Open Access
Translator Disclaimer
1 March 2011 A New Record of the Fruit Piercing Moth Oraesia excavata (Butler) (Erebidae: Calpinae: Calpini) for Hawaii and the United States
William P. Haines, Forest Starr, Kim Starr, W. Garfield King
Author Affiliations +

In November 2009, an exotic fruit piercing moth was collected at an elevation of 1125 m in Kula, Maui, Hawaii by W. G. King, and the specimen was submitted with his insect collection for an introductory entomology course at the University of Hawaii. Soon thereafter, the species was independently collected by the authors and others from other localities on the islands of Maui, Kauai, Oahu, and Hawaii (C. Campora, B. Kumashiro, C. Jacobsen pers. comm.), and tentatively identified as Oraesia excavata (Butler) (Erebidae: Calpinae: Calpini), which was confirmed by M. Pogue (2010). To our knowledge, this is the first record of establishment of O. excavata outside of Asia, and certainly the first record of establishment in the USA. Widespread surveys have not taken place, so the full extent of the invasion within Hawaii remains unknown. However, the species has been collected from widely dispersed sites on the islands of Kauai, Oahu, Maui, and Hawaii, and eradication is not considered a possibility.

The large moth is quite distinctive, with a scalloped trailing edge of the forewings, unusual porrect palpi, and orange head and ventral surface of the body and legs (Fig. 1), which easily distinguish it from other species present in Hawaii. Antennae of males are pectinate, while those of females are simple. When resting with folded wings, the moth somewhat resembles a dead leaf with a scalloped dorsal edge, and the beaklike palpi are noticeable (Fig. 2).

Because we observed only a few eggs and larvae, and none were successfully reared completely from egg to adult, we are unsure of the number of instars, duration of life cycle, and extent of color variation. We successfully reared one field-caught caterpillar to adulthood (Fig. 2), confirming the association between caterpillars and adults. Six eggs were laid in the laboratory by a female caught by S. Montgomery et al. at Kokee, Kauai. These were roughly spherical (diameter about 0.80 mm), light brown with dark brown splotches, and loosely adhered to a substrate within the collecting container (Fig. 3). Newly hatched larvae (Fig. 4, body length 3.2 mm, head capsule width 0.45 mm) are uniformly grey with black tubercules and setae. Intermediate instars (Figs. 5 and 6) are very dark brown, with an orange dorso-lateral spot on the second abdominal segment. Late instars (Figs. 7 and 8) are light brown or grey, with or without a lighter dorso-lateral spot on the second abdominal segment. The head capsule width of the penultimate instar (Fig. 8) is approximately 3.6 mm. Caterpillars of O. excavata are loopers, and can move quite quickly, but the caterpillars we observed in the field generally remained quite still, oriented cryptically along a stem or petiole. Caterpillars were found on vines both during the daytime and at night, and often dropped from foliage when disturbed. When feeding, early instars leave the leaf epidermis intact, creating “windowpane” damage, while older caterpillars chew through the entire leaf, usually starting from the edge.

Figs.1–8:

1) Oraesia excavata, ♂. USA: HI, Oahu, Koolau Mtns. Waahila Ridge. 360m. 21.308N, 157.796W. UV light trap. 9 Jan 2010. W. Haines. a, Dorsal surface. b, Ventral surface. 2) O. excavata, ♀, live moth showing resting position. USA, HI, Maui, Olinda, Hawea Pl., 890 m. 20.822N, 156.297W. reared ex: Cocculus orbiculatus. collected: 12 Feb 2010, pupated: 18 Mar 2010, emerged: 9 Apr 2010. F. and K. Starr. 3) O. excavata, egg laid by female collected at Kokee, Kauai. 4) O. excavata, first instar larva, newly hatched from egg laid by female collected at Kokee, Kauai. 5) O. excavata, intermediate instar larva, USA, HI, Maui, Olinda, Hawea Pl., 890 m. 20.822N, 156.297W. ex: Cocculus orbiculatus. F. and K. Starr. Collected: 7 Mar 2010. Photographed: 17 Mar 2010. a, dorsal view. b, lateral view. 6) O. excavata, intermediate instar larva, same individual as Fig. 5. Photographed: 22 Mar 2010. a, dorsal view. b, lateral view. 7) O. excavata, late instar larva, same individual as Fig. 5. Photographed: 30 Mar 2010. a, dorsal view. b, lateral view. 8) O. excavata, penultimate instar larva, from same locality as Fig. 5. Collected: 12 Feb 2010. Photographed: 17 Mar 2010. a, dorsal view. b, lateral view.

