We outline some misconceptions and methodological deficiencies presented in the comparison of four types of aeolian saltation sensors. Specifically, we clarify the sampling area, operation, and response of the sensors and comment on the methodological challenges for field-based sensor comparisons. The goal of this discussion is to clarify some inconsistencies that may influence the selection of one sensor over another in future research. Indirectly, we hope to highlight research needs and improve the reliability of aeolian transport measurements.
How to translate text using browser tools
1 November 2011
Discussion of: Sherman, D.J.; Li, B.; Farrell, E.J.; Ellis, J.T.; Cox, W.D.; Maia, L.P., and Sousa, P.H.G.O., 2011. Measuring Aeolian Saltation: A Comparison of Sensors. In: Roberts, T.M.; Rosati, J.D., and Wang, P. (eds.), Proceedings, Symposium to Honor Dr. Nicholas Kraus, Journal of Coastal Research, Special Issue No. 59, pp. 280–290
Chris H. Hugenholtz,
Thomas E. Barchyn
ACCESS THE FULL ARTICLE
![](/ContentImages/journals/coas/27/6/6/WebImages/15515036-27.6.cover.jpg)
Journal of Coastal Research
Vol. 27 • No. 6
November 2011
Vol. 27 • No. 6
November 2011
Aeolian sediment transport sensors
experimental design
sensor comparison
uncertainty