Open Access
1 March 2013 Repeated Predation of Meadow Fritillaries (Boloria bellona) by Ambush Bugs (Phymata spp.)
Joseph W. Dixon, Ryan D. Rasmussen
Author Affiliations +

The meadow fritillary (Boloria bellona Fabricius, 1775) is a common species of Nymphalidae found throughout Canada and the north-central and northeastern United States where it lives in open wetgrassy areas such as prairies, meadows, pastures and fields (Opler 1998; Brock & Kaufmann 2006; Schlicht et al. 2007). In the state of Iowa it is also known to inhabit fens (Schlicht et al. 2007), which are diverse open wetlands characterized by continuous surface to near surface saturation by groundwater, organic soil and nonemergent graminoid vegetation (Thompson et al. 1992; Amon et al. 2002). Nectar habits include many species of flowers, with a preference for members of the Asteraceae (Opler & Krizek 1984).

Ambush bugs (Phymata spp., Heteroptera: Phymatidae) are generalist sit-and-wait predators that feed on multiple species of florivorous insects, including members of the Nymphalidae (Balduf 1939). Preferred habitat is on vegetation in open areas with direct exposure to sunlight and wind (Balduf 1941). Seventeen species of Phymata are recognized in North America with a distribution that includes all of Canada and the eastern and southern United States (Arnett 2000).

On 8 July 2010 at approximately 2:30 p.m. Central Standard Time a group mortality of B. bellona was observed in a small (0.3 hectare) privately owned remnant fen in Muscatine County, Iowa, (41° 28′ 6.59″ N, 91° 3′ 11.44″ W). Six dead B. bellona were noted on the inflorescence of a common boneset plant (Eupatorium perfoliatum L.), whereas no other dead arthropods were observed. An ambush bug was then observed, partially exposed from the inflorescence of the common boneset, feeding on a recently captured seventh B. bellona. Closer inspection of the inflorescence revealed at least 3 ambush bugs concealed among the flowers. A more intrusive inspection of the inflorescence was not completed in order to limit disturbance of the Phymata, however no other predators were discovered.

Conditions at the time of observation were warm (30° C) and clear (0% cloud cover) with wind speeds of 13.0 kph (gentle breeze on the Beaufort Wind Scale). Although there was no direct evidence of predation by Phymata for the 6 dead B. bellona, the lack of other predatory species and their position on the inflorescence of the common boneset supported the conclusion that they were discarded Phymata prey. Balduf (1939) noted that under similar circumstances (i.e., warm sunny days with little to no wind) discarded Phymata prey were readily visible in the axils and flowers of plants used as ambush sites (i.e., ambush plants). Mortality was not observed for any other Lepidopteran species at the site.

A review of the literature found no published record of this phenomenon being described previously. Balduf (1939) found discarded remains of numerous species preyed on by Phymata on flowers, axils, and below ambush plants, but never described significant numbers of a single species. More recent unpublished data of Phymata predation on Lepidoptera as well have no records of group predation of a single species (David M. Wright, personal communication). An additional peculiarity of this observation was that pollinators typically avoid individual plants, specific species, and even entire patches as predation risk increases (Jones 2009), and the presence of Phymata specifically can deter flower visitation by nectivorous insects (Elliott & Elliott 1991, 1994). Despite the presence of other flowering Asteraceae in the fen (e.g., Helianthus grosseserratus M. Martens) no such avoidance by B. bellona was observed.

Also, the use of Eupatorium as an ambush plant by Phymata is infrequent (Balduf 1939; Punzalan et al. 2008). Balduf (1939) did not observe Phymata capturing any prey while utilizing Eupatorium. However, McAtee and Walton (1918) did observe Phymata successfully capturing flies (Diptera: Tabanidae) on Eupatorium and in Wisconsin Graenicher (1909) noted that E. perfoliatum was visited by as many as 113 different species, including both Phymata and B. bellona. This observation indicated that, contrary to previously published reports, Phymata utilized E. perfoliatum as an ambush plant quite effectively.

Although there is no direct evidence that the repeated mortality was the result of predation by Phymata, alternative hypotheses (e.g., disease, other predators, etc.) are unlikely. While only a single Phymata feeding on a B. bellona was observed, Phymata are not known to take dead insects as a food source (Balduf 1943), which would suggest that all of the dead B. bellona on the boneset were the result of Phymata predation since no other predators were present. Predation on Lepidoptera by ambush bugs is believed to be quite common (Fales 1976; Wright 1981); however, the literature is lacking on observations of such behavior (Pyle 1973; Wright 1981). The impact of predation on native populations of pollinators is crudely understood and regarded as a minor problem, though additional research is necessary to test this axiom (Kevan 1999). We concur with Wright (1981) and Kevan (1999) and suggest that additional observations of Lepidoptera predation by Phymata would aid in furthering the understanding of Lepidopteran and pollinator ecology.