f01_53.jpg

Originally described from Japan (Butler 1878), O. excavata is a major pest there as well as in other Asian regions, including China (Chen et al. 1992; Liu 2002), Korea (Lee et al. 1970), Taiwan (Taiwan Forestry Research Institute 2010), and Thailand (Pholboon 1965). It has been recorded as a pest on many soft fruit crops, including peaches, plums, pears, apples, grapes, citrus, mango, loquat and papaya (Liu 2002; Zhang 1994; H. Tsumuki pers. comm.). The adult uses its barbed proboscis to pierce ripe fruit and feed on juice, often causing rot to develop around the injury, and causing some fruits to fall prematurely (Hattori 1969). In some regions of Asia, this species is considered the most important moth pest of fruit crops (Lee et al. 1970; Chen et al. 1992). It is on quarantine lists for India (Plant Quarantine Organization of India 2003), Australia (Biosecurity Australia 2008), and New Zealand (Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry 1999) as an importation threat from countries where it occurs.

The genus Oraesia Gueneé is mostly pantropical, and includes about 25 species of fruit piercing moths (Zaspel & Branham 2008). Although there are many exceptions, calpine moths, including the genus Oraesia, predominantly specialize on the plant family Menispermaceae for oviposition (Fay 1996). Based on published records, menispermaceous plants are certainly preferred hosts for O. excavata (Pholboon 1965; Fujimura 1972; Ohmasa et al. 1991), but there are also some records of caterpillars feeding on other plant families, for instance Lepisanthes rubiginosa (Sapindaceae) (Pholboon 1965). In Japan, caterpillars of O. excavata feed primarily on Cocculus orbiculatus (L.) (Menispermaceae), a creeping vine that occurs outside of orchards (Ohmasa et al. 1991). This plant is also native to Hawaii, and is a local host for O. excavata. However, because C. orbiculatus is not a particularly common or abundant plant in Hawaii, it is possible that O. excavata may utilize other hosts as well. We collected O. excavata caterpillars on C. orbiculatus at two sites in Hawaii: upland mesic forest at Olinda, Maui (890 m), and dry coastal shrubland at Kaena Point on Oahu (73 m), suggesting that O. excavata tolerates a wide range of moisture, elevation, and temperature.

Many fruits grown in Hawaii, including papaya, mango, banana, orange, and guava, will likely be fed upon by adult O. excavata, but it remains to be seen whether damage will be economically significant. At this time, excessive fruit-piercing damage has not been reported by fruit growers in Hawaii. Another fruit piercing moth Eucodima phalonia (Clerck), has been established in Hawaii for 25 years (Heu et al. 1985), but is not considered a major pest there, despite being very problematic elsewhere in the Pacific (Fay 1996; Reddy et al. 2005). Its relative innocuousness in Hawaii may be due to high levels of attack by Trichogramma and other parasitoids (Heu et al. 1985). This may prove to be the case with O. excavata as well.

There has been considerable research towards the control and monitoring of O. excavata in Asia, including sex pheromones (Ohmasa et al. 1991), plant kairomone attractants (Miyazaki et al. 1972; Tian et al. 2008), chemical deterrents (Fujimura 1972; Tian et al. 2007), bagging of fruits (Fujimura 1972; Liu 2002), pesticides (Fujimura 1972; Liu et al. 2001), and light traps (Hattori 1969; Fujimura 1972; Liu et al. 2001; Liu 2002), but these have had only limited success. A female sex pheromone of O. excavata was identified and found to be very attractive to males (Ohmasa et al. 1991), but is not commercially available or currently used for monitoring or control in Japan (H. Tsumuki pers. comm.). The odor of ripe fruit is also attractive to the moths, and traps may be baited either with the fruit themselves, or a chemical mixture that simulates fruit odor (Tian et al. 2008).

