Rhynchocephalia, a once diverse clade of lizard-like reptiles, had a nearly global distribution during much of the Mesozoic. By the Late Cretaceous rhynchocephalians underwent a marked reduction in their diversity and biogeographic range, with sparse records of only deeply nested taxa (e.g., Sphenodontinae) found in the Upper Cretaceous–Paleocene of Patagonia and the Miocene–Recent of New Zealand. Here we describe a partial dentary with teeth of a rhynchocephalian from the Naskal locality, an intertrappean deposit within the Deccan Traps Volcanic Province in peninsular India. This discovery represents the first Cretaceous–Paleogene (K–Pg) record of a rhynchocephalian outside of Patagonia and: (i) demonstrates the clade had a broader Gondwanan distribution during the Cretaceous than previously appreciated and (ii) reinforces the emerging pattern that Rhynchocephalia were confined to Gondwana after the Early Cretaceous. This further extends the rhynchocephalian record in India, which now spans most of the Mesozoic (Late Triassic to ca. K–Pg boundary). The Naskal rhynchocephalian is a member of Acrosphenodontia based on its regionalized, acrodont marginal dentition. Its hatchling teeth appear to be unique (e.g., crowns mesially tipped, distinct break in slope along distal margin) and most similar in morphology to those of Godavarisaurus lateefi from the Lower–Middle Jurassic of India. Although the Naskal intertrappean most likely was deposited during the latest Maastrichtian, additional fossil sampling across the K–Pg boundary in India is needed to determine whether the Naskal rhynchocephalian was a victim or survivor of the end-Cretaceous mass extinction.