Acknowledgements

We thank David M. Wright for his insight on Phymata predation on Lepidoptera.

Literature Cited

1.

J. P. Amon , C. A. Thompson , Q. J. Carpenter , & J. Miner . 2002. Temperate zone fens of the glaciated Midwestern USA. Wetlands 22:310–317. Google Scholar

2.

R. H. Arnett 2000. American insects: a handbook of the insects of America north of Mexico. CRC Press, Boca Raton. 1003 pp. Google Scholar

3.

W. V. Balduf 1939. Food habits of Phymata pennsylvanica americana Melin (Hemip.). Can. Entomol. 71:66–74. Google Scholar

4.

W. V. Balduf 1941. Life history of Phymata pennsylvanica americana Melin (Phymatidae, Hemiptera). Ann. Entomol. Soc. Am. 34:204–214. Google Scholar

5.

W. V. Balduf 1943. Third annotated list of Phymata prey records (Phymatidae, Hemiptera). Ohio J. Sci. 43:74–78. Google Scholar

6.

J. P. Brock & K. Kaufmann . 2006. Kaufmann field guide to butterflies of North America. Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, New York. 392 pp. Google Scholar

7.

N. B. Elliott & W. M. Elliott . 1991. Effect of an ambush predator, Phymata americana Melin, on behavior of insects visiting Daucus carota. Am. Midl. Nat. 126:198–202. Google Scholar

8.

N. B. Elliott & W. M. Elliott . 1994. Recognition and avoidance of the predator Phymata americanaMelin on Solidago odora Ait. by late seasonal floral visitors. Am. Midl. Nat. 13:378–380. Google Scholar

9.

J. H. Fales 1976. More records of butterflies as prey for ambush bugs (Heteroptera). J. Lepid. Soc. 30:147–149. Google Scholar

10.

S. Graenicher 1909. Wisconsin flowers and their pollination - Compositae, part I. Bull. Wis. Nat. Hist. Soc. 7:19–77. Google Scholar

11.

E. L. Jones 2009. Optimal foraging when predation risk increases with patch resources: an analysis of pollinators and ambush predators. Oikos 119:835–840. Google Scholar

12.

P. G. Kevan 1999. Pollinators as bioindicators of the state of the environment: species, activity and diversity. Agr. Ecosyst. Environ. 74:373–393. Google Scholar

13.

W. L. McAtee & W. R. Walton . 1918. District of Columbia Diptera: Tabanidae. P. Entomol. Soc. Wash. 20:188–206. Google Scholar

14.

P. A. Opler 1998. A field guide to eastern butterflies. Houghton Mifflin Company, New York. 486 pp. Google Scholar

15.

P. A. Opler & G. O. Krizek . 1984. Butterflies east of the Great Plains: an illustrated natural history. John Hopkins University Press, Baltimore. 294 pp. Google Scholar

16.

D. Punzalan , F. H. Rodd , & L. Rowe . 2008. Contemporary sexual selection on sexually dimorphic traits in the ambush bug Phymata americana. Behav. Ecol. 19:860–870. Google Scholar

17.

R. M. Pyle 1973. Boloria selene (Nymphalidae) ambushed by a true bug (Heteroptera). J. Lepid. Soc. 27:305–307. Google Scholar

18.

D. W. Schlicht , J. C. Downey , & J. C. Nekola . 2007. The butterflies of Iowa. University of Iowa Press, Iowa City. 233 pp. Google Scholar

19.

C. A. Thompson , E. A. Bettis , & R. G. Baker . 1992. Geology of Iowa fens. J. Iowa Acad. Sci. 99:53–59. Google Scholar

20.

D. M. Wright 1981. Historical and biological observations of Lepidoptera captured by ambush bugs (Hemiptera). J. Lepid. Soc. 35:120–123. Google Scholar
Joseph W. Dixon and Ryan D. Rasmussen "Repeated Predation of Meadow Fritillaries (Boloria bellona) by Ambush Bugs (Phymata spp.)," The Journal of the Lepidopterists' Society 67(1), 57-59, (1 March 2013). https://doi.org/10.18473/lepi.v67i1.a8
Received: 12 December 2012; Accepted: 5 July 2012; Published: 1 March 2013
KEYWORDS
Eupatorium perfoliatum
fen
Back to Top