Although O. excavata and O. emarginata are major pests in Asia, a risk assessment conducted by the New Zealand Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry (Tyson et al. 2009) concluded that the risk of importation of these species along with fruit was negligible, because larvae and eggs are not associated with fruit trees, while adults are nocturnal, highly mobile, and unlikely to remain on produce during the daytime when fruit is harvested. It is unknown from which country or by what pathway O. excavata was introduced to Hawaii, but it appears to have spread rapidly upon arrival, being independently collected or photographed on four islands within months of initial detection. It is possible that adults actively flew or were carried by winds among the different islands, but considering the apparently rapid spread between distant islands (greater than 115 km of open ocean between Oahu and Kauai), human-mediated transport seems likely. Since adult noctuiod moths often seek shelter in dark places during the day, it is possible that they could be transported in packing crates or containers, even if not associated with a specific product. The lack of a known invasion pathway may complicate inspection efforts for this pest.

Because of the importance of orchard and vine crops in the continental US, O. excavata could potentially become a pest if established there, and its geographic range in Asia is similar in climate to regions of North America, especially the Eastern US. One major factor which might limit establishment or population growth in North America is the occurrence of suitable larval host plants. There are only six species of Menispermaceae (5 native, 1 exotic) established in the continental US, and most of these are confined to the southeastern part of the country. (Rhodes 1997). West of the Rocky Mountains, there are no native or naturalized menispermaceous species in the continental US, other than Cocculus diversifolius de Candolle in the very southern parts of Arizona and Texas. However, east of the Rocky Mountains there are five species of Menispermaceae, including the widespread natives Cocculus carolinus (L.) and Menispermum canadense L. (Rhodes 1997). Of course, it is also possible that O. excavata could establish or even thrive on a different plant family, since its degree of host-specificity has not been evaluated.

Given the potential threat of this species to fruit crops in the mainland United States, it would be worthwhile to study the biology and distribution of O. excavata in Hawaii. Monitoring methods could be developed in Hawaii and used for early detection or interception of O. excavata in the mainland United States.

Material examined (deposited at University of Hawaii Insect Museum, UHIM):

  • Adult moths: 1 ♂ , USA: HI, Maui, Kula, Upper Kimo Dr. 1125 m. 20.775N, 156.298W. 24 Nov 2009. G. King; 2 ♂, USA: HI, Maui, Kokomo, 2955 Kailiili Rd. 477m. 20.867N, 156.305W. At UV light. 17 – 19 Dec 2009. W. Haines; 2 ♂, USA: HI, Oahu, Koolau Mtns. Waahila Ridge. 360 m. 21.308N, 157.796W. UV light trap. 9 Jan 2010. W. Haines; 1 ♀, USA: HI, Oahu, Ewa, Aloun Farms citrus grove. Unbaited fruit fly trap. 58 m. 21.374N, 158.045W. 25 Jan 2010. L. Leblanc; 1 ♀, USA: HI, Kauai, Koke'e State Park. S. Montgomery, C. Campora, S. Lee; 1 ♀, USA, HI, Maui, Olinda, Hawea Pl., 890 m. 20.822N, 156.297W. reared ex: Cocculus orbiculatus. collected: 12 Feb 2010, pupated: 18 Mar 2010, emerged: 9 Apr 2010. F. and K. Starr; 1 ♂, USA: HI, Hawaii Island, Ka'u, Kahuku, Ocean View Estates, 550 m. 19.073N, 155.750W. 6 Dec 2010. S. Montgomery., 2 ♀, USA: HI, Hawaii Island, Ka'u, Kahuku, near Ocean View Estates, 550 m. 19.07N, 155.74W. 5 Jan 2011. S. Montgomery.

