Observations of natural spawning events are rare but critically important for the field of fertilization ecology. For broadcast spawners, knowing the natural behavior of spawning, including proximity of animals and the timing of spawning, is essential for informing spawning experiments and directing future study. Here we describe a natural spawning event that took place on the island of Maui in the winter of 2010. Groups of Tripnuestes gratilla were observed to spawn in the late afternoon shortly after a local high tide that was a lower high of a mixed, semidiurnal tide cycle. Urchins appeared to increase the probability of fertilization by ascending to the local high points of the reefs and spawning within groups of 2–5. Although the majority of the urchins that spawned were T. gratilla, two individuals of Echinothrix diadema were observed to spawn at the same time, raising questions about potential hybridization in the wild.