Exclusion of large grazers from rangelands that evolved with significant grazing pressure can alter natural processes and may have legacy effects by changing magnitude or direction of community responses to subsequent disturbance. Three moderately grazed pastures were paired with 12-ha areas with 15 yr of livestock exclusion. Six treatments were assigned to each in a 2 × 3 factorial arrangement of fire (fall fire or no fire) and grazing utilization (0%, 50%, or 75% biomass removal) to determine grazing history effects on rangeland response to subsequent disturbance. Livestock exclusion increased C₃ perennial grass (1 232 vs. 980±50 kg ⋅ ha^-1) and forbs (173 vs. 62± 19 kg ⋅ ha^-1) and reduced C₄ perennial grass (36 vs. 180± 25 kg ⋅ ha^-1) with no effect on total current year biomass. Diversity was greater in pastures than exclosures (H' = 1.5400 vs. 1.3823 ± 0.0431). Every biomass, cover, and diversity measure, except subshrub biomass, was affected by fire, grazing utilization, or both. Contrary to expectations, grazing history only interacted with fire effects for old standing dead material and interactions with grazing utilization were limited to old dead, bare ground, richness and dominance. Fire by grazing utilization interaction was limited to bare ground. Fire reduced annual grass (64 vs. 137±29 kg ⋅ ha^-1), forbs (84 vs. 133 ± 29 kg ⋅ ha^-1), and diversity (H'=1.3260 vs. 1.5005± 0.0537) with no difference in total current-year biomass (1 557 vs. 1 594±66 kg ⋅ ha^-1). Grazing to 75% utilization reduced total current-year biomass (1 467 vs. 1 656±66 kg ⋅ ha^-1) and dominance (0.4824 vs. 0.5584 ± 0.0279). Grazing history affected starting points for most variables, but changes caused by grazing utilization or fire were similar between pastures and exclosures, indicating management decisions can be made based on independent knowledge of grazing or fire effects.