  • Larvae: 5 larvae, USA, HI, Maui, Olinda, Hawea Pl., 890 m. 20.822N, 156.297W. ex: Cocculus orbiculatus. 12 Feb – 16 Mar 2010. F. and K. Starr.; 5 larvae, USA, HI, North Oahu, Kaena Point, 73 m. 21.575N, 158.258W. ex: Cocculus orbiculatus. 15 May 2010. W. Haines.

  • Other existing material (photographs examined): 1 unknown sex, USA: HI, Oahu, Lualualei, Halona Valley, 500 m. 21.424N, 158.098W. 8 Dec 2009. C. Campora, S. Montgomery, S. Lee (specimen kept by S. Montgomery).; 1♂, USA: HI, Oahu, Nuuanu, on eaves of roof, 21 Dec 2009. G. Uchida. (Specimen at Hawaii Department of Agriculture); 1 unknown sex, USA: HI, Hawaii Island, Kawaihae, Honouli St., 20.062N, 155.839W, 95m, at residence, 7 Jul 2010 (photographed but not collected).

  • Acknowledgements

    We thank C. Jacobsen, L. Leblanc, J. Rapozo, and H. Spafford (University of Hawaii), B. Kumashiro (Hawaii Department of Agriculture), C. Campora and S. Lee (US Navy), D. Medeiros, and S. Montgomery for sharing collection data, photographs, and specimens. M. Pogue (Systematic Entomology Laboratory, USDA), and J. Zaspel (University of Minnesota) confirmed the identification of O. excavata. H. Tsumuki (Okayama University, Japan) kindly shared information about fruit piercing moth research in Japan. B. Scholtens and anonymous reviewers provided valuable comments and facilitated publication. Support and equipment for photographing specimens was provided by the UHIM and a grant from USDA Cooperative State Research, Education and Extension (CSREES), project HAW00942-H, administered by the College of Tropical Agriculture and Human Resources, University of Hawaii.

    Literature Cited

    1.

    Biosecurity Australia. 2008. Issues paper for the import risk analysis for fresh apple fruit from the People's Republic of China. Appendix A, p. 21. Canberra, Biosecurity Australia 26 pp. Google Scholar

    2.

    A. G. Butler 1878. Descriptions of new species of Heterocera from Japan. Part-II. Noctuites. Annals and Magazine of Natural History, series 5, 1: 202–203. Google Scholar

    3.

    C.X. Chen , H. Liu , & M. H. Liu . 1992. Investigation on the species of citrus fruit sucking moths in southern Jiangxi. China Citrus 21(3): 30–31. Google Scholar

    4.

    H.A.C. Fay 1996. Evolutionary and taxonomic relationships between fruit-piercing moths and the Menispermaceae. Australian Systematic Botany 9(2): 227–233. Google Scholar

    5.

    T. Fujimura 1972. Studies on fruit-piercing moths IX. Experiments on control. Bulletin of the Shimane Agricultural Experiment Station 10: 159–176. Google Scholar

    6.

    I. Hattori 1969. Fruit piercing moths in Japan. Japan Agricultural Research Quarterly 4(4): 32–36. Google Scholar

    7.

    R. Heu , K. Teramoto , E. Shiroma , B. Kumashiro , A. Higa & R. Dinker . 1985. A fruit-piercing moth, Eudocima (Othreis) fullonia (Clerck). Hawaii Pest Report 5: 4–5. Google Scholar

    8.

    S.C. Lee , J.K. Yoo & C.H. Yoo . 1970. Survey on the kinds of the fruit sucking moths and their damages in Korea (1). Korean Journal of Plant Protection 9(1): 37–41. Google Scholar

    9.

    X.Q. Liu 2002. The occurrence of fruit piercing moth in Wuhan area and its control. South China Fruits 31(3): 15–16. Google Scholar

    10.

    Y.S. Liu , Y.J. Kuang & S. Guoji . 2001. Emergence and control of dominant population of fruit-piercing moth in Hubei Province. Plant Protection 27(1): 31–32. Google Scholar

    11.

    Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry. 1999. Import Health Standard Commodity Sub-class: Fresh Fruit/Vegetables Korean pear, Pyrus pyrifolia from the Republic of Korea. p. 12.Wellington, Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry, New Zealand. 16 pp. Google Scholar

    12.

