We related presence and burden of stomach nematodes to body mass and reproductive allocation in hispid cotton rats (Sigmodon hispidus) from two long-running field studies in Virginia (1983–1984, n = 286; and 1988–1990, n = 425) and one from Georgia 1987–1989 (n = 459). Eighty percent of rats from the earlier Virginia sample were infected, with mean nematode mass of 1,311 mg. In the later samples, 23% (Virginia) and 33% (Georgia) were infected with mean nematode mass of 493 and 769 mg, respectively. Presence of nematodes was positively correlated with host body length for each sex in each sample. We used analysis of covariance to examine length-adjusted residuals for presence of nematodes and mass of nematodes for association with somatic and reproductive response variables. Both body and reproductive masses were either positively associated or not related to nematode presence in the two low-prevalence samples, and either negatively associated or not related to nematode presence in the high-prevalence sample. No relationships were detected between host mass and nematode mass per host in either sex in any sample. There was no effect of nematode presence on litter size of pregnant females, but there was a positive effect of nematode mass on litter size in Georgia. Recent theory provides several possible explanations for such neutral-to-positive effects of stomach nematodes on host fitness, including the evolution of host tolerance to the parasites, fecundity compensation by the hosts, and positive effects on host health via immune modulation.