit respirometry allows the simultaneous measurement of the upper thermal limit and carbon dioxide emission. A peculiar feature of this method in insects is a post-mortal CO2 peak (Figure 1a) which occurs after the death of the animal. However, CO2 release is not a reliable indicator of metabolic demand/oxygen consumption. Lowering of tissue or hemolymph pH, resulting in liberation of CO2 from bicarbonate, as well as other anaerobic processes, can significantly distort the relationship between oxygen consumption and carbon dioxide release. Thus, the origin of the peak has remained unclear. If the oxygen capacity limitation hypothesis holds, the peak must be of anaerobic origin (see discussion for details). Therefore, elucidating the nature of the mechanism behind it provides a further direct test of the capacity limitation hypothesis.
Materials and Methods
Drosophila melanogaster, strain Oregon-R wild type, were reared at 25° C with a 12: 12 L:D cycle. Adult flies were released, and flies eclosing over the subsequent two days were collected in narrow vials containing feeding medium. Flies aged 5–10 days (approximately equally divided between male and female) were used for the experiments described here.
To determine whether the high post-CTmax CO2 release rate is coupled to aerobic processes, CO2 flux, evaporative water loss, and behavioral activity of individual D. melanogaster were monitored using a Sable Systems SI-1 respirometry system (Sable Systems International, Las Vegas, Nevada, USA). To determine thermal limits, after an equilibration period of ∼10–20 min at 30° C the temperature of the fly was continuously increased from 30 to 45° C at a rate of 0.5° C min-1. Refer to Lighton (2007) for a detailed methodological description of the setup. The thermo-limit respirometry method is described in detail by Lighton and Turner (2004), including the requisite data analysis and statistical methods.
Carbon dioxide release rates during thermo-limit respirometry in normoxia and anoxia in Drosophila melanogaster.
In the absence of oxygen, all aerobic processes quickly cease, without directly affecting anaerobic processes. Thus, anoxia treatment was used to infer the nature of the post-mortal peak. Chamber air was immediately switched to nitrogen using a computer-controlled solenoid valve as soon as the activity of the flies ceased, and the carbon dioxide and water traces signified that the upper thermal limit had been reached. Control experiments were conducted with normoxia maintained throughout the whole trial.
Figure 1, Panel A, shows a typical thermolimit respirometry experiment in normoxia. After an initial recovery phase of 20 minutes, temperature slowly increased from 30° C to 45° C. Death occurred at CTmax = 39.6 ± 1.0° C (n = 17), when all body movements ceased. Below CTmax, CO2 release rate entered a plateau, and evaporative water loss rate increased more slowly than at temperatures above CTmax, indicating that neuromuscular control of the spiracles was still intact (Lighton and Turner 2004; Klok et al. 2004; Lighton 2007). These short-term variations in CO2 and H2O flux then ceased abruptly above CTmax, and were followed in normoxia by the post-mortal CO2 peak. Carbon dioxide release rate at CTmax was 6.27 µmol g-1 min-1, and maximal post-CTmax rate was 15.21 µmol g-1 min-1 (Table 1).
Anoxia resulted in exponential decay of CO2 emission rate, and total extirpation of the postmortal CO2 peak (Figure 1, panel B). At CTmax, the CO2 release of both groups did not differ significantly, but the maximal postmortem CO2 release rate in the anoxic group was significantly lower (p < 0.001, Table 1). In normoxia, maximal CO2 release rate exceeded the CTmax rate by a factor of two or more (p < 0.001), while in anoxia, maximal CO2 release occurred at CTmax just prior to exposure to anoxia. In addition, the total amount of CO2 released in the 20 minute period following CTmax was four-fold lower in the anoxic treatment (p < 0.001). Note that anoxia does not reduce the degree of spiracular opening; instead, it maximizes it (Lighton and Schilman 2007), as can also be seen from the water vapor trace (Figure 1). So, the observed reduction in the post-mortal peak is not caused by spiracular closure.
