At northern latitudes, bats often use roosting structures provided by people. Conventional thinking suggests that bat boxes should be entirely black to absorb heat and assist bats with thermoregulation. However, with long periods of summer daylight in subarctic Canada, we suspected that risk of overheating might occur in black boxes. We investigated whether roost temperatures exceeded 42°C, the upper limit of the thermoneutral zone in Little Brown Myotis (Myotis lucifugus), and whether replacing the black roof with a white one, akin to a sun hat, would alleviate the risk of overheating without compromising roost temperatures especially at night. We also investigated whether bats used the boxes. The internal temperature of black boxes exceeded 42°C on some days in 2 summers. Substituting the black roof with a white one consistently reduced the maximum daily roost temperature to below 42°C, but this was also accompanied by a slightly lower minimum roost temperature at night and a cooler roost temperature regime overall. The reduction in maximum daily roost temperature by the white roof was more pronounced on days with higher maximum daily ambient temperatures. At 5 sites with paired white-roof and black-roof boxes, 4 had bat use of both boxes and 1 had no use of either box. Bats used 10 of 19 (53%) black-roof boxes in 2019, and 16 of 21 (77%) in 2020. Replacing a black roof with a white one can mitigate risk of overheating for boxes in subarctic latitudes, and likely through a range of temperate latitudes. However, completely black boxes are still necessary to enhance the thermal environment for roosting bats through most of the summer. We suggest that providing bats with roosting options, such as paired black-roof and white-roof boxes immediately adjacent to one another, is a better habitat enhancement option than just single black boxes.