    A. H. Honda Miyazaki , T. Saito & K. Munakata . 1972. Studies on the attractant of fruit-piercing moths. Japanese Journal of Applied Entomology and Zoology 16(1): 40–43. Google Scholar

    13.

    Y. Ohmasa , S. Wakamura , S. Kozaki , H. Sugie , M. Horiike , C. Hirano & S. Mori . 1991. Sex pheromone of the fruit-piercing moth, Oraesia excavata (Butler) (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae): isolation and identification. Applied Entomology and Zoology 26: 55–62. Google Scholar

    14.

    P. Pholboon 1965. A Host List of the Insects of Thailand. Bangkok, Department of Agriculture of the Royal Thai Government & United States Operations Mission to Thailand. Google Scholar

    15.

    Plant Quarantine Organization of India. 2003. India Plant Quarantine Order, Schedule VI., p. 96, New Delhi. 105 pp. Google Scholar

    16.

    M. Pogue 2010. (Lot# 1000914 Oraesia excavata [Butler]), Systematic Entomology Laboratory, Agricultural Research Service, US Department of Agriculture. Google Scholar

    17.

    G.V.P. Reddy , Z.T. Cruz , J. Bamba & R. Muniappan . 2005. Host adaptation of the fruit piercing moth, Eudocima fullonia. Physiological Entomology 30 (4): 398–401. Google Scholar

    18.

    D. Rhodes 1997. Menispermaceae. In Flora of North America Editorial Committee, eds. 1993+. Flora of North America North of Mexico. 15+ vols. New York and Oxford. Vol. 3. Accessed through efloras.org on 2 Feb 2010,  http://www.efloras.org/florataxon.aspx?flora_id=1&taxon_id=10561Google Scholar

    19.

    Taiwan Forestry Research Institute. 2010. Six specimen records, accessed through GBIF data portal on 2 Feb 2010,  http://www.gbif.net/datasets/resource/8373Google Scholar

    20.

    R. Tian , Y. Izumi , S. Sonoda , H. Yoshida , T. Fukumoto , T. Saito & H. Tsumuki . 2007. Estimation of repellency of a volatile compound, sec-butyl ,β-styryl ketone, against fruit-piercing moths. Applied Entomology and Zoology 42(3): 433–437. Google Scholar

    21.

    R. Tian , Y. Izumi , S. Sonoda , H. Yoshida , T. Takanashi , K. Nakamuta & H. Tsumuki . 2008. Electroantennographic responses and field attraction to peach fruit odors in the fruit-piercing moth, Oraesia excavata (Butler) (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae). Applied Entomology and Zoology 43(2): 265–269. Google Scholar

    22.

    J. Tyson , S. Rainey , J. Breach & S. Toy . 2009. Import Risk Analysis: Pears (Pyrus bretschneideri, Pyrus pyrifolia, and Pyrus sp. nr. communis) fresh fruit from China. p. 257–259. Wellington, Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry, Biosecurity New Zealand. 454+ pp. Google Scholar

    23.

    J.M. Zaspel & M.A. Branham . 2008. World Checklist of Tribe Calpini (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae: Calpinae). Insecta Mundi 0047: 1–15. Google Scholar

    24.

    B.C. Zhang 1994. Index of Economically Important Lepidoptera. Wallingford, CAB International. 599 pp. Google Scholar
    William P. Haines, Forest Starr, Kim Starr, and W. Garfield King "A New Record of the Fruit Piercing Moth Oraesia excavata (Butler) (Erebidae: Calpinae: Calpini) for Hawaii and the United States," The Journal of the Lepidopterists' Society 65(1), 53-57, (1 March 2011). https://doi.org/10.18473/lepi.v65i1.a6
    Received: 5 February 2010; Accepted: 21 September 2010; Published: 1 March 2011
    JOURNAL ARTICLE
    5 PAGES


    Share
    SHARE
    KEYWORDS
    Asia
    Menispermaceae
    orchard pest
    Pacific
    peach
    pear
    ARTICLE IMPACT
    RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS
    Get copyright permission
    Back to Top