With respect to evaporative water loss, we compared the ratio of water loss rate before and after CTmax in the control and anoxia-exposed groups, which were 0.268 ± 0.012 SD and 0.284 ± 0.026 SD, respectively. These ratios did not differ significantly (after arcsine-transforming the square root of the ratios to normalize them, t = 0.52, df = 15, p = 0.6). After the initial increase of water loss driven by the increasing water vapor saturation deficit, increase in evaporation rate slowed down, probably due to increased spiracular control near CTmax. After spiracular control ceased above CTmax, water loss rate increased with a rate comparable to the initial saturation deficit driven increase, as can clearly be seen in Figure 1, panels A3 and B3, indicating constant and likely maximal spiracular aperture post-mortem.
The results clearly demonstrated an aerobic origin of the post-mortal peak. Thus, the null hypothesis that the peak results from anaerobic washout of internal CO2 stores is rejected. Another alternative explanation, that a change of tracheal conductance is due to post mortem increase in spiracular aperture, is inconsistent with the observed rates of evaporative water loss.
In insects, water loss occurs either via the external body surface, or via the spiracles located at the distal opening of the tracheal tubes. For a given gradient of water vapor pressure between body and environment, surface evaporation is constant, since the body surface area does not change. Respiratory water loss is determined by the aperture of the spiracular valves, which are under CNS control. The effect of this spiracular control is seen as small, noise-like variations in the water vapor trace in Figure 1, panels A3 and B3. At CTmax, this flicker in the water vapor trace ceases, indicating loss of spiracular control and constant spiracular aperture. Throughout the experiment, water loss rates approximately track the water vapor pressure saturation deficit of the air within the chamber; this is clearly seen in Figure 1, panels A3 and B3.
The CO2 release rate of approximately 7 µmol g-1 min-1 at CTmax in D. melanogaster, determined in this study and previous studies (Lighton 2007), is far lower than the values of approximately 30 µmol g-1 min-1 found for D. melanogaster flying at maximal performance (Lehmann 2001). The peak post-mortem rate of CO2 production, while more than twice the rate recorded at CTmax, is still only half the maximum rate recorded during flight at room temperature. A possible explanation may be that in flies, after death, oxygen supply is purely diffusive, whereas convection and autoventilation could play a dominant role during flight (Komai 1998).
However, this does not affect the conclusions derived from our results. Since the post-mortal peak is aerobic, the increased rate of carbon dioxide release past CTmax indicates that the tracheal system is capable of delivering more oxygen than is required at CTmax. While oxygen consumption was not measured directly, the rate of CO2 emission is a conservative indicator of the rate of O2 consumption. The constant of diffusion for O2 in air is only slightly larger than that of CO2, but the difference in partial pressure that drives diffusion between outside air and the mitochondria is approximately four-fold greater for O2. The maximal mismatch between O2 consumption and CO2 production during normal aerobic activity does not exceed 1:0. 72 (respiratory quotient of 0.72). Thus, in steady state conditions, CO2 excretion is more likely to be a limiting factor than O2 supply. Often, CO2 release rate more than doubled post mortem in normoxia, evidencing a substantial increase of oxygen consumption after the animal died.
Clearly, contrary to what the oxygen limitation hypothesis predicts, in insects the upper thermal limit is not defined by the oxygen supply capacity of the tracheal system. The results of this study, therefore, support the conclusions of Klok et al. (2004), and provide further evidence that the oxygen limitation hypothesis does not apply to tracheate arthropods, at least in normoxia. The mitochondrial mechanism behind the postmortal CO2 peak was not investigated. While of great theoretical interest, it does not affect the conclusions derived above. Mitochondrial “hyperthermic overdrive” may originate from thermally mediated membrane breakdown, and the resulting uncoupling of oxidative phosphorylation. Other workers are encouraged to explore this interesting phenomenon in greater detail.